Quick and dirty PH vs Melodrama poll. Which album do you like more?
strawpoll.com/yy6ew434Posted Jul 15, 2017, 7:16 AM UTC
Posted Jul 15, 2017, 7:16 AM UTC
See, I'm not sure I'll ever be able to compare them so plainly. They're both spectacular! But, for me at least, I feel like they're different albums I needed at different times in my life. Maybe I lucked out to be the same age as Lorde, but Melodrama speaks much more to how I feel about life right now than Pure Heroine does. Pure Heroine was there for me when I was a senior in high school, and now Melodrama is about to carry me through my senior year of college. And that just seems right to me.
tbh, I haven't voted myself yet because I can't pick one. I was just listening to her on Spotify and went from Melo to PH and was like shit, I love both of these albums so much. They are definitely very different albums. This poll isn't a fair vote on which is better.
I think I just witnessed the origin of world war 3.
I chose Melodrama but it is extremely close!
I think people have this misconception that PH is deeper than Melodrama because the lyrics are more obscure and mystical.... idk
Maybe some, but Pure Heroine does have stronger lyricism and storytelling. There is so much too each song in Pure Heroine and how they link together, beyond simple metaphors and references.
I can't decide at this stage. I've been listening to Pure Heroine for years. Right now I listen to Melodrama more, but I can't compare it to PH just yet.
Melodrama is just in general a more intelligent and creative record. After all, she had so much more time to make it unlike Pure Heroine, which was rushed
Although they're both amazing, I have to go with PH, bc the lyrics are more meaningful, but it's very close because in Melodrama she experiments with many more musical styles (I guess the minimalism is part of the charm of PH, though).
Melodrama just makes me a little more emotional so that's why I went with it. They are both so amazing tho.
Melodrama hasn't sat with me long enough yet, so Pure Heroine by default.
[deleted]
You guys have issues
But Melodrama doesn't have Ribs.
That's a very good point