surprise negative review from host - advice?

I (along with my aunt) used Airbnb for the first time last week, having booked a couple months in advance for two nights in a double room in an apartment. The host initially said that he wanted me to contact him the day we arrived in the city so that we could set up a check-in time that worked well with our arrival in the city, but I had a few concerns about this. We'd be driving into the city via rental car, so we didn't have a set arrival time like we would if we were coming in by plane, and since I was traveling internationally, my phone would not work - meaning that even if we found an internet cafe/solid wifi (not a guarantee), we'd have to camp out there waiting for him to reply and coordinate with us, which would be a lot of hassle and wasted time for us. I asked him if we could sort out the details before I left the US since it would still be less than a week before arriving at this place, and he didn't give any indication that that was a problem for him, but did say that in that case we'd need to default to the check-in time that was on the listing (6PM). I told him that was perfectly fine (I hadn't asked for anything earlier and hadn't been expecting it).

Check-in went smoothly with no issues that I was aware of, the room was fine, the host seemed nice, etc. We didn't interact with him a lot because he spent most of the day out and so did we, but I saw him a couple of times both evenings that we were there and then again the morning we left, and he didn't mention any problems at all. I was surprised, then, to find that he left us a negative guest review. It was nothing too awful, but he said that we were very hard to contact and communicate with, was annoyed that we had asked if we could make use of the second bed and have two keys to the apartment (i.e. one for each of us, because we'd be doing separate things during the day and might want to come back at different times), and suggested that Airbnb was not for us. I double-checked the back-and-forth messages we'd had via the Airbnb site/app, and I had no missed messages from him at all - every time he reached out, I replied to promptly, and vice versa. The key issue I can grant him, because I really have no idea what the standard is for Airbnb there - my aunt and I made plans for who would hold onto the key and where we would meet at the end of the day in case we only had the one, so we weren't relying on him saying we could each have one of our own and there was no expectation/pressure for him to say yes, but we figured there was no harm in asking. Maybe this was a faux-pas? The bed complaint, though, really confused me, as the room was clearly listed as a double room that had two beds (one proper bed and one sofa bed), and he was aware from the beginning that there would be two of us. I also told him in the first message that we were an aunt and a niece, so there wouldn't have been any confusion in terms of thinking we were a married couple or something.

I'm a little worried that my first and only guest review being a negative one will mean that no one will want to risk hosting me, should I decide to us Airbnb again. I'm also looking for a little bit of advice regarding some of this, though - hosts, is it generally very important for your guests to be in contact the day of their arrival, and should I avoid booking when I can't guarantee that? Would a negative review of this nature (especially if it's the only one on the profile) turn you off from hosting someone? Also, was it very rude to ask if there was a second key available if one wasn't given to us by default? I honestly didn't mean to overstep any boundaries there, but I'm wondering if I did accidentally. (It might also be worth mentioning that the aunt who I was traveling with means well, but is a very stereotypical blunt New Yorker, and she often comes off to me as pushy and rude; I'm worried that that might have contributed to things here. I'm really just guessing here, though, because I didn't see most of her interactions with the host and he didn't call us rude or pushy in his review.)

Posted Jul 16, 2017, 4:48 PM UTC · edited

429
Loading comments…