The main reason why I think Icons's gameplay reveal hasn't been all that well received
I really don't think it has anything to do with the quality of the visuals. The graphics look on par with what you'd see in the pre-alpha version of any game - they look and feel unfinished. That is totally normal. The game will keep looking better and better as the game gets developed, this is always how it goes.
The reason IMHO is that the recycled animations and character kits make Icons feel like a "clone game"... and what most people want is essentially "the next step" in platform fighter games. They don't want something that will replace Melee here - they want something that will be a viable alternative to Melee.
In other words, the dev team needs to do what Valve does - take an outdated game with interesting mechanics, implement features that make the game easier to get into than the original and that eases the matchmaking process, and then expand upon the original features by polishing them both visually and mechanically.
For instance, the wavedash mechanic. Most melee players are used to it, but even though I've played both Melee and PM a lot in the past, I personally have never really managed to master wavedashing (only being able to do it in short bursts) and I struggle against anyone that has. If the team wants Icons to be the next step in the evolution of Melee-style games, they need to make wavedashing not only easier to input, but also make it look much more visually appealing. It needs to be supported like an actual intended feature rather than be implemented in the same way that it was in Melee, i.e. sort of a "glitch" that accidentally ended up greatly increasing the game's depth. Wavedashing needs to have its own tutorial like air dodging (rather than be a "hidden trick"), and it needs to look like anybody can do it, but only good players can use it properly.
It's the same thing with the way that the characters are designed. People don't want a Marth clone - they want a character designed to appeal to Marth players. The character doesn't need to have the same combos as Marth, all it needs is a kit whose combos have a similar flow to Marth's. In other words, Zhurong needs to feel so unique that people would feel attached to her, not Marth.
Despite my criticisms, I personally look forward to this game. The visual style appeals to me and I certainly have been looking for a good F2P fighting game for a long time now, but I also understand why the first gameplay video hasn't been received all that well. I really think people want Icons to feel like it's its own thing.
I'd even go as far as saying that Icons needs to make Melee look and feel outdated.
Posted Jul 17, 2017, 3:07 PM UTC · edited
I love Marth, and I love Zhurong. I'm super hyped that she plays like Marth. I don't see a problem at all. Now I can play Marth in a game with hopefully solid netcode instead of dolphin netplay garbage.
That's honestly all I want. Dolphin netplay is a hassle, if this isn't it meets all the criteria I need. Also Marth is sick
They almost directly copy and pasted there. They should keep somethings similar to make the transition easier but change a lot overall.
I'm gonna be brutally honest. I'd rather they copy and paste the entire PM cast, balance them, and throw different skins on them with a proper training mode and solid matchmaking. That's a game I would love to play.
I want melee with different characters, same mechanics.
We obviously want different thing. As they dripfed information to us via vlogs and twitter, it was easy to see that we would have several melee clones. Those of us that were hyped about it are still hyped.
I agree buddy.