The main reason why I think Icons's gameplay reveal hasn't been all that well received

I really don't think it has anything to do with the quality of the visuals. The graphics look on par with what you'd see in the pre-alpha version of any game - they look and feel unfinished. That is totally normal. The game will keep looking better and better as the game gets developed, this is always how it goes.

The reason IMHO is that the recycled animations and character kits make Icons feel like a "clone game"... and what most people want is essentially "the next step" in platform fighter games. They don't want something that will replace Melee here - they want something that will be a viable alternative to Melee.

In other words, the dev team needs to do what Valve does - take an outdated game with interesting mechanics, implement features that make the game easier to get into than the original and that eases the matchmaking process, and then expand upon the original features by polishing them both visually and mechanically.

For instance, the wavedash mechanic. Most melee players are used to it, but even though I've played both Melee and PM a lot in the past, I personally have never really managed to master wavedashing (only being able to do it in short bursts) and I struggle against anyone that has. If the team wants Icons to be the next step in the evolution of Melee-style games, they need to make wavedashing not only easier to input, but also make it look much more visually appealing. It needs to be supported like an actual intended feature rather than be implemented in the same way that it was in Melee, i.e. sort of a "glitch" that accidentally ended up greatly increasing the game's depth. Wavedashing needs to have its own tutorial like air dodging (rather than be a "hidden trick"), and it needs to look like anybody can do it, but only good players can use it properly.

It's the same thing with the way that the characters are designed. People don't want a Marth clone - they want a character designed to appeal to Marth players. The character doesn't need to have the same combos as Marth, all it needs is a kit whose combos have a similar flow to Marth's. In other words, Zhurong needs to feel so unique that people would feel attached to her, not Marth.

Despite my criticisms, I personally look forward to this game. The visual style appeals to me and I certainly have been looking for a good F2P fighting game for a long time now, but I also understand why the first gameplay video hasn't been received all that well. I really think people want Icons to feel like it's its own thing.

I'd even go as far as saying that Icons needs to make Melee look and feel outdated.

Posted Jul 17, 2017, 3:07 PM UTC · edited

2141
EcksplisitZhurong's Husbando•

I love Marth, and I love Zhurong. I'm super hyped that she plays like Marth. I don't see a problem at all. Now I can play Marth in a game with hopefully solid netcode instead of dolphin netplay garbage.

9
ObsoletePixelPixel•

That's honestly all I want. Dolphin netplay is a hassle, if this isn't it meets all the criteria I need. Also Marth is sick

2
KrankdatsmashRaymer•

They almost directly copy and pasted there. They should keep somethings similar to make the transition easier but change a lot overall.

2
EcksplisitZhurong's Husbando•

I'm gonna be brutally honest. I'd rather they copy and paste the entire PM cast, balance them, and throw different skins on them with a proper training mode and solid matchmaking. That's a game I would love to play.

4
KrankdatsmashRaymer•

I want melee with different characters, same mechanics.

3
EcksplisitZhurong's Husbando•

We obviously want different thing. As they dripfed information to us via vlogs and twitter, it was easy to see that we would have several melee clones. Those of us that were hyped about it are still hyped.

1
BananaMarmeladeZhurong•

I agree buddy.

1
blabloblooZhurong•

I agree with your criticsm but looking at the threads it seems like people just don't know what a game being in pre-alpha means.

I'd say the clone moves and how pale and uncolorful it looks compared to the splash arts are good things to criticise.

8
thegreathobbyistAshani•

People know what pre-alpha means. They espeically know that any and all criticism that they can levy, should be levied now while the game is still in pre-alpha. Because they know that pre-alpha is a stage where any and everything is subject to change. This is the stage of development where the most can be done in terms of feedback, so they are presenting their feedback, no matter how harshly or eloquently they put it.

6
blabloblooZhurong•

I agree with harsh criticism being valid, but I don't think ineloquent is. What good is “looks like shit what a letdown" or "lul looks worse than a 15 year old game"?

5
SSBMPuffDaddy•

they need to make wavedashing not only easier to input

nah

6
Slick_Wylde•

Yeah they do, if they don't only want hardcore melee fans. If they're making this game only for hardcore melee fans, then that's totally fine, but the fact that they're making this f2p tells me they want more mass appeal. If that's true, then making techniques more streamlined is in their best interest. Now, they don't have to make everything super easy, because everybody likes some skill, but I didn't have a single friend (And I'm talking about people who played for like 5 hours almost every day) wanted to learn wavedashing. It wasn't fun, it was just necessary in high levels of play.

1
thegreathobbyistAshani•

I agree with most of this, Wavedashing should have an execution that doesn't limit the lifespan of competitive players because the input causes arthritis. And it should have it's own unique animation that's different from just a normal landing animation both for cool factor and for a clear visual so that an uninitiated audience can understand what they're seeing is a mechanic and not the game tweaking out.

I would also agree that characters like Zhurong need either a moveset overhaul or for their animations to be given more personality. I suggested as much when I saw how much Ashani's animation from her reveal looked like a 1:1 copy of Falcon Punch and sure enough, the team at Wavedash changed the animation to be more unique in the gameplay reveal trailer. So if Wavedash sees this post(and I'm sure they will), you know what to do.

2
KrankdatsmashRaymer•

You also dont want a game thats way too easy.

3
quickupvoteOP•

Easier wavedashing doesn't necessarily mean that the game would be easier. You still need to use the mechanic properly to even play on the same level as people who have been playing Melee for years. Assuming that the devs make a proper matchmaking system, experienced Melee players would probably end up playing together anyway, while everybody else, despite not being particularly good at it, won't feel like they're playing a slower version of the game (which is what it feels to play Melee when you can't wavedash consistently.)

1
BobBulbKidd•

Wavedashing does not cause arthritis, there are other much more complex inputs in Melee that cause hand pain, but I would not say wavedashing is one of them.

1
jomoo99•

Wavedashing isn't what's causing people arthritis. It's only 3 simple inputs.

1
Plain_•

Wave-dashing does not cause arthritis. It's 3 inputs spread across both hands.

1

Agreed on all counts.. they were way too loyal to the original melee animations, especially the ganon type char. moves could have very easily maintained similar frame data / properties from melee while still being visually different.

2
simpson409•

as far as i know they have a wavedash button, it's not like in melee. the timing isn't as tight and the inputs very simple.

2
quickupvoteOP•

That's pretty great if this is the case. That being said, I mostly used the wavedash as an example to show that it might be a good idea to improve/expand Melee's mechanics rather than keeping them completely identical. Easier wavedashing means a lower skill floor meaning a wider audience for the game, but it doesn't necessarily mean a lower skill ceiling since only the pros/long-time players really know how to utilize the mechanic properly.

1
MrMockRockXana•

I'm actually not sure you're right, the vast, VAST majority of negative comments I've seen are about how the game is ugly and sounds bad. Which are totally valid points, but also not particularly worrying considering the game's in pre-alpha. It wasn't a great marketing decision to release it when it's still this rough, though, even if people like me really enjoyed seeing it in action.

2
petcsonIcons•

Releasing pre-alpha footage at the most prestigious fighting tournament series was maybe not a great idea. Created a lot of hype but most of it was negative from what i saw.

What they should have done is show footage on a smaller stream or something like that and keep mentioning pre-alpha over and over again.

1
BobBulbKidd•

My main problem with it is the animations. A lot of them look kind of slow or rigid in some areas, and I'm hoping they will refine them a bit more before beta.

2
quickupvoteOP•

Well yeah, but Melee has a lot of rough animations too, especially when the game's played at the pro level. Wavedashing for instance looks super twitchy. This is why I'm saying the game needs to try and be better than Melee in terms of visual quality. They should make their animations look a lot smoother rather than copying Melee's animation style.

1
ZyxeosZyxeos•

Hi, Smash 4 player here. I never got into Melee because I felt it was a headache to have to learn to wavedash and always have to do it just to play the game at the regular level of everyone else, and otherwise be behind the curve! I personally DONT like having to wavedash. I hope that if they implement wavedash that it is mapped as a left bumper button...

Think about it.. In all Smash games we have L and R bumper as Shield, but why should that same functionality be added to two inputs? Since we'll have custom controls, the wavedash should just be another button mapped action! I love the concept of the wavedash, what it does for the character and movement.. It is a really interesting and fun mechanic to play with, so if we can somehow have it be more accessible, I'll be a lot more inclined to play Icons!

1
BobBulbKidd•

Leaving it as the effect of an air-dodge allows for so many more options. My tech skill is absolutely awful, but I can wavedash fine. Maybe they can just handle it the same way Rivals of Aether does, which makes it a lot easier without sacrificing much in terms of options.

1
Brsijraz•

Wavedashing is actually really easy, and even if you refuse to devote an hour or two to learning how to do it (I recommend Luigi) you can be fine with just dash dancing at a low level. Hell borp doesn't wavedash or dash dance and he does ok at Pitt locals. it's not a headache to learn difficult things for a lot of people, because for us learning things that aren't easy make them more rewarding. Smash 4 already exists as a platform fighter to bring people into the genre and be very easy, this game needs to depart from that.

1
ZyxeosZyxeos•

That's what I am saying I am hopeful that Icons will take some inspiration from Smash 4's simplification. Both games require as much skill. You can't tell me that Zero is less of a player than Armada.

1
Brsijraz•

I do think zero is less than armada. Melee has had 17 years of innovation, smash 4 had had what, 4? People who think the games are equal have absolutely no clue, you are entitled to you opinion, but as someone who has played both to a decent level, melee is absolutely the harder game, that's why zero was only ever a mediocre pm and melee player. He didn't have what it took in melee, but in smash 4 It's a lot easier.

1
InfinitySoulZhurong•

The different moves recyceled are iconic so I am happy they are in the game.

I wished I discovered it on game release, when I also have the 12 other and new moves the character has.

1
Ni_a_Palos•

I would have really liked to see character-specific revelation videos showcasing the moveset and archetype as a whole, kind of like how the PMDT showcased new characters. I feel this would have given people a wider look at each Icon and the recycled moves would have come off as a tribute to the original iteration.

4
PhloxofBirds•

What really jars me is the lack of hitstun. It really makes the moves feel weak, doesn't give that satisfying feeling of a strong move. I also agree with the movepool stuff. Another thing is the music, it feels generic. There's no memorable melody at all (I bet you can hum Smash songs easily, but try and hum this song from memory) and it just doesn't fit with the whole world.

Something that may be cool is if you were able to buffer your wavedash in jumpsquat, so that it gives more leniency on the inputs for a great wavedash but still has the basic motions of wavedashing (kinda like how button combos in SF are)

Also, something that's going to be REALLY interesting that I just now noticed is that ricochet projectile that gun character has

1
Brsijraz•

I disagree with dumbing down the game, firstly: wavedashing is really easy, and if you can't do it it's because you haven't tried that hard. Valve doesn't dumb games down, they refine them and make them more accessible. But I agree with you on many points. I for one thought the movement looked kind of janky. And removing l cancelling was a good move to make it accessible imo because that takes years to become second nature.

1
quickupvoteOP•

wavedashing is really easy, and if you can't do it it's because you haven't tried that hard.

I've heard that elitist opinion a lot throughout the years, and I don't agree with it at all. A lot of people can't do it, and not everyone can do it consistently. This is why there's such a huge skill gap between the people that are interested in Melee and those that are entirely dedicated to it.

they refine them and make them more accessible.

Which is exactly what a single-button wavedash option would do. Dota 1's heroes all had unique ability key setups meaning you had to learn ~110 key combinations just to be able to play every hero. When Valve made Dota 2, they added a default option that consolidated all those different key setups into one single key layout (eg. QWER+DF). That change didn't dumb down the game, it made it more accessible. Invoker players had to memorize 14 different keys in Dota 1 just to play their hero, but now in Dota 2 they only need to use 6. Invoker players didn't get better with that change, all it did was give more people the opportunity to play the hero.

2
Brsijraz•

It's not an elitist opinion, it is an opinion from someone who has actually put in a little bit of time and learned a tech skill in a game they enjoy. What I mean by really easy, isn't you should be able to learn it in 5 minutes, but that it doesn't take all that long to learn, maybe an afternoon. 14 keys on a keyboard is too much because that takes two hands and you need to also be controlling a mouse. On a controller all buttons are covered so it isn't a problem. If you want to learn how to wavedash, figure out what works for you, pick luigi (easiest and most fun wavedash) and then try different buttons, x + r, x + l . So on, for me I press x and r, the reason this is easiest (for me at least) is because both inputs will be on the same hand, once you figure out the timing you will never have a problem with it again. Promise

0
quickupvoteOP•

Why should people have to spend an entire afternoon to learn an essential mobility tool when it could easily be bound to one single button instead, without it affecting the skill ceiling of the game in any way?

1
Brsijraz•

People spend thousands of hours practicing essential things in other games, last hitting in dota, aiming in cs, even strafing in cs! An essential mobility tool. Hard for smash 4 players to wrap their heads around maybe but the time it takes to learn something makes it more rewarding when you do learn it, when you start getting crisp wavedashes after an hour of effort and you think "fuck yeah I'm a beast"

1
Krigeris•

But I do want a marth clone, smash ended at melee and was continued through PM, now it can be continued through this. Well start with what we're used too and branch out from there and build new characters on it.

1