Randomization
I was on the judge chat, but it was deemed not a judge question, so I'll post it here.
According to the rules, one's deck has to be randomized. "you cannot have a clue" as to the order of your deck. If you can identify any card in your deck, that is a dq.
However, obviously we have any clue as to the deck's order, because we have decklists. Therefore, I interpret the rules to mean that players shouldn't have any information above and beyond what can be derived from their decklist, such as distribution of lands.
In my experience, sometimes you get flooded, sometimes you get screwed. Confirmation bias is real. However, confirmation bias can be checked against reality through experimentation. If I repeat the procedure 100 times, 1000 times, 10000 times, I should approximate the theoretical distribution as I increase the number of iterations of the experiment.
The experiment: 20 forests (urza's saga) 20 aether herder (Aether revolt). Mash Shuffle 20 times. Riffle shuffle twenty times. Look at the top 8 cards of the deck. Count lands. Repeat. If I repeat this experiment 100 times, I should get roughly 400 lands and 400 nonlands. Obviously there will be variance, so the standard deviation of this would be sqrt(100) or 10. So if I draw 430 lands or 370 lands, that is still reasonable. I got 320 lands. :(
To examine a possible cause of this effect, a qualitative experiment was conducted where I intentionally shuffled the deck up-side-down, but still attempting to remain neutral to the result. As I shuffled the distribution appeared to get worse not better. If I only riffle shuffled 5 times, there were fewer lands on the bottom 20 cards, than if I riffled 10 times. This was only qualitative, and no absolute counts were made. Also, I could be sub-consciously altering the result or selectively-remembering the result, so this is obviously a biased experiment.
In conclusion: I am probably just a crazy person with too much time. However, the bending of newer cards is a well documented phenomenon. Is it possible that bent basics rise to the top? Is it possible that bent draft chaft rises to the top, if the lands are sufficiently older and not as warped.
I mention this because it impacts FNM draft. While sleeves are recommended, they are not required. Also, land stations at LGS have whatever lands. I've found Onslaught, Urza, Mirage lands in the land station. Should it be required that you bring basic lands from the same set as the draft? Should sleeving be required at FNM? Is this not even real, and I just got hit by the 1% monster and/or confirmation bias?
We've sorta had this issue before, Ice Age lands were identifiable, which had issues with Sinbad (among other things). The issue here is slightly different though, its not that the lands are identifiable when shuffled correctly, but that they don't match the expected distribution of lands.
My guess is that bent lands are "sticky". Not literally sticky, but when you are riffling, if two lands are already adjacent, you are more likely than not to leave them adjacent rather than split them. This would impact mash and riffle shuffling.
Would anyone care to replicate my experiment?
Good Day
Edit: Replication - slight variation, used 50 Amonkhet lands and 50 older cards (Torment Era) to make an "EDH deck". # of mash shuffles = 10 (no riffle shuffles, can be hard to riffle shuffle 100 cards relative to 60). # of cards drawn per iteration = 8. Expected number of lands = 200. SD = 7. Outcome = 158 lands - what would be expected from a 40-60 split, rather than the 50-50 split used. So sample size = 50 is small, but it still look 1/2 an hour to do that much, and it is still significant.
Edit 2: Replication 2- Used a more standard EDH distribution of lands - 40:60 rather than 50:50. # of shuffles and everything else the same. Got 144 lands. Sleeved the deck, repeated, got 162 lands. 144 lands is roughly 2 sigma, so not terribly rare, but not exactly encouraging, and getting 162 on the sleeved version means I can get normal amounts of land.
Posted Jul 17, 2017, 9:05 PM UTC · edited