Toronto isn't happy with resident built staircase costing $550, when they could have spent $150k
Posted Jul 21, 2017, 2:00 PM UTC
Posted Jul 21, 2017, 2:00 PM UTC
Unions HATE him!
[removed]
janky unsafe piece of shit
You can tell that from looking at the video.
But, it wouldn't have taken that much more casual labor and materials to build it to code and be a lot safer. It's when you get into structural engineering and architectural drawings that the price goes up dramatically.
He is acting like this is somehow less safe than having a bunch of 50 year old garden club members shambling down a gravel covered hill. Yeah it's not perfect, but its a hell of a lot better than it was
I think the problem is that it is an unsafe structure. While it might be better that shambling down a gravel covered hill now, is that going to be the case after a heavy rain or after a few months use? Or both. I think you could argue that it might be worse, i.e. it has the illusion of some kind of safety, when in fact it has none. A gravel covered hill is a gravel covered hill.
Then you have the question of liability, if it's allowed to remain does that mean the city tacitly agrees it is structurally sound, when it quite obviously isn't and who's responsible for maintenance?
I'm sure there's some LSC in there somewhere, probably related to the projected cost to do it "properly" and someone getting $100,000 profit to do it. But it's not in "grandpa built a death trap and the mean old city doesn't like it".
A structure that appears to be safe but actually isn't is actually way more dangerous than having nothing at all.
Hey folks. Remember to use the same lens to judge this step as you would one built to service a corporation. Standards exist to be a standard. He threw together a cheap ass set of stairs that'll be rotten and hazardous in a few seasons. It is correct that the stairs get ripped out. An un-groomed trail is safer, though less convenient.
[removed]
You aren't wrong, but it's still safer than having a bunch of old folks trying to climb down a gravel covered hill. My mother has snapped ligaments over less. Yeah this isn't perfect, but how long would it have taken the city to complete their fancy 150k staircase? Three to six months probably. This serves a purpose and it serves that purpose now. If the city builds a staircase that makes this one obsolete, then tear this one down, but until then, even a crappy staircase is better than none.
i fucking hate this city. they exhausted taxes and fund to useless shits, cut everything, then complained they can't build a fucking ~$500 staircase. now they want to remove it.
capitalism in action.
#Welcome to r/LateStageCapitalism
#Please remember that this subreddit is a SAFE SPACE for leftist discussion. Any Liberalism, capitalist apologia, or attempts to debate socialism will be met with an immediate ban. Take it to r/DebateCommunism.
Bigotry, ableism and hate speech will also be met with immediate bans; Socialism is an intrinsically inclusive system.
If you are new to socialism, please check out our socialism crash course here.
If you are curious to what our leftist terminology means, then please check out our glossary here.
In addition, here are some introductory links about socialism:
For an extended list of works, check out our wiki or this masterlist.
#☭☭☭
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
[deleted]
dirt washes away in weather
[deleted]
This is undoubtedly a fucked up situation, but I can't get over the fact this journalist is holding a fucking shotgun mic to these people's faces for this interview.
How messed up is our world when an old man is punished for his charity. He built the stairs for 500 dollars, I bet for 1000 dollars they could have been made safe. Way below the 65k estimate from the city.
Capitalism is an absolute fucking mess.
Odds are they'd have to be torn down and rebuilt from scratch to be up to local codes. There are undoubtedly regulations about riser length and height, foundations, supports, anchoring, railings, etc. that I doubt his staircase meets. Just looking at it in the video, there's no way having the risers mounted off-center on two very closely spaced supports that aren't even anchored to a foundation with no support on the ends is kosher; people stepping on the outside of the steps would quickly work them loose and eventually one would give without warning. Having the top landing narrower than the risers can't be up to code, either. No telling how the whole thing is anchored, either; it looks like it's just boards stuck in the dirt. It was a nice thought and good of the guy to try to help his neighbors, and it doesn't sound like he's being punished for building it other than the city telling him they're probably going to have to remove it, but the city can't just leave it there if it's not up to standards, or they'd be liable if someone were injured.
That said, $65k-$150k (even CAD) is a ridiculous estimate for building a small staircase. Obviously it's going to be more expensive than some guy buying lumber from Home Depot and paying a few homeless folks to help him build it, since there will be additional overhead and costs for surveying, engineering, and inspecting it, but for fuck's sake, you could build a good-sized house for the price the city is talking about. Someone is definitely getting their pockets lined in that deal.
[removed]
Im complaining about the response from the government in disregarding the old mans labour, and wouldve spend 65k on it instead.
I get that its may not be very sturdy, but in one fell swoop the old man deligitimized our neoliberal government... he needs to be celebrated.
[removed]
The government is capitalist... Antonio Gramsci sheds light on this with his theory of Passive Revolution. You do realize for profit companies are involved. We live in a world where the totality if everyday existence is capitalist. A world where just a day ago, it would have been perfectly fine for 65k dollars to have gone to for profit companies fo produce.
Of course capitalism is a mess in general, but how the fuck does it escape you in this particular example?
Dude. It's not even made with treated wood. Give it two Canada years and it'll be rotted through. Give it one spring and the steps will be slimed smooth with mold and water. It's not painted to protect it. It's not anchored.
If this step was built by a landlord, this sub would be screaming about how the landlord is cheap and willing to risk tenant injury to save some money. You know what happens if you break an ankle? You never fucking heal. Sure you get back on your feet, but you hurt for the rest of your life.
It's perfect today because it was built today. Tomorrow there will be footpaths around it because nobody wants to walk up a rickety broken down step. The next day there will be a post here complaining that the city left this rickety step up to save themselves money and now a reckless teen has a compound tib-fib fracture.
Give me a break.
They look pretty safe. I guess it would be better with a handrail on the other side, a handicap accessible ramp, and maybe non-slip treads for winter. But even with all that, and even if you made it out of really heavy duty materials, concrete and steel, it wouldn't have cost more than $3k with labor.
A quick search tells me that just the support piers need to be 6"x 6" set in concrete and 60" below grade. That's an Ontario wide code, to account for an 18" frost line. Once you take into account soil and land surveys, water flow tests mechanical engineering and architectural drawings, materials and labour. I doubt you'd be able to do it for less the $30,000.
Add in the Capitalist bit (not Late Stage particularly) , profit, and the low end of the estimate range looks about right. Which, of course, assumes that nothing nasty turns up in the initial surveys.
Where are you getting 30k from?
It's 30 square feet, and that's a generous estimate. I doubt land and soil surveys and water flow tests would cost more than $2k.
Materials were $500. If he expanded the support piers as he's supposed to, maybe $750-$1k. Labor $1k to be generous.
That's $5000 for materials, labor, soil and land surveys, and water flow tests - already 10x more than the stairs currently built, which look fine - but that's beside the point. So you're saying architectural drawings for a set of stairs are $25500.
Even if that was the case, a 50% profit margin on a construction product is LUDICROUS.
$10,000 in the end.
Link.
That's not a realistic estimate, considering you would need an engineer , a surveyor, and a whole crew of workers. 3k might be what the labour cost is a day
This is why im against big government.