Need help finding the right redirection plugin for Wordpress

So here's the deal. I have a client who uses the very popular "Redirection" plugin, which doesn't support wildcards (important for us b/c we have some jacked up URLs and paginated comments.) To solve the Wildcard problem, I've installed the Simple 301 Redirects plugin, to which I've added several hundred URLs, most of which include wildcards.

Buuut, this plugin has started acting wonky and causing issues. So I'd like to figure out what single plugin I can trust to support wildcards (for me) and still easy to use (for the client.) Any that you guys/gals have used that can make this happen for me?