r/uwaterloo•
a2xia

Car Sharing: Any pros and cons for these companies? (Community Carshare, Zipcar, Enterprise)

Question

I'm interested in joining a car share for occasional drives (i.e. probably <4 times a month), and a search on Google yields three companies: Community Carshare, Zipcar, and Enterprise. Has anyone here driven any of the aforementioned three companies and has any pros/cons to share?

Here's what I found on each company so far:

  • Community Carshare: $30 Application + $10 "Member Loan". No monthly fee, $12.50/hour+$0.25/km, but it's a flat rate per hour regardless of vehicle make.

  • Zipcar: No application fee, $20 annually. Starting at $7.75/hr M-Th, $11/hr F-Su. It seems that for students aged 18-20 the rates are starting at $9.75 and $13/hr.

  • Enterprise Carshare: $1 Application, $20 Annual Fee (first year waived), $6-$11.03/hour depending on vehicle. Availability looks sketchy? (There's only 4 cars on their map).

Anyone use either of those three or any other car sharing service before? Any recommendations? Availability? Any of them have larger SUV-style cars (suitable for say, carrying bags from airport or lots of groceries)?

Posted Jul 26, 2017, 12:20 PM UTC

013
x11onMac•

Just rent a car from a car rental agency and find a corporate code to waive the underage fee, much cheaper and you keep the car for a day

2
dshahr•

where do you find the corporate code? i'm 20 and I want to rent a car in Toronto but no one is waiving the fee.

3
thecavebreathes•

Some agencies will do a student discount that waives that.

As per RedFlagDeals, the Car and Driver corporate code is the best, but I don't think it waives the underage fee.

2
sj1124Sushi Joe•

There is so much information about this online:

https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/hertz-gold-plus-rewards/1406595-definitive-young-renters-thread-18-20-21-24-a.html

The university used to have a code that was open to anyone/everyone to use, but unfortunately it is only for University business use only now. :(

2
thecavebreathes•

Hertz on Weber applied a code that waives the underage fee, and provides discounted CDW through the university group rate.

You can also waive it by signing up for Hertz Gold, which gave me an even better rate than the CnD CDP

This was in March 2017, not sure if things have changed since then.

1
sj1124Sushi Joe•

The publicly available one was actually through National or Enterprise (don't remember), so maybe there is another code that is not advertised at all.

If you can retrieve the code in any way (eg. from your booking email) please share!

1
thecavebreathes•

I agree.. For the fall and winter terms. Rates tend to be quite a bit cheaper then, but they're usually quite a bit more expensive in the summer.

1
sj1124Sushi Joe•

If it's a corporate code that they don't qualify for (not the common ones like Car and Driver, but employees of xyz type corporate codes) then that's quite dangerous because paid insurance and/or credit card insurance will also be invalidated as well.

1
thecavebreathes•

Interesting.. signing up for Hertz Gold Seems to have given me better rates than the Car and Driver CDP

1
a2xiaOPthe program with depressed people•

Sorry for the late reply, but I should've put down in my main post that I'm only 19. All the car rental agency sites that I found, even with the waived underage fee, only rents to those 21 and above. Do you know of a rental agency that rents to 19 and aboves?

1
honhonhonFRFRJoJoke•

haha I had Student Carshare till I finished the paperwork for a car and they just went bust

They still have my $20 credit for letting me book a nonexistent car

2
thecavebreathes•

Realistically, the only $9.75/hr Zipcar has 3 different brands of Chinese tires on it and is beat to hell. All of their new cars start at $12 and go up to $12.75 on the weekends.

Community car share's cars are well maintained, but they are a bit more expensive.

Enterprise Car Share might be a bit cheaper since they're new to the region, but they're quite large in Toronto. Haven't used their service so can't comment on quality.

1
KUKU_CIVE•

I use Zipcar and is been alright so far. Only con I can think of is that their helpline sucks and price is a bit expensive (extra charge over 200km).

1