An earnest plea for help in making sense of advice about specialization
Over the last two years I've tried to solicit as much advice from career consultants as possible--including many on this subreddit, thank you--and I've always made sure to ask about 1) how early they recommend specializing, and then to further get their thoughts on weighing 2) the tradeoff between having wide experiences early on vs. specializing day one.
I've received lots of advice that appears conflicting at first, though I've come to see each piece of advice as true insofar as there's certainly merits to each particular perspective.
However, that doesn't help much when I'm wondering myself whether or not to specialize day 1 in the education sector, which I'm passionate about--I majored in education in college--or whether or not I should get broad experience and postpone specializing. I'm starting at a reputable firm in the fall.
I've also heard from chatting with people in ed consulting and ed PE that it's a highly specialized industry and that they look for specialization (e.g. PE education shops hiring TFA teachers)
Would anyone please help me make sense of the advice I've received?
The pieces of advice that seem to come most frequently include:
-
[Pro] The most successful people I know are also the people who specialized the earliest and carved out their niche
-
[Con] It's important to have diverse experience across industries; frequently seeing a similar problem from another angle for when you do specialize will be useful
-
[Pro] You will build networks early and have access to an additional and different, even if small, set of contacts than you would otherwise
-
[Con] It's important to make connections across industries even if you know where you want to specialize for myriad reasons since you don't just "live" in your industry so to speak
-
[Pro] If it's what you love, don't waste time getting to it. Just do what you love now
-
[Con, the con that I find most worrisome] You don't really know what you want, and you don't know what you want to do just because it's what you want to do now, wait until you've seen many different things
And so on and so forth. You get the gist. I'd really like help sorting through this advice since it's all "good" advice, but in aggregate doesn't really help me make up my mind about how I want to approach the first 2-3 years of my career, at least in the planning phase. I do realize that life is what happens when you're making plans but I'd appreciate some counsel nonetheless. What makes it tough for me is that education is something I think about constantly, lose sleep over, get heated about even just reading books, and care deeply about.
Thanks so much.
Posted Jul 27, 2017, 12:37 AM UTC · edited