r/AskUK•
fifefe

Is it just me or does HSBC online and telephone bank suck balls?

Half the time can't get a secure connection or telephone is overloaded, then the passwords go to fuck, and resetting them is a major ballache clusterfuck.

Never have any issues with Halifax or Coventry. So I don't think its me thats the problem.

EDIT: case in point, just phoned up, 35 seconds of nonsense before I can start trying to put in sort code etc for the automated service.

Posted Jul 31, 2017, 12:51 PM UTC · edited

5354
generic_brand_cola•

Want to hear the most Kafka-esque HSBC story?

My friend's credit card was stolen, but she had not paid the bill the month previous. She reported it stolen, and was told a new one would be issued.

She tried to pay her bill, but her online account had her old card number and a payment could not be made as it was declared stolen. As the card was in arrears, it could not be removed from the system.

She could not pay the bill any other way because HSBC had linked the old card to her account, and could not pay against the new card because it could not be activated as the account was in arrears.

She could not close down her online account and open a new one because her card arrears prevented this.

All this time, she accrued charges and interest on her unpaid credit card balance.

The automated debt systems kept escalating to collections, who were unable to take a payment because the card had now been declared stolen, but could not allocate against the new card because it was not active.

After around 6 months, they just wrote off the debt because there was no other way of fixing it.

38
Gryngolet•

Presumably your friend has checked already, but if not I'd definitely recommend that she checks her credit score and ensures that it hasn't been negatively impacted, regardless of whether the debt itself has been written off.

16
fifefeOP•

can easily believe that.

7
mas-sive•

I think you're on to something here.....

3
Mred12•

throws credit cards in the bin

1
Hefalumpa•

First Direct are excellent and they're part of HSBC. Can you move your account across?

12
jh89th•

agreed, First Direct are the best bank I've ever used.

4
MuchWittering•

Yep, my only criticism of First Direct is that last time there was an issue with my credit card they phoned me up to inform me, and tried to get me to do the security checks over the phone. That said, when I said I wasn't going to give them my details cos they could have been absolutely anybody, they were happy to give me their name and section so that I could call them back on the main number from another phone, and we sorted it out that way. This was a few years ago now, so maybe they've improved their security processes since then. But other than that one tiny niggle, the web and phone banking services have been the best I've had to deal with.

4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
ouchpouch•

HSBC retail really is just gloriously shambolic.

Their non-descript "skyscraper by river" mobile landing page is fairly well thought-out. Figuring out if it's meant to be New York, Singapore or Dubai is a handy distraction for the nine solid minutes it takes to load.

Their in-branch services are less inspiring. Particularly when the screen they're using is turned towards you. Getting over the initial shock of being suddenly thrown back to 1996, nothing more-reassuring than peering closer, and discovering you were born in Hong Kong.

I've never been to Hong Kong.

How actual telephone banking still exists is beyond me. I avoid it like the plague, although I can't bash their fraud prevention. They were right on the ball when some pikey tried to spend £300 at Nike online (although giving this fucker some credit, he did try and set me up with a Netflix subscription). Similarly, once my new debit card was issued, their fraud prevention team called me as I was trying to make an Amazon purchase. Either it happened to be a quiet time of day for them, or they really do have impressive manpower to be making calls as suspect transactions are happening.

9
CaptainDjango•

Oh yeah it fucking sucks. Can't wait for Monzo to finally launch their current accounts then I can leave HSBC for good.

8
SWEnglandAddick•

Same here. Monzo is great.

4
crownsandclay•

I've seen heaps of references to Monzo recently. Is it not just a pre-load card? What's so good about it?

3
SWEnglandAddick•

Yeah in essence it is just a pre-paid card. However the app sets it apart from traditional banks.

You get a notification instantly after every purchase. So you instantly know when your card has been used.

It displays your spending automatically into categories like ‘Groceries’ etc. So you can look back and see where all your money has gone and it helps with budgeting.

It also provides you with a location for every spend, very useful, especially if you don't recognise a transaction or just if you've had a heavy night out lol.

You can instantly freeze the card using the app so if you do lose it or it gets stolen all you have to do is press a button. If you then find you card again you just need to tap that button and it will be unfrozen.

You can split bills. When I go out for dinner with my GF one of us will pay using Monzo and then you can click on the transaction and split it 50/50 with another Monzo user.

It's great for travelling as you do not get charged fees for using your card abroad. They also use an up to date exchange rate taken from MasterCard I believe.

Most of the things I've listed are so simple but the traditional banks are way behind on them.

Monzo will be releasing a current account soon so that'll be good.

You have to get on a waiting list to get the card but that only takes about a week, or you could ask someone nicely (like me) as I have a golden ticket to bump someone to the front of the queue.

9
Mred12•

You can split bills. When I go out for dinner with my GF one of us will pay using Monzo and then you can click on the transaction and split it 50/50 with another Monzo user.

I didn't know about that one, fuck me that's handy. Thankfully my Monzo is coming in the next day or so.

... If only the cards weren't so fucking ugly.

1
crownsandclay•

Ooh that does sound good. I've been meaning to get more on top of where my money's going but it's such a hassle to do it though my internet banking. I'll send you a pm about that golden ticket

1
jimofwales•

I love the ease of sending people money on Monzo. When a bunch of us are out it's so easy to wire each other money for food and stuff.

1
essjay2009•

Just so you’re aware, if you’ve got an AMEX card and an iPhone you can add it to passbook and it will give you instant notifications of spend on the card. And that’s all spend, not just ApplePay spend. You can also get your balance instantly in PassBook. Everything else seems antiquated once you’ve had instant access to all that information.

1
Gisschace•

Tide looks like a good alternative for business banking too (mine is currently with HSBC). As soon as Tide integrates with Freeagent I am moving

1

Haven't their accounts launched already on a slow rollout?

1
CaptainDjango•

Yeah they're getting there. I think they had their first rollout event last week and they're having a few more this week for a few users. I was invited as an early adopter but couldn't make it to London on such a short notice (I live in West Wales)

5

ah that sucks man, I just got it the other week myself and can't wait for it to roll out. Shame their android app is a bit behind at the moment though

3
Sabrielle24•

They've got invites out for a handful of people now, so I imagine it's in beta testing.

1
bokster•

Look at N26. Good as Monzo, but free.

-5
CaptainDjango•

Monzo is free though?

3
bokster•

Ok, last time I checked they had a monthly fee -- I might have been mistaken, though.

I'm using N26 which is an actual bank, you get an actual bank account and you can do IBAN/SEPA transfers normally.

2
KingBooScaresYou•

I find their online and mobile and telephone systems perfectly alright. Never had a problem before and whenever I have they've gone over and above to fix it

8
BadgersOnStilts•

It is not just you. I've been meaning to change banks for so many years now.

I can play the HSBC hold music on the piano after hearing it on repeat 10000 times. I'm great at parties.

6
fifefeOP•

omg, the music. just worked it out - that's what i can hear in my nightmares!

2
devlifedotnet•

HSBC online banking is excellent imo.... not sure about telephone banking because I never use it, mainly because the app and web based online banking is so easy.

6
whencanistop•

I have HSBC and Santander accounts. My other half loves Santander, but I prefer the HSBC one.

I never have any connection issues online. The only real ballache is that they insist on having different verification systems online and on the phone and given how infrequently I use the phone banking. The key card annoyed me to start with, but I've got used to it now and it is much more secure than the texting system Santander uses.

5
fifefeOP•

The key card annoyed

they forced me over to the smartphone app. makes me want the keycard back. i'd happy carry that little bastard about over the app

4
essjay2009•

Also be aware that if you change your phone and install the app on your new phone, it won’t work anymore. I was locked out of my account for weeks a couple of years ago because of that. If I change my phone I have to remember to keep the old one until the new one is set up so I can port the account across. It seems like something that would happen fairly frequently but when you call them they seem completely unprepared for it.

3
fifefeOP•

oh god, thats probably the exact cause of all this nonsense.

i'm locked out and the recovery doesn't work as it should.

thanks for the tip

1
outline01•

I hated HSBC's online services, but over the past few years they've massively improved though.

Not a clue on the phone front, I never ring up for anything.

3
Timothy_Claypole•

HSBC phone banking may suck balls but their subsidiary First Direct get good reviews generally.

However if you hate HSBC for money laundering then you are still supporting them.

3
fromwithin•

All banks have their faults, but I've been with Natwest for 28 years and they've always been very good. The app is easy to use, supports all of the major functionality, and you can use it to get money from cash machines without a card. I've never had any problem logging in and I've never seen it go down. They also have a good fraud service where they phone up and check with you when weird transactions occur.

3
ieya404•

Curiously enough, First Direct's an HSBC subsidiary and is bloody superb on the phone - answered by a human being in the UK who's actually empowered to help. No fannying with menus.

3
twovectors•

Yup - No reason to be with HSBC if you can be with first direct IMO

2
TheDrCK•

Tried to sort a mortgage through HSBC recently. Not worth the hassle. Their online banking system is something from The Stone Age, from resetting information I'd entered on previous days, to posting me four copies of my login confirmation, to changing the amount I could borrow multiple times along the process. Try to call them to progress things over the phone, only to have no one pick up after half an hour of jingles. Gave up in the end and went elsewhere through a broker.

2
fifefeOP•

sounds the same experience for any interaction.

1

The digital secure key hurts my soul 🙃

2
Carphead•

You want to try M&S Bank. Which is an HSBC partner. Now that really sucks. We lasted a month with them after the co-op wouldn't upgrade our account. Ended up with TSB who have been everything the Co-op weren't.

M&S have a terrible website and an app you can't so anything with.

I used to like First Direct until they closed all my accounts after I went over my credit card with them went over the limit by £5 when I was travelling for six months and they had cancelled my direct debit (from their account). Didn't bother calling me until the day they did it and wouldn't let me sort it out.

2
cragglerock93•

The M&S Bank call centre staff in Manila are the friendliest people in the world though - I used to speak to them at work about ten times a day.

2
Carphead•

Oh yes first class but I don't want to call them to pay the window cleaner or milk man.

1
cragglerock93•

I'm just going to take this opportunity to be a shill and say that the Bank of Scotland (owned by Lloyds) are really good both online and on the phone - I've never been let down by them.

2
Big_Chief_Wah_Wah•

I rang up having forgot my telephone banking code. Answered the security questions and did what I needed then the helpful fella mentioned he could put me through to a voice recognition security thing so I would never have to remember my telephone banking code again!

Sounded great, until he put me through and the first thing the voice recognition setup asked for was....my telephone banking code.

2

I primarily use their Internet banking now. Love the keycard. However I find that the log-on page or even the entire website doesn't even load on first try most of the time. I used to have the Internet banking page bookmarked for ease of access but it just times out no matter how many times I try to update the link. So I have to Google HSBC and click on that and half the time that will time out so I close the window, Google HSBC again and this time it works. I've tried all the obvious stuff like clearing history/cookies.

It's such a specifically weird issue but more irritating than a genuine hindrance.

2
ASpoonfulOfMarmite•

All UK bank online systems/apps look like something straight from 15 years ago. I also wonder how it even became a norm not to have instant text alerts on every expense with your card, it seems like none of UK banks have it. HSBC is no exception, although I never had any actual service issue with them. Their IT just feels outdated.

2
TheBigJV•

Yep, they do suck balls, very useful in my local branch though! Sorted everything out for me in 30 mins.

2