Message from Rojava apoists to western anarchists: the anarchist movement is failing because it's divorced itself from society, disorganized and undisciplined. It's not a revolutionary movement right now

For how many years have anarchists been making vegan cafes, bicycle repair shops and squat cinemas. Where has it gotten the anarchist movement? Maybe it is time to try something new.

Ocalan says that the failure of the anarchist movement is that:

  • The movement has failed to institutionalize the spreading of its ideology, that in the end it ended up becoming a commodity for capitalism unable to understand how to challenge capitalist modernity.
  • The ideology is divorced from historical analysis and a moral system that can form a movement based around positive values. It's always reacting against something negative, one step behind the thing it opposes instead of forming its own values, and forging its own path forwards.
  • The analysis of what the state is as some abstract organization that will be abolished is unrealistic (given we live in an international system of states) and not useful. Democratic Confederalism gives a much deeper analysis of what is the state, the origin of hierarchy used to construct the system of the state, and the origins of the state in the emergence of civilization.

Now the new right in the west is emerging as a politically potent force that is becoming well funded, well organized, highly ideological and philosophical and getting into political power. Anarchist movements by contrast have degenerated into lifestyle politics where people dress and look like anarchists but there is no political consciousness, no elevated human beings (lots of drugs and degeneracy), and no coherency in their beliefs. It's a movement which lacks the power to shape the world.

Instead everybody is confusing process with content. Doing a big protest with lots of mass of people is seen as successful rather than having small coherent disciplined groups of people with dedication and direction, going towards a vision.

Unless big things change in anarchist movements, it will be the new right that ascends to power and the anarchist movement is going to dissipate.

People need to start studying apoist ideology (you don't have to believe all of it, but at least make the effort to understand and critique it), and building revolutionary organizations with discipline and organization. Anarchism is not how we dress or eating food from the bins, it is an ideology that we work to spread.

To make a revolution will take blood & hard work. It will not be fun or exciting but based off of struggle and sacrifice. Most people will be too weak to dedicate themselves to something higher and filled with purpose which is why only a small few will be the ones who make history. We have to work to push ourselves to reach our full potentiality as human beings and become the best examples and representatives of humanity. Physically fit, intellectually enlightened, spiritual, dedicated, active and hard working, subsuming our egos to our sense of the divine, our destiny and writing history.

Start from here:

https://www.reddit.com/r/rojava/comments/6q2ogl/if_you_want_to_understand_rojava_start_studying/

Don't believe me? Compare this anarchist song from the 30s with this modern anarchist song. If you want to understand how modern anarchism (challenge everything! don't tell me what to do! I'm a free individual!) has become an ideological commodity for capitalism, read Baudrillard's Agony of Power.

People will not spontaneously learn ideology through random reading of Facebook memes. It will be in classrooms where there is a teacher. Revolutionary groups get up early everyday and work hard. They do not do drugs, make rave parties or lose themselves looking for a fight (we fight but when it is tactical towards strategic goals). We are well rounded human beings ready to go where we are needed, ready to fulfill whichever role we are called upon.

Many people who call themselves anarchist are actually liberals in disguise reading Noam Chomsky (another liberal) with confused contradictory ideas doing it to be part of a social group. But beyond the shell there is nothing inside, just empty rhetoric and funny slogans or logos and ineffectual random action with no purpose or direction in mind.

Posted Aug 13, 2017, 12:44 PM UTC · edited

17297
Loading comments…