TheWorldTreeWithers/r/Communalists•

North American anarchism, and leftism generally, is a complete mess. It's been utterly recuperated and defanged. I'm hoping that the response in light of the surge in far-right organising, is that the left starts to take ideology seriously again.

19
SirBoogie90•

I completely agree with all of this however these are all criticisms Bookchin gave decades ago.

That being said, as this post is being debated in many areas online now. Whos having their revolution, so far, fairly successfully right now?

The anarchists in Europe and the US? Or the people in Rojava?

Democratic Confederalist ideas are the future of the left, they are new, they have learnt many lessons from the past and it moves forward. Its time to organise.

My only critique thus far is the personality cult clearly forming their around Ocalan, which in his own writings he said should not happen around any individual. I dont want their ideology to stagnate like the USSR state did around looking towards the past regarding Marxism, Leninism.

7
TsundereHaku•

Boosh.

5
mshelikoff•

I'm not an anarchist or a revolutionary—at least not for where I live—so perhaps the message wasn't meant for me, but I've met a few people in the US who call themselves anarchists and revolutionaries in recent months, so I'm responding while thinking about them.

1) Useless rhetoric:

Regardless of the motive behind the words, trite and facile dicta online like

Most people will be too weak...only a small few will be the ones who make history...work harder...sacrifice more...subsume your egos to a sense of the divine

will remind many of horrible movements now and through history that have misled the weak-minded. If the goal of those words was to create stronger bonds of comradeship among true-believers in your small group then I hope that goal was realized because it's difficult to imagine anything else useful being achieved from such rhetoric online in 2017.

2) Revisiting old disputes:

I think many criticisms of western anarchists seem to have traveled from some Bookchin disputes in the 1990s through Ocalan to this reddit post. A Wikipedia summary of the Bookchin/Black dispute is here.. Maybe it's all still relevant today. I don't know.

3) Why US anarchists aren’t organized:

My view is that Huxleyan over-organization is the primary—and perhaps the only—systemic enemy to individuals and communities reaching their potential in much of the US today. I think anarchists in the US are disorganized because opposition to over-organization is their primary—and perhaps their only—source of unity. In Syria, opposition to many horrors serves to unite people in revolution.

4) Over/under-organization:

"Capitalist modernity" seems to me to be a symptom where the root cause is over-organization for the sake of economic efficiency. Complex language and different government and economic systems are all fairly recent evolutionary developments, but the balance between over-organization and under-organization is found in a huge number of biological systems and social systems throughout the animal kingdom. That balance predates humanity by hundreds of millions of years. An Apoist might view this biological analysis as flawed because it's materialist and positivist. I'm not an Apoist.

5) Purpose of education:

My view is that the west—and increasingly, the remainder of the world—educate young people primarily for the purpose of increasing economic efficiency. We've become an over-organized society because students are rarely educated for other purposes such as self-actualization, improving relationships, and increasing civic responsibility. These are motives to educate that can create an opposing force to over-organization in the future. I don’t think it’s a coincidence that so many administrators and officials in North Syria are educators.

6) What I think US leftists should do:

Contact your representative about issues, try to make common cause with progressives and conservatives when possible, become part of your local community, talk about what you believe, run for the school board, argue for power to return to local neighborhoods from the state and federal government, draft state constitutional amendments for proportional representation voting systems and then for direct democratic New-England-town-hall style government systems, don’t get bored or distracted. Back to Huxley from 1958:

In their propaganda today's dictators rely for the most part on repetition, suppression and rationalization -- the repetition of catchwords which they wish to be accepted as true, the suppression of facts which they wish to be ignored, the arousal and rationalization of passions which may be used in the interests of the Party or the State. As the art and science of manipulation come to be better understood, the dictators of the future will doubtless learn to combine these techniques with the non-stop distractions which, in the West, are now threatening to drown in a sea of irrelevance the rational propaganda essential to the maintenance of individual liberty and the survival of democratic institutions.

4
Ereraveth•

What I think US leftists should do:

How is supporting the state going to help abolish the state?

4
SirBoogie90•

Because Anarchists not taking part in anything doesnt help anyone. Yes, supporting a genuine social democratic local politician isnt revolution, but if it helps the community and puts people in a better position to further organise, its something worth organising around. To then network and build relationships with the community, educate them and then take it further.

6
Ereraveth•

I agree direct action is important, just that trying to 'contact your representatives' and work within the system is pointless if you want to eradicate that system. I like the framework I read in the communalismpamphlet.net about creating local democratic councils and slowly seizing power for the people, personally.

2
SirBoogie90•

This is of course, what i am all about. But if you read Bookchins works or even if his biography, youll see regarding trying projects like that, anarchists often refused to participate on that also.

1
mshelikoff•

What do you mean by "state" when you write "abolish the state"?

Bookchin defined the state as a "professional apparatus of people who are set aside to manage society, to preempt the control of society from the people." With that definition, I think the path to abolish the state in the US is for people outside that professional apparatus to engage with it in order to replace it with something closer to a self-management of society. My view is that the means exist in the current US system with one or two constitutional amendments for that change to take place with considerable time, effort, and Huxleyan rational propaganda.

I think a different definition of the state can lead to silly arguments about what exactly you're trying to abolish.

2
RojavaPlanOPRojava Plan•

Page 193 Ocalan's Manifesto for Democratic Civilization part 2:

state is the sum of surplus product and value together with ideological tools, instruments of coercion, and the art of administration.

This is represented by the neolithic archetypes of the shaman, military man, and elder who conspired against the council of mothers.

3
mshelikoff•

Ocalan and Bookchin seem to be writing nearly the same thing in their definitions. Sometimes, one addresses causes and the other effects, and they're writing different words because they're addressing different audiences. Ocalan is most likely using Marxist terms because he was to a significant extent pushing his readers to follow him from Marxism to democratic confederalism. Bookchin wouldn't use that language. He'd abandoned Marxism decades before and his readers were likely to have never adopted any Marxist ideology.

Bookchin's professional apparatus of people who are set aside is supplied by Ocalan's (Marxist) surplus product and value.

Bookchin's to manage society corresponds to Ocalan's art of administration.

Bookchin's to preempt the control of society from the people results from Ocalan's ideological tools, instruments of coercion.

I think Ocalan's views about women and feminism reflect a gender essentialism that is difficult for me as a Westerner to follow. I can understand the meaning and context of what he writes from other sources, and I can even recommend sources to other people to help them understand it. But as an ideology, feminism that hearkens back to the neolithic era will always be foreign and obscure to me.

3
meforitself•

Contact your representative about issues, try to make common cause with progressives and conservatives when possible

Lmao

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
meforitself•

That is the last thing I want.

0
TotesMessenger•

I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:

^(If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads.) ^(Info ^/ ^Contact)

1
GrassrootsEmpire•

Hey u/Rojavaplan, I'm intrigued about the idea of revolution being the institutionalization of an ideology, and that by that logic, we should learn from the spread of major religions. Where can I learn more about treating your ideology like a religion?

1
mshelikoff•

Haytham Manna briefly discusses religion in his book on Ocalanism in the context of East and West. The book (which generally shows critical support of Ocalanism) is still available in English for free at http://sihr.net/en/ocalanism-ideological-construction-and-practice/ . Manna was the first co-chair of the Syrian Democratic Council, of equal status (at least on paper) to Ilham Ahmed as the head of the political wing of the SDF from Dec 2015 to March 2016. This is from his "Personality Cult" chapter (page 51-60):

There is a systemic problem in Ocalan's writings related, in the Eastern subconscious, to the "true religion" and the "saviour" solution....the creation of "the leader" within the Eastern faiths and tradition is more established than generating critical thought.

What Manna doesn't mention is that, even if the Western subconscious is more likely to reject leader/savior solutions, critical thought solutions still often have the outcome of treating ideology like a religion.

The French Revolution's Cult of the Supreme Being and Cult of Reason are two commonly used examples of treating an ideology like a religion in the West. A more recent example related to power struggles where I live are changing views and increasingly polarized views in the US about the ideology behind the American Civil Religion.

Anyway, back to the main point about about Western anarchism and Ocalanism, I think both would claim (with some justification in my view) that devotion to the nation-state is treating an ideology like a religion that's enshrined in international law. Perhaps you should also learn more about that?

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-1†
shovelfight•

While constructive criticism is a good thing, our movement is in shock and mourning. One day after 19 injured and one martyred by fascists is not the most appropriate time for critique. We need solidarity, as exemplified by the YJS here:

http://theregion.org/article/11203-exclusive-yazidi-female-fighters-on-charlottesville-unite-against-fascism

-1