CMV: Most disagreements are caused by unclear language.

[∆(s) from OP]

Here, and elsewhere there are disagreements on many topics. I propose that most of the larger disagreements are due to someone using a word, and the listener holding an entirely different view on what that word means.

Some common examples:

Gender - Gender has at least 2 very different definitions. Gender can be a social construct or it can be an individual construct. Gender can be something that society dictates to you, or it can be something which you discover about yourself. Most of the arguments around gender are due to one side arguing one case, and the other side arguing the other case, and both sides not realizing they are arguing past each other.

Ought - on the one hand, ought is a simple word used to describe a duty. However, ought is a poorly defined word, in the sense that morality itself is such a fractured and diverse topic. There is utilitarianism, kantianism, virtue ethics, care ethics, theological ethics, political rights, etc. While their can be agreement within a moral framework, most arguments about "oughts" or "shoulds" boils down to the two positions grounding their ought statements in different moral systems.

Racist - is a racist someone who discriminates based on race or is a racist someone who supports the current social/racial order. Is an African-American male who uses a racial slur about Chinese persons a racist? Is a white person who believes in individual merit a racist? Given the differences in definitions, it is easy to see why Right-wing folks constantly complain they are unfairly called racists, yet at the same time, left-wing folks feel correct when they use the term.

So, I acknowledge that many smaller disagreements can be due to different view-points or different expectations. If I want pasta and you want pizza we can have a disagreement. If board member A thinks the market will go up, but board member B thinks the market will go down, they can have a disagreement. But when it comes down to the big things - race, gender, abortion, religion, politics - most disagreements actually boil down to the two camps using the same word to mean two totally different things.

How to CMV - demonstrate that at least 1 of the major arguments of our day is due to an earnest disagreement, and cannot be boiled down to a simple "this word has two definitions and each side is using a different definition, hence they disagree."


This is a footnote from the CMV moderators. We'd like to remind you of a couple of things. Firstly, please read through our rules. If you see a comment that has broken one, it is more effective to report it than downvote it. Speaking of which, downvotes don't change views**! Any questions or concerns? Feel free to message us. Happy CMVing!

Posted Aug 14, 2017, 5:57 PM UTC

1235
Loading comments…