What is the game you wish you can play for the first time again and experience it brand new?

Eternal Darkness has always been one of my favorite games. I have always wished to see a reboot but I fear it would not hold up. I remember playing it and just being amazed, and even frightened a little, while playing it. The cool insane effects were totally new and I had no clue what was going on. It was an amazing feeling that I never got from a game and haven't really since then.