AMDGPU pro vs AMDGPU (OSS) in Saints Row 3

I'm noticing really terrible performance (<50 fps) using AMDGPU pro 17.30 (and the previous versions 17.10 and 16.40) on Ubuntu 16.04.2 (Kernel 4.8), yet when I use AMDGPU on Kernel 4.10 and 4.11 I'm getting 90-100fps. This is on an RX 480. Is anyone else experiencing this?

Posted Aug 15, 2017, 1:46 AM UTC

1021
TingPing•

The proprietary OpenGL driver is generally considered worse so that is logical. The only advantage it has is support for compatibility profiles for old CAD software (and a few awful games).

7
k4os77•

and a few awful games

Hello Dying Light and Divinity: Original Sin...

5
Frogging101•

Dying Light works on Mesa now.

The compatibility profile wasn't the problem; there was an unrelated problem with its vertex shaders. A workaround has been implemented in Mesa git and will be in the 17.2 release. I believe it still needs MESA_GL_VERSION_OVERRIDE=4.5 MESA_GLSL_VERSION_OVERRIDE=450, however.

3
k4os77•

Tested. And it works now. Even better than expected.

But the point was that Mesa devs found a workaround, the game didn't fix it.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
TingPing•

IIRC there are workarounds for D:OS at least.

1
salsadoom•

The DOSEE hack doesn't work perfectly though, things like blood show up as large red squares (no big deal) but pressing alt to highlight nearby objects doesn't work and that's almost game breaking.

1
breell•

I press 'X' and it works.

No idea why it's not alt though.

2
hellslingerOP•

Good to know. I've noticed that WebGL acceleration in Chrome has problems and artifacts with the open source driver, and they worked just fine with pro. Not a big deal.

DOOM 2016 also works just fine in Wine >2.0 with the pro driver, and doesn't work at all with the open source driver (unless using the bcrypt fork and vulkan).

1
SciencePhysicist•

Doom 2016 works fine with the mesa RADV vulkan driver, just set "+r_renderapi 1" as your launch paramenter to start in Vulkan mode

3
imaginary_username•

Pretty sure you need to be on mesa-git until 17.2 is released as stable though. Last time I tried 17.1.5 doesn't work whether you have OpenGL or Vulkan.

1
imaginary_username•

Pretty sure you need to be on mesa-git until 17.2 is released as stable though. Last time I tried 17.1.5 doesn't work whether you have OpenGL or Vulkan.

1
SciencePhysicist•

The fix for it was backported into 17.1.4 I think

1
hellslingerOP•

What distro are you using? I switched back to Ubuntu LTS to use the pro driver, installed the wine staging ppa, apparently have all the right mesa versions, but doom vulkan still doesn't work for me. It worked without any problems in Arch.

1
SciencePhysicist•

It should work under the pro driver for both opengl and vulkan. For mesa you either need 17.2 or 17.1.5 has the fix back ported, you can also use mesa-git.

I use fedora 26 with dc patched kernel and mesa-git

2
SapientPotato•

WebGL acceleration in Chrome has problems and artifacts with the open source driver

Huh, I just tried WebGL on an old APU with the open drivers and it was quite fine. I was however using the radeon driver, not AMDGPU as that isn't supported, and I was also using Firefox. Maybe you could try it on Firefox to see if it happens there as well.

2
hellslingerOP•

Interesting. I'm not sure if I can use radeon with the RX 480, but I'll give it a try.

1
SapientPotato•

I think that doesn't work. The newer ones require AMDGPU. Also, I only tried the HexGL thing, though it is a pretty good test.

1
swick_•

doom somehow requests a compatibility context so all mesa drivers will fail. I'm not sure if they actually need the compat context. They probably didnt even notice or care about it because on windows all gl drivers support compat. Might be possible to pretend to have a compat context to get it to work.

0
SapientPotato•

Why do said awful games have to do that specially if it ends up breaking support for new hardware just so that some obscure/ancient chip can run it ? Anyway, isn't multiple code paths a thing?

1
TingPing•

Probably done out of ignorance, every OpenGL implementation for consumer GPUs supports it except Mesa.

1