Shaving cream/aftershave recommendations?

I've been wet shaving for about a month now, and wanted to get into some of the more artisan soaps and aftershaves, but after trying a few B&M and Fine samples, most of them are too strong/musky. Does anyone know of some scents that are more clean/fresh instead of masculine and musky? Thanks!

If it helps, some of the colognes I wear and enjoy are Channel Bleu, Aqua di Gio, Lacoste Noir, Mont Blanc Legend, and Gucci Guilty Black.

Edit: I'm definitely going to try out a bunch of samples from Maggards once I get through the samples I have now. Thanks for the suggestions!