ELI5: How did scientists realize that they've discovered a new pure element rather than a compound, before the invention of electron microscope?

Chemistry

For instance, how did Marie Curie realize that the new substances she found - radium and polonium - were actually pure elements, rather than compounds? When Michael Faraday liquified oxygen, did he realize that it was an element? How and when did people realize that "liquified nitrogen" was of different nature than "liquified air"?

Posted Aug 19, 2017, 8:50 PM UTC

153
ZevVeli•

Essentially when they reduced a compound down to the point where they could not separate it any more, they were almost completely sure that they had created a new element. Tests on the new element to determine reactivity with known elements were performed in order to try and determine the molecular weight in order to see if the properties measure matched up with the prediction of location in the Mendeleevean Periodic table. This lead to some issues, for example, it was believed that one compound was actually an element called "Didimuim" and the properties and weight were hotly debated among the chemical community with six proposed positions on the Periodic table, the debate stalled progress on the Periodic table for about a decade until someone separated it into two compounds which they named "neodidimium: or "New Didimium" and "Praseodidimium" or "Old Didimium" however the IUPAC of the time was not willing to accept them as new elements barring further proof. Once they were proven they were renamed to "Neodymium" and "Praseodymium" which are the first two elements of the F-block (part of the other reason why nailing down the exact location was so difficult.)

9
TimberdwarfOP•

That was super interesting, especially the portion about Didymium being mistakenly believed to be an element for some time! Thanks!

3
restricteddata•

(Is an electron microscope even useful to determining whether you have a pure element?)

For instance, how did Marie Curie realize that the new substances she found - radium and polonium - were actually pure elements, rather than compounds?

The definition of a chemical element is how it reacts. So as the other response noted, you can take your substance, and do all sorts of reactions with it that you know will remove certain types of other, known elements. Eventually you get down to something that can't be isolated any further. In the case of radium and polonium, though, they were also isolated by their radiation signatures — they let out specific, regular amounts of radiation that identify them uniquely. Radiochemistry (the identification of radioactive elements and isotopes) uses these radiation signatures to isolate elements as well. (Technecium is another good example of this.)

When Michael Faraday liquified oxygen, did he realize that it was an element? How and when did people realize that "liquified nitrogen" was of different nature than "liquified air"?

The idea that air is composed of two elements — oxygen and nitrogen — was known in Faraday's time (thank Priestly and Lavoisier for that work, about 20 years before Faraday was born). By the time of Faraday the understanding of what a "chemical element" was had gotten to the point where they understood that a simple phase change was not relevant to the identity of the element.

To answer the follow-up question — when did that change, if it did? — the answer is, basically that understanding is what we credit to the Chemical Revolution (again, Priestly and Lavoisier, among others — late 18th century). Prior to the Chemical Revolution (but still within, say, the so-called Scientific Revolution) understandings could be quite different and complicated (e.g., Robert Boyle may or may not have understood things the same way — his work is seen as somewhat transitional between alchemy and chemistry, and his understanding of what was going on in chemical reactions does not exactly match up with the post-Chemical Revolution understanding). But to put it another way: in order to have a modern procedure for isolating chemical elements, you must have a modern understanding of a chemical element in the first place. There are many people who participated in that "transition," but crediting Lavoisier (1743-1794) with it isn't the worst thing if you want to just put it on the head of a single person. It was not an overnight thing, though, and Lavoisier was building up a lot of other work himself.

There is much more to this historical angle than I have indicated — but the main point here is that by the 19th century, much of chemistry was fairly "modern" in its understanding even if the underlying mechanism (electron bonds, etc.) were not understood well until much later. The "pre-modern," alchemical understanding did not understand elements in the same way as the later approaches did, and it was pretty complicated by the late 17th century and early 18th century; e.g., it was not just a matter of different elements, but possibly the creation of "subtle" elements that were intangible, and elements certainly could change from one element to another in this view. If you want to wrap your head around alchemy, the works of Lawrence Principe (The Secrets of Alchemy) and William R. Newman (Atoms and Alchemy) are both considered very good by historians of science (of which I am one, but of modern science).

4