Agonizing over Topquilt Selection

Advice

Howdy, UL! I just got a new job, and to reward myself I'm taking the next reasonable step toward lightening my pack by replacing an old North Face synthetic bag from 1999 with a down top quilt (1422g). I'm pretty sure I'm going with an UGQ Bandit in Paisley 2 exterior and a black interior. I'm also pretty sure I'm going with 950 goose down to save weight.

Where I'm getting hung up is temp rating. I have a 3 year old boy and a newborn, so versatility is paramount. I need to be opportunistic to get out in the woods and so I'll be camping anywhere from 90 degree sweltering heat down to just above freezing. I live in North Texas and much of my camping will be TX, OK, AR with the occasional warm season trip to Tahoe or the Boundary Waters of MN. I'm a hammock camper and I'll be pairing the top quilt with a 20 degree Underquilt which I find is perfect for all conditions until an UQ is no longer needed.

So I'm tempted to go with a 30 degree to save weight and just layer clothes as I approach freezing temps since I'll rarely be camping in weather that cold. Alternately, everything I read says 20 is the most appropriate for all but deep winter camping and to just vent in higher temps and use a Costco down throw or a silk sheet when it's really hot.

Please help me over think this to death as I want to spend this money wisely and pursue cheaper solutions for the really hot weather.

Posted Aug 22, 2017, 2:55 PM UTC

312
ItNeedsMoreFunhttps://lighterpack.com/r/5uepah•

Is the 950 fill power really worth it? You're spending nearly $100 to save a little over 1 oz. That seems pretty ridiculous to me. I would hope to be saving 5-10oz (or more!) with a $100 investment. Unless you're kit is totally dialed in, I bet you could save more weight elsewhere for that $100.

I think part of the reason the default 20deg quilt is recommended is that Enlightened Equipment is pretty aggressive with its temp ratings. A 20deg EE quilt is a great all-purpose quilt.

With more conservative (and expensive!) companies like Nunatuk or Katabatic, a 30deg quilt might be a fine all-purpose rating.

I'm not sure where UGQ falls on that scale, but you can get a rough sense of it by comparing fill weight for a similar sized quilt (similar length and width).

Either way, given that you mostly camp in warm places, it seems like a 30deg quilt from any manufacturer will be just fine.

6
shootsfilmwithbullethttps://lighterpack.com/r/3ny5c7•

I'm not sure where UGQ falls on that scale,

On their website they claim to to fill 30% over ENR ratings. If true, that'd put them on the conservative end of the scale.

3
OccularPapercutOP•

Thank you for this insight. I was too far in the splurge mindset trying to build the ideal quilt. 950 fill power is not a good value and that money could be better spent elsewhere.

2
IANALAMAHammock'er - https://lighterpack.com/r/9t6nb9•

Higher FP improves weight AND compressibility. I just haven't found a way to effectively and reliably calculate the volume savings from one item to another, besides manufacturers product stats/details

2
biggyww•

I use a 20 degree underquilt and a 30 degree top quilt down to mid 20's without too much concern. I'm in Colorado usually above 9,000 ft though, so it's not nearly as humid as your area.

I'm also a big advocate of synthetic quilts, especially for high humidity areas. Down doesn't work nearly as well when it's got moisture in it, and the nature of a quilt minimizes the bulk and weight overall, so I feel like it's a perfect application of synthetic insulation. I know nobody wants to hear this, but I have, at times, regretted having a down quilt and wished for a synthetic. As always, YMMV.

3
mittencamperhttps://www.trailpost.com/packs/292•

If you're mostly camping in texas I think 30 is probably your best bet. I use a 20F, which is the most versatile temp quilt where I am in Michigan, but in august it is too warm and for most of the night I'm not under it. I might pull it on around 2-3 am when the temp is in the 60s. In texas the heat is around for much longer, so go warmer and supplement with clothing deep in the shoulder seasons.

2
Morejazzpleasehttps://lighterpack.com/r/f376cs•

I think that with an underquilt being used and the conditions being generally dry and hot areas, the 30F would be totally fine. I use a 30F quilt in the PNW and have yet to be cold in it (even in wet colds in the 40s).

2
RygorMortishttps://lighterpack.com/r/71eewy•

Another 30°F chiming in. I'm in the mid-Atlantic and use it from freezing-70°F, anything warmer I usually just bring a sheet. I've taken it below freezing by using clothing, but I don't think I would want a warmer quilt, mainly for those humid nights.

2
OT_hiker•

First off, I have the Bandit and highly recommend. Second off, I will back up the recommendations here and suggest a 30 degree rating for your purposes.

2
Ant-honeyCity Baby attacked by rats•

30 30 30

I run a 30 underquilt and 30 top quilt for most of my outings (also hammock). I'd like a 10 or a 20 top but I've been ok so far and don't mind being a little chilly or wearing more clothing in the winter. Northeast. A 30 should really do you fine where you live and you'll probably vent more often than not.

2
gardenlevel•

I went with a 30, just got it earlier this year. I've spent a few nights at lower elevations and it's been too warm. Also a couple nights at higher elevations where it was just right. Long term, I think I'll end up with 3 quilts and use / combine them as needed. 50 for true summer, 30 for most of the time, and last I'll get a 20 or 10, depending on how things go this autumn. I'm on the 30 starter quilt train.

2
khovs•

Are you someone who can sleep in jackets, etc? I can't sleep if I'm wearing clothing of any kind so I'm looking at 10 and 20 deg bags. If you can sleep in a down jacket and hood you can factor that in.

2