Disappointed in Arya's sudden change

There’s been a lot of rave about Arya’s duel with Brienne. Two fan favorites clashing it out in Winterfell.

Perhaps I’m an uncultured, overcritical idiot, but the scene had me cringing hard. It felt sort of like a cheap, anime fan service fight. Akin to Arya vs the Waif cringe when Arya was being chased around by T-1000.

Arya bests the Big Woman several times, initially because Brienne underestimated Arya’s ability and fought lightly. But at the end of fight, neither are holding back and stalemate.

TL:DR AT BOTTOM

At this point in the show, with Barristan, Oberyn, Drogo, and Loras dead, Jaime unhanded, the Mountain undead, The Hound bested, Brienne of Tarth is one of the greatest fighters still alive and whole. She’s big, strong, and has trained all her life. She has beaten Loras, Renly’s rainbow guard, Jaime, Sandor, Bolton men, held her own for a while against a grizzly bear, groups of Northmen and Vale Men that outnumber her 4 to 1. And somehow with all her prowess and great height and reach advantage, at full tilt she ties with Arya.

This is when people will come and say, “but wait! Arya trained with the greatest swordsman who ever lived, Syrio Forell, the Hound, Jaqen H’ghar and Faceless men. She has been trained in multiple fighting styles over the course of 4-5 years.”

My response:

1 Arya trained in water dancing style with Syrio Forel for only a few months. She gained the basics and could train on her own from there. But there is no indication that she became an expert from her training with Forel. Arya was only able to kill an unarmed boy who wasn’t expecting a fight from her. Furthermore, Arya never demonstrates her sword fighting skills in Season two. She challengers Thoros to a fight, and he nonchalantly disarms her

Secondly, Syrio Forel may have been a good swordsman, but he was killed by Meryn Fookin Trant (who any boy whore with a sword could kill three of). Of course, Syrio didn’t have a sword and Trant had armor.

2 Arya never trained with the Hound. The Hound insults water dancing and mocks Arya to show him what she can do. Arya thrusts needle into Clegane’s armor, hoping to kill him, and then gets slapped to the ground.

The Hound once told her where the heart is so she can kill people. However, this is the limit of his killing pedagogy over her.

3 The Faceless Men never trained Arya in sword fighting. Jaqen never trained Arya in any sort of fighting. When Arya joined the Faceless Assassin guild, she spent most of her time cleaning floors and dead bodies. When she elevated in the guild she was tasked to assassinate some old men with poison. Arya did kill Meryn Trant, but not in a sword fight. Rather she assassinated him through stealth and trickery. The only actual fighting pedagogy Arya received after Forel was from the Waif. She was beaten with a staff and learned how to fight blind. This of course gives Arya a huge advantage over her opponents in her ability to fight in the dark and rely on her hearing. This, however, is not sword or knife training. Afterwards, the Waif, which we have no indication is a good fighter (only a good assassin), stabs Arya and almost kills her. Arya then kills the waif, not because she is a better fighter, but because she out smarts her and lures her into a dark room where Arya has the advantage.

My main criticism of this duel is that it betrays Arya’s character development. At the start of GOT, Arya wanted to be a warrior, a knight. However, she quickly learns that knighthood and honor is bullshit and takes the mindset that any means to kill someone is justifiable. Arya is not a fighter, she is not meant to fight with a sword or spear or ax. List of Arya’s kills. If you look at everyone she has killed, none of them were engaged in combat or a fight with her, except the Waif (who was actually a better fighter than Arya, but lost because Arya outsmarted her). Arya is meant to be an assassin. She uses poison, stealth, subterfuge, she attacks from behind when your guard is down. Arya has been doing this for the last six seasons. And come episode 4 of season 7, out of no where D&D make Arya to be one of the best swordsman in Westeros. This development is completely inconsistent with the events she has faced the last six season and feels implausible.

Furthermore, it devalues the skill of Brienne and many other warrior characters in the show. It takes away their worth as characters who's primary assets are in their martial ability. Oh, you trained 20+ years, have fought and killed dozens or hundreds of warriors in combat, to become one of the best fighters in Planetos. Well actually, this small girl who has quasi trained for four years is your equal.

TL:DR

  1. Syrio only trained Arya for a short while

  2. The Hound never trained Arya

  3. Jaqen never trained Arya in combat. The waif trained Arya in staff fighting, but not sword fighting.

  4. Arya never showed expert skill level in sword fighting until her duel with Brienne. She has only killed one person, the Waif, in actual combat.

  5. Arya is meant to be an assassin. She uses poison, subterfuge, stealth. She attacks when you’re unarmed or not expecting it. The contrivance of her being one of the best swordsman is inconsistent with her development over the last six seasons.

  6. Arya's out of nowhere master swordsmanship devalues the ability and worth of many other characters (Brienne, Sandor, Jon, Bronn, Jorah, Daario, Loras) who some have trained for dozens of years and killed hundreds of men.

EXTRA TL:DR Out of nowhere Arya becomes a master swordsman.

P.S. Anyways, I guess I was just disappointed in what her character has become. Give me your down votes now.

Posted Aug 23, 2017, 9:11 PM UTC · edited

421
crossedstaves•

Frankly I think Jon's skills may be the more problematic. He joins the night's watch at 16, sure he's trained in a castle with a master at arms for a good bit, but he's still only 16. He may be the best of the new recruits, but that's not saying too much. After a couple months of training which don't amount to too much because he's sparring with people that are shit. Then he's a steward. Not that much swordplay involved in fetching tea. All the night's watch goes out beyond the wall. He joins up with some wildlings, gets captured. Eventually more shit happens, but not that much fighting for him. Comes back to castle black, they fight the wildlings, Jon mostly commands and does some fighting.

Like he trained as a kid in a castle, but without doing much else over the span of several years, he just starts finding himself in the middle of hardhome and the battle of the bastards and battle of that dumb frozen lake just mowing people down without getting a scratch. He killed a white walker in like 10 seconds, no challenge.

No sense that any of the legendary swordsmen in the show, or seasoned knights have any edge on him.

That feels way less natural to me.

At least we actually see Arya training. We don't see much training or advancement from Jon.

7
GetOffRedditASAPOP•

I agree. In the books Jon is made to be more of a natural leader than an excellent swordsman. However, Jon's combat ability has a natural progression. He is constantly fighting in actual combat, killing dozens of wildlings, crows, and northmen. Even with all this experience, he shouldn't be as talented as he is depicted in the show.

Arya is shown to be constantly training. However, she has only engaged in combat once in the entire show before dueling Brienne. If you look at all her kills, she kills by stealth and deception. She has only killed the waif in actual combat.

5
crossedstaves•

I'd give her some credit for the Inn at the Crossroads fight. During that little battle she took out two dudes with some clean sword work.

While I think real battle experience is probably pretty valuable (not being an experienced sword fighter myself I can't really say), I don't know its necessarily everything. Rigorously drilling technique, movement, footwork do have real value.

Even when training in staff fighting the evasion skills she displays, the footwork, some degree of the parrying skill would likely apply as well. The staff may not have trained her in how to deliver the blade, but it does still cover the lesson of not getting hit.

2
GetOffRedditASAPOP•

Do you mean this fight? She killed a Lannister man and Polliver. Both were injured, disarmed, and on the ground due to Sandor. They did not fight her. She essentially assassinated them. Which is what her character is: an assassin. She kills her enemies mercilessly when they are not expecting it. If you look at all her kills, only one involved a fight (the Waif).

3
crossedstaves•

She killed them with a sword in the middle of a battle and displayed fine sword technique in doing it. Polliver wasn't on the ground until she put him on the ground slicing him the back with a very well executed swing of the sword. I'm not saying that it proves she was a great fighter, or trying to say any two things are equivalent in terms of combat experience. I'm just saying it counts as some experience. Podrick stabbed the Kingsguard trying to kill Tyrion in the back of the head during the battle of the blackwater, I wouldn't begrudge him that as being combat experience despite not having faced each other traded blows. Plenty of people in battles are seen getting fucked up by people other than one they're focusing on. Arya's experience is some combat experience, that's all I'm saying.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
SammyDaBull•

They've explained this countless times. Kit is an amazing hand with a sword, so they kinda made "show Jon" an even better swordsman than he normally would be because Kit looks fookin badass doing spin-thrusts and shit.

Did you see that kill on the wight in ep6 right before Dany came? That shit made me hard, he did the Darth Maul.

4
PingStark•

Well she trained quite a while with the waif and she was blind at the time. So her new ability to move is understandable since she can see now. And it was made pretty clear that she worked her water dancing routine every day (except when she was at the house of black and white , there she was training with a staff) . So If you take into account that the traveled for a very long time she had plenty of time to work on her skills

6
GetOffRedditASAPOP•

She trained for four years, which is a considerable amount of time. But, Brienne trained for decades. Brienne killed soldiers and other seasoned warriors in combat. Arya has only fought one person in combat (the Waif). She lost their first fight, nearly died, and won the second because she had a sword and tricked the waif into coming into a dark room.

-1
PingStark•

Yes but it's a difference in style like the mountain and oberyn. In an openfield battle Brienne style would give her more chance to survive but Arya was train in an assassin combat style. So it's more efficient in one on one combat. Her size and mobility give her the advantage especially in close quarter combat. Her sword is a rapier so she can produce rapid frontal thrusts. It takes more time to Brienne to repeat strokes, she leaves a lot of openings

5
GetOffRedditASAPOP•

Jorah vs Braavosi water dancer. Brienne>>>>Jorah Jorah, a Westerosi knight, was capable of holding his own against a water dancer for several minutes, before being defeated. Would you argue that this water dancer, who has likely trained all his life, is less skilled than Arya? So I assume water dancer>Arya

If Brienne is better than Jorah, she would likely be able to defeat this master water dancer. Thus shouldn't she be able to defeat Arya?

Another reminder: Meryn Trant, a piece of shit swordsman, killed Syrio Forel, supposedly the best water dancer alive. Of course Forel didn't have a sword on him.

Arya was train in an assassin combat style

  1. She was never trained to use a sword by the Faceless Men. The waif taught her how to fight with a quarter staff.

  2. Furthermore, assassin combat style is not one on one fighting. Assassin combat style involves sneaks, stealth, deception. It involves killing your opponent from behind.

list of famous assassins: john wilkes booth, Gavirlo Princip, Lee Harvy Oswald. Common trait: all of them assassinated their target from behind.

2
PingStark•

Well, I would not compare too much. I get your points really. But I guess training blind gives you a different perspective. Assassin style was meant in the way of defeating your ennemies with the minimal stroke (line crav maga). But I think anyway that Brienne wasn't in a killing mode, she was sparing. Arya was more serious I think. But her size and sword made her develop a unique style combining her different training. I wouldn't put too much effort into it. I think her main strength comes from the element of surprise, nobody expects her to be able to do that so nobody can anticipate her moves. You might be tall, strong, trained etc if you can't touch your opponent you will loose stamina and strength especially if you are wearing heavy armor

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Chaosfolk•

The training duel is completely justified and the outcome is reasonable. Brienne trained and fought against men in armor and longswords for all her life an now faces off against a small nimble and very agile assassin. It's not what she expected and logically missed several "cuts" which wouldn't do her any harm in the real fight anyway because she is wearing armor.

Likewise, Arya got herself kicked and she fell on the ground. In the real fight, brienne would have followed with a quick sword strike and killed Arya.

It's like comparing A professonal boxer with a karate master. Each of them can surprise another and win the fight

5
GetOffRedditASAPOP•

It's like comparing A professonal boxer with a karate master

Brienne is a master Westerosi swordsman. But, is Arya a master water dancer? My point is, she hasn't trained enough, been trained by experts enough, or practiced her skills in actual combat to be considered a master or professional.

3
mandydu30•

Cry me a river

3
GetOffRedditASAPOP•

My bad. I forgot that we're not allowed to have intelligent discussions about the characters we love and enjoy. Instead we must completely accept everything the show gives us and keep our mouths shut.

Thanks for the constructive criticism friend.

1
rmcoach90•

I totally see what you're saying but I thought the surprise of how good she was, was a good moment. There's quite alot that happens off screen and the scene with Brienne was a testament to Arya's will to be a warrior and her thirst for vengeance. She has been dedicated.

Also the first spar I'm sure Brienne didn't give it her all. Then she bested Arya afterwards. And most of Arya's style was defense, dodging, and maneuvering. She's tiny, quick and doesn't wear armor

2
crossedstaves•

Yeah, if Brienne was trying to kill Arya, Arya probably would have been killed the moment Brienne knocked her to the ground given how long she lay there catching her breath, a follow up swording could have finished her off.

Also Brienne could have just worn a helmet.

2
rmcoach90•

Agreed

1
damnspear•

If they focused more on Rocky style training segments we would then be bitching about the lack of plot. John has had multiple fights plus prior training along with natural skill, it's safe to say he isn't your average Joe. The Arya and Brienne fight scene was surprising to me but in a good way, I didn't question Arya's lack of experience because there's no doubt that she went through strenuous training to be an assassin, not to mention the training she's done along the journey. I guess that's the difference between books and tv, it's much more difficult to show improvements in physical ability without dedicating the whole hour to it. They're fighters and they haven't had a break since season 1, now if Sansa suddenly picked up a sword and started wrecking shit up I'd be scratching my head.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
TelMeThisAintTrueYou still mad at us, boy?•
1
JaqensRedGoddessValar Morghulis•

Well said! I thought the same thing. It made sense that in the beging of their sparring, when Brienne didn't know how skilled her opponent was, Arya managed to outmanoeuvre her but Brienne should have have had the upper hand in the end. In all her time training to be a fighter she has surely had some opponents that were almost as fast as Arya, while Arya had no training against someone with armour and longsword, let alone someone with Brienne's skills. On a side note, I really wish that Jaqen had trained Arya as well. Actually I wish we had seen his fighting style and skills, because in the books he does fight at Harrenhal.

1