Free Hub Issues

My free hub died at around 500 miles and would no longer engage. Sunringle replaced the wheel and the new one just failed with less than 200 miles. Tired of failing hubs, I just bought a new (non-Sunringle) wheel instead and decided to take mine apart.

Could these failures be the result of me doing anything wrong, or are these hubs just too cheap for my fat butt?

Posted Aug 23, 2017, 11:06 PM UTC

47
sledneck_03•

Welcome to the club man. Its your fucking he man strength. Ive killed soooooo many hubs.

I only ride dt swiss hubs. 350s are pretty decent priced... its worth it to never walk home again (or back to the truck)

Their ratchet system is very strong.

My top fuel has dt hubs, my new fatbike is getting a dt hub installed the day it arrives to the LbS.

3
morbetterOP•

So you think it's just a cheap hub and there's nothing I could have done to prevent it?

2
pigcupid•

You weren't asking me, but yes, I do. It looks like the ring that holds the pawls in place is slipping and there's nothing you can do to fix that except to put out less power (that's dumb).

And I cannot possibly second sledneck's DT 350 recommendation any more. That is THE go-to hub for reliability, weight, and cost. Any time I try to cut corners and build my own wheels with something else, I end up regretting it within 6 months.

2
morbetterOP•

The both of you are confirming what my researching is telling me - that the DT350 is the way to go in the future. I already have a new wheel that the LBS guys say is what they run on their bikes, but if this new hub dies too, I will definitely look into 350s.

1
sledneck_03•

Well if you glide then mash constantly its like an impact wrench on them. This is un avoidable for me and just climbing in general will be loading on them. Every time ive blown mine was on a climb. If you go on mtbr and go to the clydesdale section you will see its a common problem with people 200+ lbs and lots of inquiries for a clyde proof hub.

1
longer35•

Was it the SRC hub? I had to get mine serviced under warranty because there was apparently a batch that didn't have the correct bearings so you couldn't correctly tighten the assembly for the thru-axle models. Mine was a 197mm that I luckily noticed coming loose and would have to retighten every 30 miles or so until they warrantied the hub. Another guy I know had the same issue on his boost version. Apparently it was possible to allow the hub to loosen to the point where it allows the hub to try to engage off-axis enough it would skip a bit, rounding the pawls a little each time until they no longer engage. If it is new enough to warranty, I'd do it. If nothing else, you'll have a working hub to sell and maybe offset some of the cost. Don't expect it to be fast...it took Sun almost 10 weeks to ship parts. Dealing with them has been a bit irritating to say the least.

2
morbetterOP•

I'm not sure which hub it is, but it's the Charger Comp wheelset.

1