(Spoilers Main) Kings Landing's Population

SpoilerMAIN

It has been well established in the books and previous seasons of the show that King's Landing has a population of half a million. During the WOTFK the population may have surged to six hundred thousand due to refugees.

However, in S7E7, 6mins 44secs into the show this happens:

Jon Snow: "How many people live here?"

Tyrion Lannister: "A million, give or take."

Jon Snow: "That's more people than the entire North, crammed into that."

Is this a gaffe? How has KL's population doubled? Even with the onset of winter, the city's population would never increase that much.

Furthermore, how is the entire population of the North less than a million? Robb fielded at least twenty thousand men. Torrhen Stark fielded at least thirty thousand men. Indicating the North could have fielded more. This is more soldiers than the entire Crownlands could muster in the WOTFK. The North is obviously more populated than the Iron Islands and Dorne. And both must have populations greater than a million. Most fan estimates place the North at around 2.5-4 million. Did the show writers make a mistake? Or did our characters make a mistake?

Posted Aug 28, 2017, 8:26 AM UTC

111
N7Greenfire•

We have no idea how many people the onset of winter would bring, unless you want ot link a book quote?

all the refuges

plus all the lannister and Ironborn men.

Peasant rabble(including women children the old crippled ect) and trained equiped fighting men are two different things.

2
GetOffRedditASAPOP•

Not all the Lannister banners were there, indicated by Cersei's command to call all the banners. And the Lannister armies don't live in KL.

Tyrion obviously didn't count the ironborn, because they don't live in KL.

The WOTFK has been over for years. Many of the refuges would have returned to their farms. Daenery's army did invade but they did not sack or pillage holdfasts, villages, or towns of the crownlands. There was no indication of war refugees still in KL. It would seem many denizens of KL would have left after Cersei blew up the Sept.

We have no idea how many people the onset of winter would bring, unless you want ot link a book quote?

You're correct. But Tyrion never explained that KL's population would double in size during the Winter. This seems to be a major inconsistency when literally every book and show reference has placed KL at 1/2 mil, then suddenly it doubles without explanation. Seriously, a five second remark that the city's population vastly expands during winter is all that would be needed to establish continuity.

1
N7Greenfire•

There was atleast a garrison there, and Tyrion could have counted the Ironborn we don't know

The riverlands was still horrendously fucked up, and with winter coming it might not be healed properly enough to support its population, it also has roving bandits as late as season 6, who killed what 30 people building a Sept there was also the whole Frey thing, peasants could have been flocking in droves fleeing winter from a scarred land that they already couldn't till.

1
GetOffRedditASAPOP•

Which is a good speculative point. But a simple fucking explanation by Tyrion would have sold me.

If you live in a city suited for half a million people and that city doubles in population shit is bound to happen. Overcrowding, disease, famine. Cersei and Jaime have been in KL all S7 and S6, yet there's not one mention of overpopulation? In S6 Olenna does mention cutting off the flow of grain to KL, but that's no indication that the city's population has doubled. How does Tyrion know the population has doubled? Does Varys have information on the stream of winter refuges into KL's? Does Tyrion haphazardly guess how many poured into KL? His only explanation is that the city has good whores and work.

But, why do we have to speculate the cause for this extremely important fact? A city's population doubling is not an insignificant event. KL is now far greater than Old Town and has possibly surpassed Meereen or Braavos.

1
Belial91•

In the show the only time the population is mentioned I think is when Jamie talks with Qyburn when Qyburn he asks him how many lives he saved and Jamie responds "half a million".

This was during the reign of the mad king though so there was some time for the population to increase and the onset of Winter very likely also brings more people in.

2
asendra•

Round numbers make for better tv. I guess. Who knows.

2
GetOffRedditASAPOP•

Sounds like dumbing down for the audience.

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
Flashpenny•

Furthermore, how is the entire population of the North less than a million? Robb fielded at least twenty thousand men. Torrhen Stark fielded at least thirty thousand men. Indicating the North could have fielded more. This is more soldiers than the entire Crownlands could muster in the WOTFK. The North is obviously more populated than the Iron Islands and Dorne. And both must have populations greater than a million. Most fan estimates place the North at around 2.5-4 million.

Yeah, and all that was BEFORE Theon's invasion, BEFORE the Red Wedding, BEFORE the Wildlings' campaign of murder and mayhem ot Castle Black, BEFORE the Boltons' sadistic killings, BEFORE the March on Winterfell and BEFORE the Battle of the Bastards (the last of which was basically a Northern Civil War). Their population has taken a huge fucking hit during the show and could be well down to 800,000-900,000 now.

1
GetOffRedditASAPOP•

Before Theon's invasion

The Iron Born only invaded the Western coast of the North. They did not penetrate inland, except for Theon who took Winterfell. They ruled Motte Cailin, Deepwood Motte, and the Stony Shore. But, their reign lasted shortly and were quickly repelled from the North.

5000-7000 causalities (mostly smallfolk)

Before the Red Wedding

event did not take place in the North.

4000 causalities

Before the Widling's campaign of murder

The Wildlings did not kill tens of thousands. They killed less than a hundred Crows and a couple hundred villagers in the scarcely populated region of the Gift. The Gift was already vastly underpopulated for years because of Wildling raids.

700 causalities

Before the Bolton's sadistic killings

The Bolton's were sadistic and did kill many. Mainly lords (e.g. Lord Cerwyn and his family) who failed to submit. Ramsay and Roose were vicious bastards who ruled by fear. But, why would they slaughter tens of thousands of their meek peasant subjects?

1000 causalities (generous)

Before the March on Winterfell

All of Stannis' army died, but they are not Northerns. The Boltons lost a couple hundred soldiers.

200 causalities (Northerners)

Before the Battle of the Bastards

The BB was a Civil War, but it was only one battle.

7500 causalities (All Bolton, Umber, Karstark. Majority of wildlings Mormont, Mazin, Hornwood)

I'll also assume that most of Rob's men died

20000 (causalities. Bolton men counted above).

We must not forget that Jon Snow added about 6000 free folk to the North. About 1500 died at the BOB, so that's a gain of 4500 people.

Total causalities: 40,000.

If we assume the North had 3 million before WOTFK, has 1 million at the end of S7, how did the other 1,960,000 Northerners die?

1
GetOffRedditASAPOP•

The majority of the North's military and aristocratic power has been destroyed. Thus, as Jon said, they can only muster less than 10,000 men. This does not explain what happened to millions of smallfolk and other citizens who did not die in battle.

The WOTFK took place in the South, in the Riverlands, Westerlands, and Crownlands. Only the Northern military died there. The Iron Born did invade the North, but their impact was negligible. The majority of the North has been untouched by war (e.g. White Harbor, Dreadfort, Hornwood, Ramsgate, Widow's Watch, Mountain clans, Karhold, Last Hearth, Skagos, Bear Island). Only several thousand soldiers and nobles died from these lands. So how could these Northerns have been greatly impacted by famine or disease if their lands remained relatively untouched? Did 2/3 of the North die from disease and famine? This seems unlikely.

If that many Northerns died there must have been an extremely deadly plague, worse than the Black Death in Europe. But, there was absolutely no mention of famine or virulent pandemic in the North.

So we can only speculate how 1/2 to 2/3 of the North died.

1