r/crossfit•
cmswhyte

What would be the best way to sort Athletes for a Competition? [Rx, Intermediate, Scaled, etc]

Hey, so first of all things: I really had trouble finding a good title for this post. English is not my native language so i kind of struggle with the correct use of words, definitions and/ or grammar.

We attended a Competition last weekend where people had to do the Qualifier Workouts and based on their scores get divided into certain categories: Elite and Intermediate. First 20 are Elite and the places 21 to 30 are invited as Intermediate Athletes. This system has the major benefit of not having to decide wether you are an Elite or Scaled athlete - not leaving you in a category you are unfit for. But on the other hand you get put together with people you shouldn't have to compete in the first place.

On the other hand, deciding beforehand and registrating for a Competition as an Elite can be too much, as in "No chance at all" but as an Intermediate/ Scaled Athlete might be not correct.

A lot of my friends are inbetween and therefore constantly unsure, so i was wondering: What do you think is the best system to sort Athletes for a competition?

Posted Aug 29, 2017, 10:08 PM UTC

316
jamesewelch•

Most of the competitions here are: Open, Rec, and Masters. Whatever you did The Open workouts is what you are expected to do at the competitions. Most events give movement examples and recommended weights as a guideline as well.

For example, the Open division might say: HSPU, DU, Squat Clean 185, etc. Rec division might list movements that they won't include such as "advanced gymnastics" and that everything can be scaled, etc. Masters division (usually 40+) usually says there's going to be no overhead movements or muscle ups, etc.

2
cmswhyteOP•

I have not once seen this here in Germany/ Europe. But it is an interesting concept and helps categorizing

1
epwnym•

Competitions around here list movement requirements for scaled, intermediate, and Rx divisions. It's usually based on what you'll have to do in the competition. If you can't do everything in the list, you can't compete in that division.

2
cmswhyteOP•

Juat like u/jameswelsch said, that concept looks thought through and actually helps way more than ours. Are your qualifying workouts posted all at the same time or weeks/ days apart?

1
epwnym•

It's not a qualifying workout. It's just a list of items posted weeks/months beforehand.

You register for whatever division you want. If you can't actually do the movements, well, you'll just look like an idiot at the competition.

And if you're really good and you register for scaled, it will also be obvious and everybody will think you're an asshole, lol.

2
cmswhyteOP•

Oh okay. But what if there are more Athletes than you have room for? For the German Throwdown there are over 100 competitors - surely they couldn't all compete?

1
epwnym•

You just have a limited number of slots per division and then it's first come, first served for registering. Like buying tickets to a concert.

The size of the facility and the number of judges will generally dictate how big of a competition it can be.

2
HarvInThePaint•

I think you are talking about larger competitions like Granite Games, Wodapalooza, etc. They have online qualifiers. An easy way to do it would be to require divisions to be divided by your open placing... say Elite - finished top 500 in the open for your region, RX 500-1000, intermediate 1000-1500, etc. It would take some additional time on the back end though to check that an intermediate athlete wasn't 550 and trying to sand bag.

2
cmswhyteOP•

Well, yes. But also, no. Even the smallest ones here have a Qualifier. I think, Rostock, Kulmbach, etc. didn't have one, but all the other ones do/did. Hell, Berlin has more than 3 different comps which require a Qualifier.

It could be a good idea to factor your open score in to measure your rank, but it would require all staff members to check every athlete individually. In a few cases it could really help finding someone who wants an easy win though

1
verboseduodenum•

So, this weekend I did my first CF competition. It was a team competition, with only RX and scaled divisions (no masters, no age groups or anything). It was such a bummer for my team to have to get through 400 single unders as the first part of a relay WOD while other teams crushed 200 DUs and were on to the next stage. Seeing someone bang out 30 unbroken butterfly pull ups, and then stand on a scaled podium twenty minutes later was just annoying.

That's why I like what Rep Your Box (a big CF comp in Florida) is doing this year. It's a two day event, 3 WODs each day. This year, athletes just sign up, but don't pick RX or scaled. Everybody does the same day 1 WODs, with no weight or skill variances other than male/female weight. At the end of the day no one knows their scores or where their team stands. At the beginning of day 2, scores and rankings are revealed, along with the RX/Scaled cutoff. So you only find out if you're scaled or RX when it's too late to intentionally flop a WOD so you can go from lower-ranked RX to the very top of scaled. No one knows where the cutoff will be.

Obviously, if you were really dedicated to the idea of sandbagging, you could run a hustle by committing to under-performing all day on day 1, but there's no way to know how low you need to go unless you organize a way to track every single team's scores. Even then, you don't know the cutoff, and if you go way too low there may not be enough points left on day 2 for you to make podium.

I, for one, like it. We'll see how it goes.

2