[S3E18]missing the forest for the trees (or, another idea about the ending)
People are getting way too caught up in the weeds of "how" things unfolded in the finale that they are missing what (I think) is the point of the ending.
The "meaning" of the ending is pretty simple: you can't save Laura Palmer. Or, rather, you can't save every Laura Palmer. Because there are Laura Palmers everywhere. There's one in Odessa that looks exactly like Laura Palmer but is named Carrie Page. It is "the story of the girl that lived down the lane" because there are traumatized and suffering girls down pretty much every lane. And if you save one, you just need to go one lane over to find another that is living a life of suffering. Carrie/Laura's scream at the end isn't because she's waking up from some dream to reality. It's because she hears that echo of pain (Sarah calling out to Laura the morning after her murder) and can feel it in a metaphysical sense.
Don't get too caught up in figuring out the exact mechanics by which the character Special Agent Dale Cooper transverses a different time/reality to save character Laura Palmer. Cooper "saves" Laura Palmer - we see her dead body wink out of existence. But in doing so, he achieves a pyrrhic victory at best - Laura/Carrie hearing Sarah at the end hints that by Cooper not being able to let Laura go he may just be perpetuating the cycle. Bringing Laura back doesn't save her - it just continues her suffering. Again, this is all happening on a meta-textual level and not at the level of literal story plot.
This also makes me think that even if we get a 4th season (which I doubt), I think we've already seen the thematic end of Twin Peaks - the end of FWWM where we see Laura, now dead in the physical sense, being comforted by a benevolently smiling Dale Cooper at peace. The end of The Return hints that Cooper trying to save Laura is part of a cosmic loop that he cannot escape (Jeffries' 8). The end of FWWM shows that, eventually, Dale Cooper comes to accept Laura's death. Instead of repeating futile attempts at going to the ends of time to "save" Laura (even in FWWM he was warning Laura not to take the ring), he finally realizes that physical death is the route Laura takes to escape suffering. He finally learns that the most compassionate thing he can do is to welcome Laura into "death". He can't stop suffering. If he wanted to stop suffering then he would need to stop Laura from being born. And if he did, then he's back in the same spot: Laura doesn't exist. And even if he, with all his good intentions, decided to make that happen - stop Laura from ever experiencing pain - what about all the other Laura Palmers suffering out there?
I think Lynch is saying that the Mother cannot be defeated as long as people fight the Mother. It's a very fundamentally Buddhist view (4 noble truths). By trying to fight suffering, you are just perpetuating it. By desiring the end of the Mother, you are creating more Garmonbozia for her to feast from (which is why the Mother inhabits Sarah Palmer - who carries around more pain and suffering and guilt than a woman who's husband sexually assaulted her daughter for years and eventually killed her?)
You (Cooper) must come to accept suffering. You do not have to like it. You shouldn't like it. But the most compassionate thing you can do for someone isn't necessarily to try and end their suffering but to welcome them with love when the suffering is over.
This is why I don't think the Fireman and his interdimensional theater are actually the White Lodge. I think the Fireman is basically the Time and Space FBI. He's trying to put out these small fires and then takes a shot at taking out the big bad Mother just like Cooper, Cole and Briggs do. Turns out, you can't end suffering through some elaborate plans with numbers and coordinates and getting people to certain places at certain times and all the other "mythology" stuff. Sure, you can defeat some abhorrent scumbag like BOB by fighting him (done with a Hulk fist for purposefully comic effect) but you can't put an end to suffering like that.
You can't punch Mother because she'll bite off your fucking throat. You can't trick Mother (suffering) because she will just yank out Laura Palmer and stick her in Carrie Page. And if you try to save Carrie Page, she'll just stick in her the next girl down the lane.
Anyway, totally rambling but I think that given both Lynch and Frost's interests in Buddhism and Eastern thought in general, and Lynch's career-spanning meditation on suffering that this might be one way to look at the end of The Return.
Posted Sep 6, 2017, 3:58 AM UTC