Small, localized (rust)hole in steel chainstay
I got an old steel MTB (Wheeler 8000) for a good price, but it required some maintenance. I decided to do it thoroughly, and while brushing away surface rust at a few spots I came upon this small rust hole in the middle, underside of the chainstay. It is between 1 and 2 mm in diameter, Forgive me for the bad lighting, the brushed metal reflects a lot of light and appears white. Anyway, my description gives more information than the picture.
I probed around and the damaged is very localized; there appears to be no damage beyond the edges of the hole and the metal is quite thick at the site of the hole. The rest of the frame is also in good conditions, only some surface rust. Notably, bottom bracket shell was also in very good condition.
My assessment is that there is no risk of structural failure whatsoever, however I am very curious of what could have caused this. My theory is that a localized anomaly in the steel corroded, leaving the surroundings intact, but maybe someone else with knowledge in metallurgy or just more experience has another opinion.
tl;dr: What caused small localized rust hole with intact surroundings?
Posted Sep 9, 2017, 3:44 PM UTC
It's hard to tell with the picture. Are you sure some previous owner or the manufacturer didn't drill it? Maybe a water drainage hole that lost some paint around it? Seems very strange it could rust through but not impact the surrounding area (assuming you are confident there is not significant rust inside the frame). In any case, make sure to spray in some frame protectant before you build it up.
Nope, edges are too irregular for a drilled hole, and it is not exactly at the bottom, but slightly on the side towards the wheel, and nothing on the other side. As expected, the chainstay bridge was the worst rusted part, but that was still far from rusting through, despite previous owner not using full-length fenders.
Yes, very strange indeed. The normal scenario of a rusthole usually means the edges of the hole are porous, and the wall thinned out, for all I have seen! I just broke my hardened steel probe while testing the strength of the edges of the hole! Nice, now it will rattle around in there...
Already drenched the lady in a lineseed-based rust protector!