Ability Bloat in Pantheon

Has there been any info from the devs on how they will address (or not address) ability/hot bar cloat in Pantheon? Specifically, I'm talking about the phenomenon in modern MMOs where you are accumulating new abilites and spells every level, somtimes multiple new abilities per level. In addition, you're given as many hotbars as your heart desires, and in no way limited by game mechanics as to how many abilities you have at your disposal in a given encounter. Eventually, you end up with a situation like this.

I checked the official wiki on combat, skills and spells, as well as searching this sub and couldn't find any info on this. I'm curious if anyone has any info on the design decisions surrounding this, and what others' thoughts are.

Speaking for myself, ability bloat drives me nuts. In addition, I think it really drives off players who stop playing a game and try to return later, especially if they skip an expansion. Coming back to ability bloat in a game you used to know well is a really jarring and off-putting experience. I much preferred the way Guild Wars 2 handled their ability system, limiting you to just a few abilities based on your equipped weapons, but allowing you to tweak specializations to modify your play style and adapt to different situations. Horizontal progression in general just seems like a great way to avoid ability bloat.

Posted Sep 21, 2017, 9:56 PM UTC

329
Darkstryke•

You kids are spoiled. I remember the days of having two abilities: Taunt and kick.

9
BetrayerMordred•

Ah, the days when your entire existence could be simulated by a goddamned dipping bird.

4
borgy95a•

But somehow they were still glorious. Those goddamned glorious dipping birds tanked well!

3
iksarDruid•

From the FAQ:

2.2 Will there be a limitation to the number of abilities we can use at a given time?

You may be limited to a subset of your abilities for the next encounter, causing you to have to intelligently plan ahead and memorize the spells most effective against the upcoming enemy. Likewise, you'll want to memorize spells that counter the upcoming mob’s abilities. Lastly, you may have some abilities that work synergistically with others in your group. But the key point here is that these tactical decisions can be made right before the actual encounter. Then, say you move on deeper into the dungeon and are about to confront a different boss with different abilities and a different disposition, it may make tactical sense to prep different abilities. So yes, you are limited to that extent (you cannot simply use any of your 80+ abilities whenever you wish) because planning for the battle ahead and doing so effectively is key to Pantheon. The exact number of spells, abilities, feats and actions one can prep is TBD and won’t likely be finalized until Beta. What’s depicted in screenshots showing the UI is not final.

7
Finances1212•

I just hope that it's not a system like GW2 where you slot in 4-5 abilities and spam. I hate that system. Give me choice don't confine me a simply 5 button rotation

5
NabeShogunShaman•

From the FAQ:

2.2 Will there be a limitation to the number of abilities we can use at a given time?
You may be limited to a subset of your abilities for the next encounter, causing you to have to intelligently plan ahead and memorize the spells most effective against the upcoming enemy. Likewise, you'll want to memorize spells that counter the upcoming mob’s abilities. Lastly, you may have some abilities that work synergistically with others in your group. But the key point here is that these tactical decisions can be made right before the actual encounter. Then, say you move on deeper into the dungeon and are about to confront a different boss with different abilities and a different disposition, it may make tactical sense to prep different abilities. So yes, you are limited to that extent (you cannot simply use any of your 80+ abilities whenever you wish) because planning for the battle ahead and doing so effectively is key to Pantheon. The exact number of spells, abilities, feats and actions one can prep is TBD and won’t likely be finalized until Beta. What’s depicted in screenshots showing the UI is not final.

I seem to remember watching the shaman swap around a spell on one of the streams and it was like EQ1, you had to sit and meditate to do it and it took time, but yeah you definitely have limited spellslots (though those aren't the same as ability things like bash, sense heading or whatever).

3
IvoryApple•

Whether or not you can change spells, weapons, or gear in-combat is a fundamental design decision. It affects everything about combat, from time-to-kill, mob hit points, resists, spells, skills, casting times, interrupts, cc duty cyle, aggro radius, ai/personality, and more.

It has to be made before you place the mobs and build the encounters. If they haven't made this decision yet, pre-pre-pre-pre alpha is still years away.

-2
Saerain•

Indeed. 8-12 slots, I would hope. The hotbar plague is a tragedy.

3
IvoryApple•

8 sounds good until you are a caster. Simple example: Wizard in EQ1

Group expects you'll be able to root, so you need at least one root. Down to 7.

Group expects Evac. Down to 6.

Group expects you can stun caster mobs that heal and/or gate. Down to 5.

Group expects you can strip enchantments off of mobs (Cancel magic). Down to 4.

Self buff #1 (shielding). Down to 3. Self buff #2(diamondskin). Down to 2. Self resist buff. Down to 1.

You really didn't want to use two damage types, did you? :) Nope. Pick one. Or an AE/rain and a DD? Naaah.

While it's true you can swap/re-mem in/out of combat for some of these, getting caught with a bad pull while you're re-buffing and temporarily un-mem'd evac is not ideal. Sure, there's lots of "but but but" and "git gud" and "macro, noob" and so on, but ultimately, there is no logical reason to limit spells or skills out of combat.

In combat? Sure, go for it. I'm all about the limited set encounter. But out of combat, why should I have to re-mem half my spellbar to rebuff? Just let me cast the buffs out of my spellbook directly or any amount of non-combat bars I'd care to have.

6
nouppercaseWarrior•

Like idea of being able to cast spells directly from spellbook while out of combat.

4
KayninDire Lord•

the quick mem, was nice when it was added.

Didnt have to manually load the self buffs and then load the dd after done buffing.

2
welly321•

Shaman or enchanter in EQ1 is way worse than wizard. Wizards have it easy

1
IvoryAppleSummoner•

Sounds like you have some first hand knowledge, care to share, welly321?

1
welly321•

Enchanter you had to have

  1. tash
  2. short term mez
  3. ae mez
  4. stun
  5. root 6.charm
  6. mana tap
  7. clarity
  8. haste
  9. long term mez
  10. bedlam or whatever mana free rune
  11. self buff shield
  12. group magic resist list goes on
2
DancinginAshes•

I liked neverwinter online interface, where you had lots of options but limited slots.

I hate having forty abilities that I need to have on my screen.

2
kiskoller•

I loved Rift with the gazillion spells I could have. Made keybinding all of them tricky, but well worth the effort. It also required me to have a greater dexterity.

2
SportsBetter•

An ability bar with only 8-10 skills sounds fun at first. Then it turns into a constant chore of swapping out spells/ buffs throughout the night. It doesn't feel like engaging game play anymore

2
RodalliOPDire Lord•

I guess that depends on the pace of gameplay and what kind of experience you're looking for. In an MMO where there was downtime and planning between fights, like EverQuest, it was perfect and very engaging. Especially because the abilities at your disposal were so varied and specialized to a given situation, even within a single class. In EQ, for some classes, at least a quarter of your abilities weren't directly applicable to combat at all, which is pretty unheard of in present day MMOs.

If you're not into an 8-10 ability limit at a given time, then Pantheon may not be the game for you given the dev's plans (at least according to folks here). Looks like they're going with a 10-ability/spell limit.

2
SportsBetter•

Everyone here has this strange "this game may not be for you" if you want something different than EQ classic. I'm playing a shit ton of Agnarr... I know what this game is going to be like.

I understand wanting around 8 combat abilities memed at a time and having those locked for an encounter. You should still have a separate bar for only buffs that are always available. EQ basically has this now with the saved spell lists. Have a combat list saved and a saved buff list. You can quick change between them. It's not a bad compromise but even that sees unnecessary

1
RodalliOPDire Lord•

I'm not telling you that you won't like this game if you don't like EQ "classic". Please don't get confrontational, or defensive, and start accusing me of saying something I'm not saying. I'm telling you that this game is going to have a 10 ability limit at any given time. There won't be a "saved spells list". Not sure what that is, as I don't play on Agnarr.

I'm telling you this because it's literally the question I asked in this submission and got several responses for. It's in the FAQ. The current plan is a 10 ability limit. Boom, done. Of course, that could change. But right now, that's the design. That's all I'm saying.

1
UItraEnchanter•

I just hope they give us a well thought out amount of spaces on our bars. Players should NEVER have to choose between critical abilities because you'll actually lose a sense of balance between classes if you basically have to RNG your skills outside of a "spec" or "skill tree". It wouldnt be fun if you had to gamble on putting "fireball" on your bar hoping your target has "frost shield" on their bar and not "fire shield" because there is no space. Of course, for PvE, you'd probably know which spells would be best. For PvP, it's going to be a race to change your skills in your bar, or hope that you've chosen correctly by default.

VR should also make sure that every class has the same number of "main skills" so that certain classes dont have more "free space" on their bars than others. It would be silly if a WAR needs all 12 buttons to tank, but a WIZ only needs 2 buttons to DPS.

1
Halfwise2Shaman•

This may be a good place to re-emphasize that the game is designed almost exclusively with PvE in mind, and anything PvP will likely be tacked on as an afterthought. So the "choosing correctly" would simply be a matter of intuition or research, and not too big an issue.

Hmmmm, I wonder if the insight ability could help ascertain certaing strengths or weaknesses in a mob.

4
The_Real_Mehndi•

Stupid inane long rotations? please no... Tons of spells for RP/Situation/Flavour so my class feels hella unique and has some fun toys? please yes!

also this is kinda not related but please let there be a dot class based on managing dots and increasing the dot damage and not touching DD filler spells.

1
Vidget•

I don't mind having 24 abilities on my bars, but only a handful of those should be part of the main combat rotation. All the others should be professions, cooldowns, situational abilities, stuff like that.

1
Riposte_ThisWarrior•

I don't mind it either way. I enjoyed everquest 2 running 7 hot bars but I also enjoyed Wildstar running 12 slots on 1 hotbar

1
Quick_FYI•

I always enjoyed ability bloat. Memorizing is just a pain in the arse. I want to be able to fucking click my damn feather fall, not switch around on hotbars and spellbooks to cast it, do whatever I wanted to do that made me need it, and then switch back. Or get stuck in combat because of some stupid mob and have to shit around forever just to get out of combat again and be able to switch my skills.

Nevermind the pain that is having a skill on cooldown and having to wait for it to come off again, just to be able to swap it out.

Augh. Fuck that annoyance. I'd rather have five quickbars with ten slots each to have every single skill in arms reach.

If it's too cluttered for someone, well DON'T PUT THEM ON YOUR SCREEN. You can still click them in your spellbook!

/rant

-2
asteldian•

As far as I am aware it is already decided that a limited hotbar is happening, the debate of all skills vs limited is one that always has people on either side and in the case of Pantheon they have gone with limited.
Done right I actually enjoy limited bars, in GW1 it was awesome, oddly in GW2 it annoyed me.

I would actually quite like a separate hotbar which held 'Utility' spells - designing your hotbar for combat is one thing, but memming out the 30 min/1hr buffs, or that levitate/feather fall is actually a little irritating as they are very much a case of sit, mem, cast, unmem...in other words having no real relevance to combat/strategy, so having a hotbar that could hold a number of these would be nice.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Quick_FYI•

Of course, because then it makes even less sense. Locked into my skill while fighting at least forces me to chose them BEFORE the fight starts. That's ONE somewhat good thing in all the hassle that it's going to cause.

Not locking them in will turn every rotation into a clusterfuck of having to change skills on the fly.

That's some Satan level of evil right there.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Quick_FYI•

...that's a weird question to me. Why would I consider bugs?

0
IvoryApple•

You can still click them in your spellbook!

Well sure, if you can. But in EQ, you can't/couldn't. You have/had to memorize them, first. Hence the whole problem. :)

I'm with you though, I prefer the EQ2 style of hotbars versus the EQ1 spell gems. I would tolerate an in-combat versus out-of-combat UI mechanic, though, if they decide to go with limited set encounters (and forbid skills/spell/gear/weapon swapping IN-combat)

1