[Everything] Theory on CotF
I don't know how to create that cool little hover box that hides spoilers, so I'm just going to warn you now that there are spoilers (kind of) in this theory.
I was thinking about the children of the forest and the deal they made with the first men to, supposedly, end the warfare and stop the white walkers together. Now, we don't know how much of these myths are real and how much is embellishment/false. We're told that the CotF "broke" the arm of Dorne to stop the flow of humans into westeros. Then we're told that during the war they attempted to do the same with the neck to stop the first men from coming further north. My theory is that at least the latter half of this myth is wrong.
I postulate that the humans had already pushed the CotF to the far north (north of where Last Hearth is now) at the peak of the war. That's when the CotF created the white walkers to push back against men. Skipping a few steps and we get to the flooding of the neck. The whites/wights can't swim. What if the CotF, in an attempt to stop their creation's progress south, tried to "break" the neck and lock the whites/wights in the north. That attempt (their first in the same vein as The Wall) obviously didn't work out as they were hoping, so they had to ultimately team up with humans.
I think one of the big things that supports this idea is the fact that all cooperative interactions that we know of between first men and CotF happens below the neck. The deal was made happened on the isle of faces, and they shared the cave on dragonstone. We know they built the wall together, but that was after the long night. Why wouldn't they have made the agreement in the north? Wouldn't it make sense to do it somewhere that was convenient to both parties? What if the first men took on the religion of the old gods to help boost the power that the old gods embued in the CotF to help them break the neck?
I don't know. It's just a theory on the situation. I do believe that they broke the arm of Dorne to stop the influx of humans because it makes logical sense that with fewer CotF, the less powerful their magic would be; so it's not as if they first flooded the neck then broke the arm to keep the walkers in westeros. Let me know what you think or of you just want to add. Thanks.
Posted Sep 24, 2017, 6:50 AM UTC
love your analysis of a typically-untouched subject. I think you might be completely right. I hope we get a deeper look at the history of the COTF/First men/WW in the final season or at the very least - in the books to come. Kudos brother.