r/FeMRADebates•
ispq

The B in X-Men is Silent: Bisexuality & X-Men

Relationships

Someone I know has been writing articles about comics, X-Men and mutants mostly, and this article got me thinking:

Specifically both about the appropriateness of using the comic book as a means to show a mirror to society, and how effective that mirror is at times. The X-Men were originally written up back in the 1960's as a metaphor for the Civil Rights Movement. The Mutant Metaphor has been used over the years to shed light on various issues and forms of oppression in society, such as the Legacy Virus as a stand in for AIDS, and the mutants of Genosha as a stand in for both South Africa and Nazi Germany.

How useful a tool are modern US comic books for shedding light on human sexuality in today's society?

Posted Oct 3, 2017, 9:47 PM UTC

46
Russelsteapot42Egalitarian Gender Skeptic•

I find this... annoying to read. It comes off with a tone that suggests that bisexuals are entitled to representation in X-Men, which I really can't get behind. The need to convict comic creators of 'silencing' or 'biphobia' for this failure just doesn't jive with me, especially as the same article is highly critical of X-men's attempts to portray same sex relationships in the past. Can we really blame writers for being hesitant to explore such a sensitive subject in a culture that is so eager to crucify them for any percieved misstep?

11
BegferdethSupreme Overlord Deez Nutz•

I can't really get behind this article, especially when it has lines like this:

It is unreasonable and biphobic that the audience is asked to accept, without textual evidence, that one same-sex relationship means the character is bisexual.

A character has a same sex relationship, has an opposite sex relationship, and this isn't enough to be bisexual? If that doesn't count, what possibly could? If you need them to have multiple partners of each gender, to fit that into a storyline you would end up with the other end of biphobia: "Bisexuals are all sluts". I don't think that's much better.

Then there is the problem that the characters that ARE bisexual enough for her apparently don't have enough "screen time"...

However, the reveal of her bisexuality took place in 2013 and has not come up since. Even with her popularity, she has appeared in no more than 125 comics since coming out as textually bisexual.

"No more than 125 comics"... in 4 years? There's only 48 months there, that's ~3 appearances per month, that isn't enough screen time for your favorite character? How high do you set the bar? There's only so many comics in a month, and you gotta make room for the other thousand or so people in the Marvelverse.

If they want to do it the "Mutant Metaphor" way, then bisexual people are all over the place in Marvel. Spiderman has a normal girlfriend (Mary Jane), a superpowered girlfriend (Black Cat), one that I'm never really sure (Gwen), does he count as bisexual if Mutants are a metaphor for gay? Wolverine too... his first wife in the movies was normal, then he gets the hots for Jean Grey. Mutant Metaphor has bisexuality totally covered!

9
YetAnotherCommenterSupporter of the MHRM and Individualist Feminism•

A character has a same sex relationship, has an opposite sex relationship, and this isn't enough to be bisexual? If that doesn't count, what possibly could?

The author seems to think that only being an out-and-proud, explicitly-declared, with-the-exact-word "bisexual" counts as bisexual representation.

3
GodotIsWaiting4UEccentric Free Agent•

616 Gwen has never had superpowers. I think the only version that ever got any is Spider-Gwen, who’s from an alternate universe.

1
YetAnotherCommenterSupporter of the MHRM and Individualist Feminism•

As a Bi dude, and an X-Men fan, I just want to say this...

Chris Claremont originally wanted to write Wolverine as bisexual. Its the higher-ups who stopped him from doing so. Also, Storm has been implied to be bisexual on more than one occasion.

Really I find it frustrating that we have... not merely identity-politics but label politics. Someone who consistently has relationships with members of the same sex but doesn't scream "I'm GAAAAY" whilst practically farting rainbows? Not sufficient to be gay representation, allegedly. Because behaving in an exclusively same-sex-attracted fashion isn't enough... merely showing the audience the character's sexuality is nothing... the audience must be told.

And I think this is actually kind of bad. This fixation on the Quaint Little Categories reinforces stereotypes and makes it harder for individuals to forge their own identities. It reinforces the idea of these categories as determining basically everything about one's life, and it obliterates diversity within these categories. It also treats the audience as incapable of identifying with characters outside their identity categories.

In addition I think its actually bad for bisexual representation. Why? One of the great things about a non-declarative canon is that it makes it impossible to disprove any specific character as bisexual. So what if character X has only had two relationships before and both with a member of the opposite sex? Character X could still have a few same-sex flings on the side, just off screen! A non-declarative canon, in other words, makes bisexuality as much of a plausible tacit default as heterosexuality.

And not only that, but allowing the fanbase to use their own minds broaden's a character's appeal and makes it easier for wider demographics to identify with them. So why not just let the audience imagine what they wish?

5
GrizzledFartNeutral•

Crap like this is much more about getting someone to fall in line than anything else. As u/Begferdeth said:

A character has a same sex relationship, has an opposite sex relationship, and this isn't enough to be bisexual? If that doesn't count, what possibly could? If you need them to have multiple partners of each gender, to fit that into a storyline you would end up with the other end of biphobia: "Bisexuals are all sluts". I don't think that's much better.

There is never a correct answer. There isn't supposed to be a correct answer except to grovel.

3