r/Coffee•
ecle

Bonavita brewing very sour coffee but also nearly overflowing?

I have had my Bonavita 1900ts (the thermal carafe) for a year, and I keep it in my office. I have recently changed jobs and now suddenly the coffee is always very sour.

Intensely sour. Drain pour sour.

I am doing everything the same as in the past when it was fine. or even bitter.

It is also coming close to overflowing in the basket. Lots of foamy bloom-looking stuff going on (even when the coffee beans are not that fresh). It may have been doing that before, though, and I just didn’t notice because I wasn’t anxiously staring while it brewed.

I don’t understand why suddenly my coffee seems underextracted.

Amount: I always make the “8 cups” (40 ounces).

Grind: Capresso Infinity set to one notch away from the center (so on the finer end of medium).

Filters: Melitta filters, prerinse them.

Coffee: Whole Foods Allegro Cafe La Duena medium roast—the same type of coffee as always (and have even tried a different bag in case something was weird with the first one). I also tried a different roaster and beans just in case and got very sour coffee.

Adjustments I’ve Tried: finer grind, different beans, more coffee, less coffee, a LOT more coffee, more time to drip after it turns itself off.

The coffee compass troubleshooting doesn’t seem to be helping me here. There is something odd going on. or I am crazy. or incompetent.

tl;dr: If more coffee and finer grind don’t fix sour taste, what is going on? The only thing that has changed is my location (no elevation changes though!)

Posted Oct 6, 2017, 2:42 PM UTC · edited

4215
Kozzer•

Have you tried using the Coffee Compass?

If things were working well before but aren't now, I ask the obvious: when was the last time you descaled and cleaned the bonavita?

14
TheFenixor•

Not OP but thank you so much for this! I've been looking for a Troubleshooting Guide like this myself.

2
tayfife•

I have the exact same unit. For some reason the water isn't draining into the carafe correctly, and therefore causing it to almost over flow, and over extract the coffee, not under extract it—which is what is making it taste bad.

I was going through the same issues as you. Then I switched my filters, and all my problems went away.

Humor me on this one... don't pre-rinse your filter, and just make sure it's stretched out to all the sides in the basket, before placing the grounds in. Let me know what happens. Or try using a different, slightly sturdier filter. What's happening is the filter is sagging into the hole in the bottom of the basket, and clogging it up, which restricts the flow of coffee into the carafe.

10
xenonsupraCortado•

I also have the BV1900 and agree with this. I would definitely stop pre-rinsing your filter. The machine was not designed for that.

If that doesn't help, try a new brand/batch of filters, maybe yours were bad for some reason. I use the brown Melitta.

I disagree with the posts above saying it is your water. That may account for subtle differences but not this.

Do you have the pre-infusion mode on/off? Shouldn't matter but just curious.

Also, do you have a scale? Can you post your coffee/water weights?

8
uggghhhggghhh•

Wouldn't over-extraction yield bitter flavor, though, not sour?

2
tayfife•

Sometimes people confuse those two things. Not necessarily saying OP is, but if the basket is "almost overflowing", and not draining properly—that almost always creates an over extraction problem. If the coffee is in fact sour, I'd say it it likely due to another variable, other than extraction time.

2
uggghhhggghhh•

Yeah, that makes sense. I was thinking possibly damage to the machine during the move and now it's not heating the water enough.

2
chitochitochito•

It's your water.

8
Muskowekwan•

Water won't make a huge difference like this. The drain is probably clogged due to pre-wetting or switching filters.

Honestly water is completely overhyped in this sub because most people don't have great grinders or other equipment that is consistent enough to eliminate as variables. Yes water is important but testing it in a home setting is hard, if not impossible with consumer grade equipment. Even something like a lido will produce enough fines to throw off extraction then the difference water will make. Never mind other factors such as the roast levels between batches of beans, the humidity, etc.

4
mirthilous•

It would be easy to test to see if it the water. Just bring in water from home and see if it is different,

1
lunchb0x91•

perhaps your new office is using reverse osmosis filtered water. lack of minerals in the water could lead to under extraction. try bringing water in from home and use that and see if it makes a difference.

If that is the issue, you can just continue to bring water from home or use this article to make remineralized water at the office. https://baristahustle.com/blogs/barista-hustle/water-recipe

7
uggghhhggghhh•

Could be some damage to the machine in the moving process? Maybe it's not heating the water well enough anymore? I'd try to contact Bonavita and see if they can help you out.

3
atomic92•

Have the exact same setup as you.

Don't Pre-rinse your filter and use the pre-soak method on the Bonavita. You can also try a different filter.

Also try a coarser grind, Mine is set to the first or second notch on Medium. Clean the machine out, you may have something gumming up the works and causing the beans to get over ground.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
BurntPaperAmericano•

Is the spout clogged with hard water buildup? Or maybe your coffee is TOO fine, and instead of passing through properly, the water is flowing around the filter and skipping the coffee.

1
atomic92•

If you get a chance, time how long it takes to brew a half pot or full pot of coffee until the grounds aren't swimming any more and you are only getting a couple drips from the basket. The water is likely over extracting the grounds, causing the bitter taste

1
Nymeria9•

Is your grinder to blame? Is it getting old? When I had this it was because my grinder was making lots of fines. Fixed my grinder and issue resolved.

1