r/HomeKit•
DericusB

door sensor options

Hi all, I recently added the elgato eve door sensor to my closest door to automate the lights on when opening the door . The response time is around 3 seconds. The hub is fairly close and yes it does respond faster after opening and closing the door a few time. I think it has more to do with the device waking up.

Beside the elgato and fibaro door sensor, are any other door sensor?

Has anyone used the fibaro and eve, how do they compare to each other 1 on 1? most of the reviews are for one or the other.

Posted Oct 6, 2017, 6:39 PM UTC

47
krmkrx•

There will be near instant response times for Elgato Eve Products with an upcoming firmware update for the devices, if you are on iOS 11. See blog.elgato.com

4
DericusBOP•

Thanks, I’ll keep an eye out for an update. Hopefully it includes the door sensor.

1
ItsDBack•

These sensors will be part of the update: “soon after iOS 11 launches, Elgato will publish firmware updates for certain sensor-based accessories (namely Eve Motion, Eve Door & Window, and Eve Light Switch), which will enable user commands and automation to be processed with minimal delay.”

https://blog.elgato.com/ios-11-new-homekit-features-better-responsiveness-for-eve-accessories/

3
ItsDBack•

Chris Young on youtube has reviewed both:

Fibaro: https://youtu.be/Tb6O0Sctj6o

Elgato: https://youtu.be/yQXYjFARYJ0

2
RichardBLine•

I have both of these sensors. For my application, I believe the Eve is the better product for the following reasons:

  1. The eve product comes with spacers and the Fibaro does not. The smaller piece of the two sensors is not the same height as the larger piece. Also, over time, you might find that your house settles and the door and door jam are not aligned as thy once were. To remedy all of these cases, Elgato provides about 6 spacers with the product. You can stack the spacers together, and connect them to the smaller contact sensor to raise it to the height of the larger contact sensor in order to align them and have a better contact. if your house is old, you will find this indispensable in aligning the two contact sensor.

  2. The Eve keeps a log of when the door opens and closes. I believe it's a rolling log and the data is over written after a month.

  3. The Bluetooth antenna seems to be a lot better in the Eve product. The Fibaro product looses contact with Homekit quite a bit, and it's installed at the same distance the Eve product is from my Apple TV. The Eve product doesn't loose the connection as much. But this will depend on how many walls are separating the products from your Apple TV. But in my case, the Fibaro is much more finicky.

  4. Elgato comes out with more updates to their app than Fibaro does to fix issues. Fibaro drags their feet when providing updates.

  5. There are clear markings on the Eve product on how to align the two sensor pieces. The Fibaro does not have any markings.

The only thing I don't like about the Eve product is the battery compartment. It's tough to get it open to put in the battery. Other than that, I think the Eve product is much better.

2
jdowney83•

I know it is a little different, but have you thought about a motion sensor if you have Hue lights/hub. The hue motion sensor is pretty instant, I do have hue lights so maybe it will be slightly slower with other lights.

1
RichardBLine•

Even if you don't have Hue lights, I would recommend the Hue motion sensor, since it can now trigger Homekit devices. It's crazy fast. Right now, it's faster than any other Homekit motion sensor I have.

2