r/CLG•
MTOB

[LoL] Potential Roster acquisition given recent news

Recently Jacob Wolf reported that many teams did not end up making the cut for the upcoming LCS season. The rosters of all of those teams will become free agents as their contracts will be immediately terminated. I think CLG should give former Immortal's jungler Jake "Xmithie" Puchero a shot on their team, last split he proved to be a force to be reckoned with and I feel like with him on our team we could potentially even make finals at MSI or something like that.

Posted Oct 18, 2017, 3:48 PM UTC

5160
mint420PewFat•

Might be an unpopular opinion, but I would rather CLG go for a different jungler. Love Xmithie and I wouldn't hate having him back on CLG, but remember that CLG parted ways with him for a reason to begin with. Both he and the org had stagnated... actually not even, they were legit getting worse as time went on. Not that it was his fault, but he needed a change of scenery and CLG needed to inject something new into the team.

It sucks CLG didn't make worlds, but IDK if another go-around with Xmithie is what the team needs.

55
vquislingKelby•

totally see where you're coming from. i love xmithie and i wish him the best, and i would LOVE to see him on CLG again.

will always support him 100% wherever he goes, unless he goes over to TSM. that would hurt :(

20
defiantketchupRespect all, Fear None.•

Oh god. Now that you mention he makes a great TSM candidate.

Wasn’t he the only one against kicking Doublelift? Definitely an upgrade over Sven and their weak ass early game shot calling.

8
ForCasteStixxay•

Xmithie would definitely solve their problems but it would break my heart to see it

13
ZerwursterCLG•

In theory, remember when they had one of the best western shotcallers in Yellowstar and went on to have a really shitty split because no one was following on his calls? Could happen with Xmithie too.

1
AngryCLGFanLiNk•

Weren’t there rumors that doublelift was trying to get other people on CLG to join him on TSM? Just a rumor I read, pls no hurt the messenger.

2
MarstonX•

yup, he tried to get darshan and xmithie to leave clg.

4
Noah__WebsterHuhi•

Makes me wonder if the stint with IMT reinvigorated him though. It's been proven he fits well with the team stylistically if he is on top of his game. I think people also forget how fucking hard he was popping off during MSI, and even the two splits we won titles. He was great on tanks, but his Nidalee and Kindred were super sick too.

I'm obviously biased because he is one of my favorite players of all time (both as a player and a person), but I think we would be insane if we had peak Xmithie again.

4
recursion8bigfatlp•

I don't think he got worse, I think the meta shifted away from his preferred style of control/support jungling towards carry/assassin junglers. Remember why Akkadian and Inori and the like looked like gods? If we bring him back we can mold Omar exclusively for carry jungling to complement Xmithie, so we'll be safe in either meta.

2
mint420PewFat•

If we bring him back we can mold Omar exclusively for carry jungling to complement Xmithie, so we'll be safe in either meta.

That's actually not a bad idea, seeing as Omar apparently like carry junglers before he played pro.

It depends on whether CLG can actually execute on using them both if needbe though, especially with Bo1s coming back. It might be better to just try and get a jungler who can do both.

9
rudebrookeDexter•

Omar would get murdered in a carry jungle meta - let's be real.

Just because he likes to play them in soloq does not mean he would make a good professional carry jungler.

Last season he was playing in the most forgiving professional jungle meta I have ever seen. Cinderhulk champions in a meta with huge catch up XP and higher respawn times on camps (less decision making/pathing options available - therefore harder to make a mistake) and he STILL managed to get dicked most of the time - imagine how useless he would be if he gets invaded and killed playing Lee Sin twice with no catch up XP to use as a crutch...

If you want a carry jungler, sign Lira or Reignover. If you want a support jungler sign Xmithie.

0
tb9910•

I definitely agree with you. We should be looking forward instead of back. Jake seemed really happy with Immortals so he had his reasons. I think he only performed so well this split because he had a new team around him. Sometimes you just need a new environment, so asking him to come back seems to be a bit much.

There’s a lot of other talent out there we’ll definitely find someone and smash the next season :)

2
callmekanaCLG•

LirA or bust.

2
Will_OzellmanDARSHAAN?•

Would like to see xmithie on clg with a good top and mid at the same time

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
A4LMAAphromoo•

I'm so split, on one hand we got rid of Jake for a reason and if we brought him back we might see the same problems we had before BUT on the other hand thats my FUCKEN boy and I would die if Jake joined TSM.

43
mikelo22Donezo•

The image of Xmithie's dad rooting for TSM in the crowd sends cold shivers down my spine.

30
YachiruChinWestrice is best rice•

Oh God! Plz. No!

8
Bill_Martigans•

Not like this. First Double then Jake?

6
WarWrenBIG DIXXAY•

We “got rid” of Jake because he wanted to leave. I think CLG would be open to having him back if it was in his interests.

3
heroduderox•

Why do people keep spreading the narrative that we kicked Xmithie? He wanted out, jesus christ.

3
Nefari0ussCLG•

I know I've been pretty vocal that I think Omar should be given a whole split but if we are to make just changes I see the following viable choices:

  • Xmithie - Pros are well known. Existing synergy with team. Control heavy jungler focused on neutralizing opponent (best style IMO for international performance if your laners can perform). Very smart adaptive pathing. Excels at tanks including Tony's bae Gragas. Can carry on Nid/Kindred but not assassins like Kha or Rengar. Cons are also kinda well known. Mechanics are seen as 'poor'. Huge potential to do well and make a MSI/deep worlds run if things come together nicely. I can go on about how much I love Xmithie for a long time so I'm a bit biased.

  • ReignOver - Similar style to Xmithie and supportive jungler. Can speak English. 'New', atleast to CLG. Strong pathing. Speaks Korean with Huhi. (Don't underestimate the value of having a person from the same culture in the environment.) Cons are that he has a very high price tag and may perform like he is on TL (his role in TL performance can be debated).

  • Lira - High mechanics, early game monster. His first split in NA he was best of the year and debuted the 'Lira Path'. Should have decent English?? Cons are trouble in late game with closing (NV in general had this problem).

  • OmarGod - young, mechanically talented. Great attitude for growth on a team with a track record of success with rookies. Should excel in carry jungle meta. Can be molded in to whatever team needs. Cons are that he may have low ceiling. If he has high ceiling it might take some time to get there (see Huhi) which would require giving up a split for long term success.

I'll format it when I get home.

Edit: some responses about MikeYeung. I consider him and Omar to be pretty much the same. We haven't seen enough for me to say either is all that different.

13
XMatthewHotshotGG•

I would also add Mikeyung because he would fit the "develop players" mentality that CLG has, I also think he has a higher ceiling compared to Omar.

4
recursion8bigfatlp•

I would not count on LirA's English. Remember he had Korean top laner and mid laner to work with, and they just left their bot lane on an island.

3
Nefari0ussCLG•

Ok. I had the question marks because I wasn't sure.

1
rudebrookeDexter•

Nisqy wasn't Korean and Envy performed better with him than either of their Korean mids.

1
ragnao•

CLG Mikeyueng?

3
Narnak•

I think Reignover is the best short term fit and Moon is the best long term fit. Mike Yeung is decent but I think Moon as more potential. Lira is super good but I'm hard against anyone without good english.

2
Nefari0ussCLG•

I'm personally a bit skeptical of moon without Hai. He might be very good. But what makes you think Moon would be better long-term over Hai.

2
MaradonaGoat•

Give me back mah boy Xmithie.

7
SBenda•

I don't see enough people talking about Lira. I really hope he is the one they go after. I think the main problem with CLG right now is how lackluster their early games are and that stems from the jungle. We all know they can 5v5 shot call and team fight but they need someone who can get then leads and make plays pre 20 mins.

5
recursion8bigfatlp•

LirA's English level is unknown. Given on NV he played with Seraph and Ninja/Pirean as his solo laners and they left English speaking bot lane on an island, I would not count on it.

2
SBenda•

If you listen to the comms from the NV games he actually has really good English.

4
recursion8bigfatlp•

Fair enough. I don't follow them enough to know, was making educated guess.

1
SplycedGG•

Do you know where we can find the vods w comms? I checked and couldn't find any on google but maybe I'm blind lol

1
SBenda•

Don't think they have vods of full games. The ones I'm talking about were from the Mic Checks on YouTube

2
SwervyLovesDvaCounter Logic Gaming•

You can’t go to the league YouTube page and they highlight games like 2-3 minutes per match and during the highlights they show them shotcalling during a won team fight or objective steal/take.

1
KazumaVongolaCLG•

I would love to see Xmithie back. I know him and aphro didn't see eye to eye on some things but I feel that they could work it out.

4
wtf_is_takenHotshotGG•

Really?

1
Diamond4ox•

Nah Xmithie wanted to leave during the off-season and aphro didn't even knew about it. aphro was told that Xmithie when he came back to the gaming house.

1
a78dthrowLolmithie•

I think grabbing Jake and Mike yeung wouldn't be a bad idea. They could work in tandem and Jake can help mentor Mike and Omar. Ideally having two junglers who have different playstyles would be great so we don't get the fiasco that was xmithie on Rengar ever again.

3
eatyourdinherCLG•

lol both? they are both deserving full time starters on any NALCS squad

1
Zerclgg•

Xmithie is always a good choice. He is a reliable supportive and strong jungler. It still was very refreshing to see a playmaking jungler like Dardoch, and i think that aggressive playstyle took some earlygame preasure off them and fit the team very well. The human on the other hand somehow didn't fit.

Final thought: If Xmithie is free, he's one who should at least be considered, imo.

3
Realshotgg•

+Xmithie +Olleh

3
MonteDoa•

Didn't Xmithie want to leave CLG? His mom said he wasn't too happy with the org. Assuming his mom is telling the truth I can't imagine how CLG is going to get him back.

Edit: corrected by someone else, Xmithie did not ask to leave, although he was indeed unhappy with the organization.

3
recursion8bigfatlp•

Getting real tired of debunking this every week on this sub.

8
MonteDoa•

Yea my bad the whole situations is pretty confusing. Xmithie is known to be unhappy with the org but he also didn't ask to leave. There's probably some sort of semantics game going on there but I don't know the behind-the-scenes stuff so I can't say what's really going on.

Here's Xmithie's mom saying he wasn't happy with the org though

https://np.reddit.com/r/CLG/comments/6pkyge/lol_farewell_dardoch_welcome_omargod_clgamingnet/dkq5pv0/

You can understand why I made that mistake. People usually want to leave organizations they're unhappy with, especially if that unhappiness was to a level that affected their performance.

7
recursion8bigfatlp•

My guess is he was unhappy immediately after Spring playoffs where we flunked out at 5th/6th in embarassing reverse sweep fashion, and expressed that with the org when they did post-split exit meetings. But then as his mom says, after vacation/break he felt remotivated to stay with CLG for Summer but the team probably didn't consult with him a 2nd time and just moved him.

1
thesuperpersonTrick2LG•

I mean my perception was that he was not for or against leaving and the team decided to take a risk as opposed to going into another year, with the trend being a stagnating roster.

1
HibbitishHuhi•

I'd welcome Xmithie back with open arms if he and the team wanted it.

3
bakaimono123•

CLG OLLEH!!

3
recursion8bigfatlp•

BRING BACK XMITHIE AND THE P.O.B. Get Flame too, so we can get vanilla Flame and Brown Flame vanilla Spartan and YellowSpartan on one team.

2
JustBronzeThingsLoLAphromoo•

I'd love to have him back... but does he want to come back?

2
shakyturnip•

I wouldn't be too surprised if Xmithie ended up on TSM... ugh

2
daniel5426Aphromoo•

Xmithie might retire, anyone worth signing from IMT would be Olleh imo. I still think Lira and Hakuho are the best free agents pair to get

1†
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
ionxephCLG•

I want xmithie back so much, partly because he is one of my favorite players overall

Though I have some doubts on if that will really be the best for CLG in the long run

1
iGreatness•

It's just me who would love to have CLG KaKao? :{}

1
Baltej16In Zikz We Trust•

If omar doesnt get the boot and its to prevent xmithie from joining the forces of evil then we should welcome him

1