r/Twitch•
bguyle

Streaming with capture device compared to system with built-in features.

Tech Support

Hey everybody I've been streaming off and on for the last couple years on my PS4 and haven't really had many issues when it comes to the actual broadcast. Fast forward to a few months back when I bought an Elgato Game Capture HD so that I could stream and record other consoles that don't have sharing features.

So when I stream on my PS4 I usually stream with high quality settings, maybe not maxed because I want cell phone viewers to not deal with buffering but still high settings regardless. Now whenever I stream on my Elgato it seems like there is always some issue, mainly with the bitrate and upload speeds but other problems come up too like mic input dropping. It's gotten to the point where I run an internet speed test before streaming, adjust my bitrate accordingly and still I've had bandwidth low messages while my stream fragments or just doesn't keep up.

I guess the main point of this post is a two parter, why does my quality and maybe even upload speed seem to fluctuate to such a great extent where it derails my stream and do others streamers coming from consoles to more advanced set ups feel like it's almost not worth the trouble dealing with all the extra hurdles?

Posted Oct 19, 2017, 4:46 PM UTC

611
Old_Ronintwitch.tv/ramenly•

I used to stream PS4 from the twitch app directly from the console and hated its limitations. I used the elgato hd60 pro with no issue, but personally I like to use PS4 Remote Play since it's less hassle to set up (and it's free)

2
bguyleOPwww.twitch.tv/bguyle•

Remote play isn't for streaming though unless I'm missing something? Unless you're talking about remote playing and capturing off the system... In which case that sounds great, if I could just get past my initial problems.

1
Old_Ronintwitch.tv/ramenly•

Yes, you can use remote play to mirror your PS4 gameplay onto another screen (I use my PC monitor) and use a streaming software (I use OBS) to stream the mirrored gameplay. I noticed no input lag either.

3
bguyleOPwww.twitch.tv/bguyle•

Very clever! I didn't even think about trying this, but wouldn't this eat up more bandwidth that normal in order to Remote play too? I feel like this is great idea after I sort these initial problems out.

1
Old_Ronintwitch.tv/ramenly•

Hardly. I mean, I have decent internet connection so I've never noticed any lag. It's free and takes 5 minutes to set up so couldn't hurt to try out. :)

3
Jollyriffictwitch.tv/Jollyriffic•

There are a few issues here. first is never use the software that comes with any capture device. They are inferior to OBS. There is one singualr nice thing about capture cards and it's that they have onboard processing, at least for the PCIe cards. Helpful if you have a weak or lower core count than 4 (pretty much anything that isn't higher tier i5/i7 or 4-core 8-thread ryzen or higher). Next is that it sounds like you have network issues. This could be due to the following 1.) poor signal from the ISP, when weather changes or even new users jump onto the line you're on the signal DB changes. Only a tech can come out and adjust your lines to be within a decent margin. Just like with wifi, you don't want too low or high of a db, that leads to poor transmission. this has nothing to do with your wifi its the internet line that comes to your house. 2.) your router could be a steaming pile of junk, i have bought everything from $500 and down at walmart and bestbuy, they are all actually junk the main issue being their operating system that they use and the lack luster coding and parts used. If you have an all-in-one, that's a major problem, those are even worse. If you have an all-in-one, swap it out for just the modem then pick up something like https://www.amazon.com/dp/B01BMMK4HI It looks basic AF but this is like one of those sleeper twin turbo gutted cars that eat motorcycles alive. this is the brand network admins use at their home; ask me how i know :) 3.) Another issue could be simply your ethernet cables, your ethernet on the pc is kind of "meh", or even your wifi on the computer is "meh" quality. When streaming over wifi, people say that it's worse, honestly it's not. In reality i get lower ping on wifi than with ethernet and i run shielded cat7 cables. Cat5 is typically is what people use in their house, simply because they don't know what any of it means. the higher cat number the more bandwidth and less packet loss you should have. you can get cables in both shielded and unshielded, in short a metal barrier is between the line actual copper lines and the outside world, this keeps interference from decaying the singles transmitted in the lines. in some cases ethernet can actually be worse for streaming than wifi. So what you want to first do, is call the ISP ask them to look at your signal to them and explain that your internet is pretty erratic while trying to live stream. While on the phone with them, see if there's any better packages you can jump on (mostly to lower your bill, it's good to call about every 6 months), next if you have an all-in-one, swap it out and order the router i have listed above. I would also recommend picking up at least 1x shielded cat7 cable. this would go from the modem to the new router. If you like to hardline, pick up a second for the modem to the pc or whatever else you want to hardline. Keep those cables as short as they require. further the distance, the more issues you could potentially have. Not really something that you need to put too much worry into as a home user, but the less distance that signal travels = less time to talk with the router, modem, hub, network, world.. the router i listed does actually have a ton of options inside of it, makes DDWRT and Tomato look like tinker toys and beats them in all sorts of performance and quality. There is a quick setup and you honestly do not need anything more than that screen and the update screen.

Some other things, never use the app that kicks the ps4 or xbox to the computer then stream that. if you must for whatever reason, make sure your output is identical to the size of the box you're capturing. Most people screw that up and stream at say 1080 or higher when the box they are capturing is far less. This results in massive video fedility corruption. If nothing else it sort of looks like a extra soft filter was put onto the video. Really just looks like someone screwed up all their settings, because they have.

2
bguyleOPwww.twitch.tv/bguyle•

Thank you so much for all this, I'm at work right now so I can't properly digest this all and respond but I will be sure to do so when I can!

1
bguyleOPwww.twitch.tv/bguyle•

Thank you for the advice I've implemented as much as I can, router and modem are set up much better I think too. Tonight's test run seems to be going just fine too.

1
Thulacktwitch.tv/Thulack•

Do you use OBS to stream or are you using El gato software? Also if you are setting your bitrate to what your bandwidth is your are going to have lag issues. Try setting your bitrate at like 2k.

1
bguyleOPwww.twitch.tv/bguyle•

I'm using Elgato's software when capturing, when setting my bitrate I try to aim for half of my upload rate and even though I'll go a little lower. Like if I'm pulling 10mbs upload I'll set a bitrate of like 4-4.5.

1
Thulacktwitch.tv/Thulack•

Yeah try setting it at like 2k and maybe try OBS for streaming.

2