Michigan Conservatory Wedding: October 14, 2017, 78 people, $15k - Photos & Summary plus Budget, Guest, and Alcohol Breakdowns

Our wedding happened on Saturday and I am so happy! Here are the sneak peeks from our photographer. I'll post some of these individually when I'm talking about various elements in the recap below.

I underestimated how nervous I would be. The week leading up to it, I was a frantic mess. There were so many last-minute things to do, I felt like I was constantly going. And then the day of, I was excited, but since our venue was DIY and we didn't have a planner/coordinator, I just felt the pressure of so many moving parts. For the most part, it all came together, but it was nerve-wracking. My husband (!) felt the same.

To me, the best part was the ceremony. There was a moment right before I walked down the aisle, where the bridesmaids and groomsmen were behind all this greenery and I could see the white chairs with everyone seated, and everyone had flowers, and the string musicians were playing and it was all just so rich and lush and full and beautiful (and I thought I am so glad we got the string musicians). Our venue had a max of 100 people but some would have had to stand, so our final number of 78 was perfect - everyone had a seat but it still looked full. My favorite compliments about the wedding were the (several different!) people who told us it was the most beautiful ceremony they had seen/heard, and I'm proud of it - I think it struck the right balance of personal and ritualistic. His father walked him down the aisle, and both my parents walked me down. His sister walked down with his father's wife, placed a single white rose on an empty chair for their late mother, and officiated. SIL was awesome - she was a perfect mix of funny and serious and lots of people commented on what a great job she did. Aside from her welcome/intro, we wrote the whole ceremony ourselves. My husband is a published poet and I am ABD in English lit and taught it for years, so expectations were high, but I think we pulled it off. We printed a found poem that is fragments of poetry about love through history and attached it to the program, which SIL/officiant referred to in her opening; we had one of my friends read a selection from Wendell Berry's "Poetry and Marriage" and a bridesmaid read Denise Levertov's "About Marriage." (Seriously, if you are looking for selections, read these, they are so beautiful!) We did a wine ceremony. We read structured affirmations to each other (e.g. we each answered "What everyone knows about you is [x], but also, [y]" and other prompts like it) and then the vows we wrote together for the ring ceremony.

My friends and family were amazing. My mom, dad, FIL, and SMIL went an hour and a half or so early to set up decor alongside the caterers (who set up the tables, chairs, bar, and centerpieces), and did a beautiful job. My friend who loaned us the sound equipment was basically the sound guy and kept things running smoothly. I had been nervous about people dancing with no DJ and just the Spotify playlists I put together, but it was great - our photographer told us we had "the BEST playlists!" and I think almost the whole wedding was on the floor for "Uptown Funk" and just about every couple for "I Can't Help Falling in Love With You." My bridesman was a great MC, introducing the speeches and formal dances. And of course my sister-in-law was an awesome officiant. And it was great hanging out with my bridespeople and SIL on the day of - we basically took over a salon in town, they let us have champagne and a private room, and it was just really fun.

The koozie favors were a surprising hit! I mean, a lot of people didn't take them, but a few of our friends were all "these are such a good favor! So useful!" Our rule about putting our names and dates on a favor is that if it's a thing you might have a company name on, it's fine - so I think it passed that bar.

Also, I loved my eucalyptus head wreath! The florist did a great job with it. I had planned to take it off after the ceremony, but ended up wearing it all night.

Things that went wrong:

  1. It rained all day, which sucked. We had an indoor wedding largely because we know Michigan weather in fall is unpredictable, but it meant we couldn't take outdoor photos on the grounds of the botanical gardens or really make use of the fall color. We snuck in our first look outside before it started again, but that's it.

  2. The cocktail hour was supposed to be in the Conservatory, where we had the reception, but apparently our point person at the caterer didn't communicate well with her team and they set up the bar in the reception space and failed to move the ceremony chairs. Which meant that everyone sort of hung out in the lobby between the two for cocktail hour, which is like a gift shop/front desk with some tables and chairs. Not ideal.

  3. The speeches were really long, and the caterers waited until they finished to start serving dinner, even though I had wanted them to serve it during speeches. The high school friends contingent of the groomsmen were supposed to give a speech at the rehearsal dinner, but one had to come in the day-of and another's flight was delayed, so they did it at the wedding, along with my bridesman as an MC intro, my MoH, his BM, my mom, his dad, and my dad, almost all of whom went longer than the 3-5 minutes we said. This pushed everything later - dinner started around 8pm (luckily there had been plenty of appetizers before, and there was salad and bread on the table, but still) and formal dances weren't until almost 9pm. Our photographer was AMAZING in adapting, though - we were only supposed to have the second photographer for 5 hours, but she ended up staying the whole 7 (3-10pm), and said not to worry about the money.

  4. Our first dance was ridiculous. We had taken dance lessons and loved them, but forgot everything we learned once we were up there.

I think my biggest mistake was not making an info sheet for the caterers. I made them for my parents/in-laws for setting up, my friend for the sound system, my bridesman for MCing, but the catering point person just seemed so on top of things from our walk-through that I didn't fret too much about them and considered it handled. It wasn't a disaster or anything, but would have been better if they had had some key bits of info.

Budget breakdown:

ExpenseDetailsCost
VenueBotanical gardens ceremony (Conservatory) & reception (Auditorium) spaces, tables and chairs, parking$2450
CateringAppetizers, salad, plated dinner with two entrée options, three sides, beverages, and pies for dessert; dishes, flatware, glassware, equipment and other rentals; servers, bartenders, cooks, managers, tax, fees$4778
Alcohol3 cases of Bell's Two Hearted, 1 case Atwater Vanilla Java Porter, 2 cases Miller High Life, 2 cases Sam Adams, and 8 bottles each of Chardonnay, Sauvignon Blanc, Cabernet Sauvignon, Merlot, and 12 bottles Champagne$697
Photography7 hours of two shooters, engagement session, rights to all photos$2500
MusicViolin and cello duo and sound equipment for ceremony (reception music was a Spotify playlist and borrowed sound equipment/mic from a friend)$375
FlowersBridal bouquet, bridal head wreath, 4 bridesmaid bouquets, groom's boutonnière, 8 boutonnières for groomsmen, bridesman, fathers; 3 corsages for my mom, his stepmom, and his sister (officiant), white rose to commemorate his mom, loose eucalyptus for tables, tax and delivery$430
Decor14 geometric terrariums and succulents for centerpieces (terrariums on top of two books, surrounded by eucalyptus) and card box; guest book; string lights; signs$450
DressCustom top from Wear Your Love and Lulu's dress altered to make a skirt$495
SuitExpress charcoal jacket and slacks$130
ShoesCustom bridal shoes$110
TiesFrom thetiebar.com - 7 for groom, groomsmen, and bridesman$147
Hair & makeupHair & makeup for 7 people (me, my mom, 4 bridesmaids, and SIL, who was our officiant)$750
PaperSave-the-date magnets, invitations, RSVP cards, envelopes, postage, programs, seat assignment cards, thank-yous, all from Vistaprint$400
Ceremony props3 copper goblets, decanter, wine for wine ceremony, and gold shawl for officiant$120
FavorsPersonalized koozies (bartenders used them on the beer bottles to pass out)$115
Marriage licenseIn Michigan$20
InsuranceRequired by venue ($1 million in coverage including liquor liability)$185
BabysitterFor the 5-month-old of a groomsman and his wife and the 6-month old of one of my friends, in an adjacent room to the venue rooms. We limited this room to breastfeeding babies only - 2 bridal party members traveling with toddlers hired their own babysitters off-site, one of which we helped find.$120
Hotel roomTop floor downtown suite for the women to change in while the groom and groomsmen were at our house, and where we stayed on our wedding night$230
TransportationTwo six-seater SUVs to drive both parties to the venue$92
GiftsPersonalized pocket knives for groomspeople, personalized leather notebooks for bridespeople, frames to be filled with family wedding photos for parents$350
TOTAL$14,944

I didn't know whether to count our rings - if we do, my rose gold and diamond vine band was $400, and his custom white gold band (which has the same leaves as my engagement ring) was $800, and my engagement ring (emerald and rose gold with accent diamonds) was $750. We also had an awesome rehearsal dinner the night before for the wedding party and immediate family in a private room with an open bar (which was super fun!), but I don't know the exact cost since my FIL paid. I would estimate about $1300. We also went on a mini-moon to a resort on Lake Michigan for two nights, which was about $500 for lodging and food. So if you add in the rings, rehearsal dinner, and mini-moon, the total is more like $18,500.

Guest breakdown:

  • 78 people
  • 46 (59%) flew in - two from Europe!
  • 9 (11%) drove 3+ hours
  • 23 (30%) local
  • 42 (54%) bride's side
  • 36 (46%) groom's side
  • 3 (4%) bride family
  • 15 (19%) groom family
  • 33 (42%) bride's friends
  • 20 (26%) groom's friends
  • 5 came (and traveled!) without their spouses (their choice - all were invited)
  • 3 changed their accepts to declines within a week of the wedding
  • 2 no-shows (locals)
  • 65% invitation accept rate. Considering it was a flight away for 75% of invitees and not to a cool destination locale, this was unsurprising. We have both lived all over and got married where we live now, where we have both been grad students, so all the locals were grad school friends, and our local accept rate was 90%.

Alcohol Breakdown:

Our venue was beer and wine only, so we wanted to make sure we had good beer and wine. We got two of our favorite local Michigan craft beers, and then two mass-market beers. We got 32 bottles of wine, 2 reds and 2 whites. But I think we may have overestimated beer drinkers and underestimated wine drinkers! My dad told me later that towards the end of the night, the caterers were worried they were going to run out of wine, and he told them to add another 10 bottles. It's unclear whether they did, or how they would've gotten it since we provided the alcohol. And we have 9.5 bottles left over! 9 of which are the Chardonnay and Cab. So I'm sort of confused, but it seems like they might have ordered an extra 5 Chard and 5 Cab but only needed 1 of them. Anyway, assuming they did order the extra 10, here's our consumption stats:

TypeBottles boughtBottles consumedBottles left over
Bell's Two Hearted (IPA)723438
Miller High Life482523
Sam Adams481830
Atwater Vanilla Java Porter241212
Chardonnay (Bogle)1385
Sauvignon Blanc (Beringer)880
Cabernet Sauvignon (Bogle)1394
Merlot (Beringer)871
Champagne (Cook's)1266

So if you calculate that each bottle of wine is 5 drinks, that's 250 drinks consumed. At 78 people, that's about 3.2 drinks per person (though not everyone drank). We calculated for 4 drinks per person, but just didn't realize how many more would drink wine than beer - it was 65% wine and 35% beer, when we calculated about 50% each. Anyway, we're glad to have the extra wine and beer, all of which are what we drink regularly anyway, especially the Two-Hearted, VJP, Chard, and Cab! So we're set for months on booze.

Hope that monster summary was helpful! We're so excited to be MARRIED!

Posted Oct 19, 2017, 6:09 PM UTC · edited

10134
kalichibunnyWinter Brunch Wedding•

Yay!!! I haven't even looked at all of this yet, but... and I know this is super creepy... I was lounging around on Saturday, reading reddit and admiring the gloomy Ann Arbor weather, and I randomly thought "I think it's textrovert's wedding today!" It looks like things turned out really beautifully despite the rain! Congratulations!

14
textrovertOPOctober 14, 2017 | Michigan | Botanical Gardens Conservatory•

Aw, that is sweet! And definitely means I've spent too much time on this forum. :P I was definitely disappointed we didn't get to show off Ann Arbor at its autumn best for all of our out-of-town guests, but oh well!

8
kalichibunnyWinter Brunch Wedding•

I’d say juuuuust enough time ;) but hey that’s a pretty sweet deal ya got on the salon! Mind sharing where you went?

1
textrovertOPOctober 14, 2017 | Michigan | Botanical Gardens Conservatory•

Sure! It was Vis-a-Vis, and it was really nice - it's big, multi-level, and they let us have a fun plush room as well as the salon room where everyone could hang out and see each other while we got stuff done. They had four people going at all times so it was efficient, and definitely the most affordable I found, too!

2
kalichibunnyWinter Brunch Wedding•

Ooo yay! Thanks! Their location is kind of perfect for me so I will def check them out!

1
shrahhh•

Holy crap. Thank you for this and please plan my wedding! Hahaha! Congrats! Everything looked beautiful!

4
textrovertOPOctober 14, 2017 | Michigan | Botanical Gardens Conservatory•

Ha, thank you but no thank you! I loved our wedding but am so glad to be done with wedding planning! I can see why it's a full-time job for some people. I'm so happy to not have that job and just be married now!

2
terriblyunclear•

Saving this post for future reference. All these details are SO HELPFUL and your wedding looks BEAUTIFUL. Seriously lusting after your indoor forest of a venue too 😍

3
FutureMrsEngineerMARRIED 9.16.17•

YAYYY!!! I have been waiting to see how your wedding turned out and oh my goodness it was BEAUTIFUL!! All that greenery is just stunning. Also obsessed with your look; you are rocking that flower crown! I totally forgot we had the exact same wedding color - dark teal for the win! Ugh it's all just so pretty. Congrats fellow Ann Arbor bride ❤❤

3
textrovertOPOctober 14, 2017 | Michigan | Botanical Gardens Conservatory•

Thank you, dear! I did love my eucalyptus crown. And the teal! The photographer made the dresses look exactly the color I wanted them to be - they were sliiightly bluer than I would have wanted in real life! (I was overall happy with the dresses, though - they had pockets that ended up being really useful, since my MoH could keep my vows and his ring in there, and my other bridesmaid could keep her reading!)

2
FutureMrsEngineerMARRIED 9.16.17•

I wouldn't have even known! She totally nailed the color! I'll be interested to see how editing effects the color of my girl's dresses... Congrats on a stunning wedding though, and cheers to a long, happy marriage!!

2
someinvisiblehand10/6/2018 | PA•

Omg, I want that to be my venue! How stunning. It looks amazing inside, doesn't even matter you didn't get to go out!!

3
gettinghitched20187.22.18 | Motor City Detroit, Baby!•

So amazing !!! Congratulations!!! I always get a big smile on my face whenever I see Michigan weddings. Thank you for the thorough recap. Good luck and enjoy your marriage (:

3
kmgz9.22.18 * Hudson Valley•

Thank you for this post!! I've bookmarked it. $15k is our budget, my venue is also DIY, and I'm a big fan of the aesthetic you guys had, so this is total inspiration!

3
Black_Widow14June 17th, 2017•

This breakdown ROCKS. Holy shit! And this wedding looked fabulous <3 So dreamy!

3
EmmyBayBee2709.08.17 Married &amp; so in love!•

I love going there! Such a beautiful place to get married! Also, im just super jealous you have so many sneak peaks! I've seen 2 since my 9/8 wedding :(

2
textrovertOPOctober 14, 2017 | Michigan | Botanical Gardens Conservatory•

I was shocked/impressed that our photographer got a dozen photos back to us within 24 hours and posted them to her Facebook page so I could share them! Along with her adding 3 extra hours for the second photographer for no cost to us, as long as we get the rest of the photos back in a reasonable time I am going to give her GLOWING reviews on any site I can find. Her photos are gorgeous and she's just a pro. (Lindsey Billings of The Billings Photography for anyone in Michigan looking for a photographer!)

3
SneepleSnurchCalifornia, Dec 2020•

Congrats!! Glad everything worked out beautifully. Thanks for the writeup & numbers (I'm a sucker for statistics) and now go enjoy married life! :)

2
pat_benatartlet•

This is tremendously helpful. Thank you!

We're planning a similar guest count and I've been trying to get a handle on how much alcohol to purchase and whether I ought to go with a caterers alcohol package or not.

Congratulations on a beautiful wedding and many good wishes!

2
atomic__llama9.22.18 | NJ•

I'm trying to figure out alcohol consumption, so I found your breakdown super helpful and interesting! I think we're going to have about the same number of people at our wedding and it's going to take place over the same time period, and this is making me think I am SEVERELY overestimating... so many of the sites say account for 1 drink per hour per guest, but I feel like more people will drink much less than much more if that makes sense?

2
textrovertOPOctober 14, 2017 | Michigan | Botanical Gardens Conservatory•

It does. I'd say our crowd is generally a pretty heavy-drinking one - about 80% of the wedding was under 40 years old and most like to have a good time. Lots of Texans! Our theory for why there were so many more wine drinkers is that without liquor, people went for the more potent option. With liquor I think it would've been even fewer per person. I think estimating 4 drinks per person for an evening event is plenty, regardless of how long it is. Most people are going to be at that or under, and the ones that exceed it will probably be outweighed by the ones that don't drink (pregnant ladies, Mormons & Muslims, older people conservative about drinking, etc.).

3
atomic__llama9.22.18 | NJ•

Yeah, I think that's true. and that's a really good point about abv with wine vs beer... I wasnt thinking about that. We have our fair share of people who I will imagine will pound like 10 beers in 5 hours, but then I know a lot of relatives will only drink ~2 glasses of wine.

Just curious, did you have a champagne toast or did you just have that as one of the wine options?

1
textrovertOPOctober 14, 2017 | Michigan | Botanical Gardens Conservatory•

We did have a champagne toast but the servers just went around and poured for anyone who wanted it.

1
fearlessqueefs•

I'm impressed you got so much for such a great price!

As a banquet server for 8 years, I always felt serving a plated dinner during toasts and speeches was a bit rude or cheapened the experience. Any noise other than the person speaking was amplified x100.

Even when we had the different meals exactly planned out with each seat number at every table (which should have been doable for your size group) we inevitably ran into that oblivious guest yelling "is this the chicken cause it looks like pork and I ordered chicken" "no henry, it's ok you keep yours actually miss I want the pork too now, and do you have any other reds cause I only drink rose, and can I get another set of silverware". And now everyone is looking at me and listening to mine and the guests interaction cause they've completely distracted from the speaker.

2
textrovertOPOctober 14, 2017 | Michigan | Botanical Gardens Conservatory•

That makes sense. We probably should have served dinner first and then went to speeches. I just didn't realize they would take so long!

And yes, we definitely got a good deal on the catering. I really dislike buffets and was set on a plated dinner, and was so happy when we found it for $60pp, rentals, service, and all!

1
secondhand_totsie5.26.2018 | AZ•

Thank you so much for sharing the detailed breakdown! Your day looked beautiful and like so much fun. Would you be willing to share a script of your ceremony with an internet stranger? From your description it sounds completely lovely. I'm in the process of writing ours right now and I'm in need of some inspiration!

2
textrovertOPOctober 14, 2017 | Michigan | Botanical Gardens Conservatory•

Sure, I actually have a script of all the words from our ceremony minus the officiant's (opening, wine ceremony, pronouncement). I'll PM you!

1
hayitsahorse•

The photos are beautiful and the budget breakdown is so helpful! Thanks for posting!

2
happiesthamburger11/4/2017•

I too have been waiting for your post! Congrats, this looks amazing!

2
rosegoldlife•

Do you mind messaging me which musicians you used? I live in the area and I'm also a classical musician - curious to know if any of them are my peers and also, yknow, future reference :-)

1
textrovertOPOctober 14, 2017 | Michigan | Botanical Gardens Conservatory•

Sure! We went with Go 4 Baroque, and they did a beautiful job.

2
nycbarbrideBrewery | 5/19/18•

Hi! I might have missed it, but where are those bridesmaid dresses from? They are gorgeous and the exact color I'm looking for!

1
textrovertOPOctober 14, 2017 | Michigan | Botanical Gardens Conservatory•

They're from Kennedy Blue - the Thea dress, in Teal. They have pockets! But definitely order a swatch first - the pictures here make them appear the exact color I wanted, but in person and on iPhone photos they were significantly bluer. Azazie has a "peacock" color that is close to what they look like here, too, which I would have gone with except that they didn't have a cold-shoulder style.

1
violetpolkadots10.06.18 * Mackinaw City, MI•

This is so beautiful! The greenery is to die for. Is it the Matthaei Botanical Gardens? We looked at that venue before we decided on Mackinaw City, and it is so freaking beautiful, inside and out!

1
textrovertOPOctober 14, 2017 | Michigan | Botanical Gardens Conservatory•

Yes, it is! Thank you.

2
mosquitojane•

Okay I am so intrigued by the idea of affirmations. What were they? We’re writing our vows right now (we’re getting married in 10 days), and I want to do something unexpected!

1