Is this a great deck?

Posted Oct 26, 2017, 5:59 PM UTC

Posted Oct 26, 2017, 5:59 PM UTC
Two playable 1-drops on turn 1, and one ehh 1 drop.
Six mediocre/playable 2-drops on turn 2.
One bad and one good 3 drops on turn 3.
One high quality 4 drop, and one high quality five drop.
Bonemare ++
Eleven removal spells ranging from awful to godly. Arcane and Greater Arcane missile are very situational cards, and just horrible late game draws. The 2 Kill Commands and Fireball are your win conditions. Those alone can end games or save yourself when you fall behind. Poly is obviously great. On the hunt, toxic arrow, arcane explosion are both situational and bad. On the hunt is good for your kill commands, but you're a Hunter-Mage so the ping aspect becomes irrelevant.
Five card-draw cards, six counting Arcanologist assuming you don't draw the secret, and seven if you want to count Tracking. Best case scenario, you can draw 8 cards which is very good.
One weapon which is decent.
Seven beasts, or twelve counting the Pirhannas generated from the weapon as well as the minion generated off Jeweled Macaw.
Your best game plan is to full mulligan for a strong, early, curve. You unfortunately have a lot of filler-spells, and not a lot of high-quality minions. If you can land those few minions on curve you can leverage that early game tempo into face damage, allowing those Kill Commands and Fireball to end the game.
All in all, it's a good deck but it's high variance. Which, like wholewheatie said, makes it harder to pilot.
Thanks a lot for your detailed analysis, it's been very helpful. Yes, I hads to take some subpar spells. The draft was going to be aggro/tempo HunterMage right from the start and I kept taking stuff that helped the game plan. But there are limits to what you can do. I took every passable 1-3 minion. I did follow the gameplan above and went 8-3. I lost a game to a midrange paladin/warlock due to a slight misplay (I pinged down a minion instead of pinging face and he survived wirth one hp). I lost another game to missing all my curve and my opponent drew the nuts. I lost my third game to a warrior/hunter aggro deck but I misplayed that one badly on turn 2 (played into an explosive trap).
Yes it is, but probably harder than average to pilot. Make sure to go aggressive as it's an aggro deck.
Yes that was the plan with the draft 😀
I wouldn't saw its great but I would defenitly agree to be aggressive. The problem is you are missing some beefy well statted early drops. Take good trades but when it doubt face is the place because you are not going to win with board control. You have 16 hp of burn though (And greater arcane missiles) so with you hero power you can get some wins that you dont deserve lol
that arcanologist into freezing trap is fucking triggering me right now
It only has 12 minions
Feels light - you don't have great turn 3-6 plays so you'll probably be filling those turns with multiple small cards.
If you face any resistance like a big early Taunt (Tar Creeper, Stegadon, type cards) or an early AOE (Defile, Consecration, etc) you'll probably have spent so many resources that it'll be hard for you to recover even with 2x Intellect to reload it's won't be enough.
Agreed. I've found that decks which curve this low get shut down or run out of gas too easily in this meta where there's so much removal going around.
The two On the Hunts are suboptimal when you have the Mage hero power, 2-drops are weak and insufficient, only one actual 3-drop and 4-drop, and too many weak cards like Boar, Dalaran, Flare, and GAM.