[Spoiler] Lore question: Purge and similar spells

SpoilerDOS2 Discussion

What happen to a spirt when you consume it with source vampirism?
Do they vanish to oblivion or are they send to the hall of echoes? Is consuming a corpse the same than consuming an spirit? In act 4 you are asked to use "Replenish Source", it's the same than using source vampirism?
I want to know the morality behind geting source from corpses/spirits

Posted Oct 27, 2017, 8:06 PM UTC

415
Carbonights•

I believe people's spirits are essentially the source that was within them imprinted with some instance of their being, and when you eat the source you eat that essence of them as well. But the Hall of Echoes is no better anyway because once you go there the God's eventually just eat you too anyway. I'm curious what the afterlife is like if you rid the world of source instead.

7
calagon1•

Doesn't Aetera, the Eternal entombed in the Blackpits say as much? When you talk to her she remarks on you being fundamentally a crude source vat, and concludes that mortality was a deliberate design choice for the harvesting of said Source.

Speaking of which, one thing about the ending confused me as a result. Dallis and Lucian at the end remark that when the Deathfog was unleashed on the Black Ring the death of all those elves weakened Tir-Cendelius, allowing the God-King and the Voidwoken their first entry.

But shouldn't it have been opposite? All those elven souls should surely have strengthened Tir-Cendelius in the short run, right?

3
KeylusOP•

I guess there will be not after life without source, does the hall of echoes still exist after you purge the source?

2
legion160•

Ok so you have beaten the game good. Heres the thing about source, consuming a spirit sends it into nothing, oblivion, aka it just ceases to be. HOWEVER its possible to be brought back from nothing or recreated since you can consume Linder Kemm's soul and Isbeil's soul BUT the God King can bring them back from nothing since they were sworn. I guess this means the God Kings true power is beyond the games scope considering he can do this while still trapped in the Void.

5
EmpororPenguin•

I always thought they were just imitations of them, especially since the kraken will spawn them again once they die

3
legion160•

nah being sworn is a pact like nothing else, he can kill you at anytime and he can take your soul should you fail him (he can purge you basically) If he can do all that while being trapped in the void, its not a stretch to say he can remake someone just as easily, remember the "Gods" aka eternal lords made all the races of rivellon by themselves and the God King is infinitely stronger than any one of them alone considering it takes all 7 of them to keep him sealed away. (also technically you are immortal while being sworn the God King because he CAN keep raising you but he won't..)

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
ArmaMalum•

From how I interpret it it goes like this:

The Hall of Echoes, canonically (source: Ego Draconis), is a place where spirits go to be stripped of your living memories piece by piece to return to the great flow (or whatever which game calls it at the time). In this game we learn this is not entirely true and the Gods actually consume the source of the dead to sustain themselves. Since you, as a godwoken, glean memories from people's source one can make the easy leap of saying you are doing the same thing as the gods when you consume a spirit. So I guess at that point it depends on your definition of existence. The memories/experiences of the person is on you/RelevantGod so they're sort of living on, at least partially.

Corpse: We know that source can exist by itself (pools) so it's not unbelievable to say all living/unliving matter has source, even if the spirit behind it has gone (since you can vamp corpses with no spirit tied to it) so I don't think it's the same thing. Now, the counter to this stance is that when you vamp a spirit the corpse is vamped too, so..........eh? Personally I think we can file that under 'gameplay reasons'.

Re: Morality. If you're a strict definition kind of person you get the villain tag if you consume too many spirits via dialogue so it's alignment-wise an evil act. Personally I feel the reason that is is because there is almost always a "vegetarian" option of a dead corpse nearby and therefore only did it to inflict fear/pain but that's just me.

As far as Act 4, I'm not going to lie the finale was a whirlpool of a lore dump and confusing motives so I'm not going to touch that just yet.

3
ironicperspective•

On the note of corpses, if you vamp the corpse, its spirit will disappear as well.

5
KeylusOP•

Now I remember finding a book in the academy that said the gods needed the mortal races because they feed from our source, but I didn't thougth it was refering to consuming the spirits of the dead.
Thanks for the explanation. I guess it's still evil to consume spirits if they want to go to the Hall of Echoes, even if they get consumed there it could be their last wish after all.

2
FireHazard11•

The game treats purging spirits and bodies of the innocent as an evil action. I got the Villain tag by eating too many civilian spirits.

2
LucatIel_of_M1rrah•

What happen to a spirit when you consume it with source vampirism?

They are destroyed and dead for ever. There is one exception to this and that is someone joining all the fragments of your soul back together.

Is consuming a corpse the same than consuming an spirit?

Yes, if they are in the hall they die there too for sure. If someones spirit is near their corpse and you purge the corpse the spirit is destroyed too.

Consuming source is evil and is what the gods do to those who go to the hall of echoes. For this reason there is no true afterlife, just waiting to be destroyed by the gods. Once you destroy the gods there would then be a true afterlife because there is nothing to eat those in the hall of echoes.

2