Discovered I really liked spice by unconventional means - Guide me, /r/spicy!

So I'm a recruit in a local law enforcement agency, and last week I was OC (Pepper) sprayed for training.

Well, it turns out I'm immune to pepper spray - and I really enjoyed the kick it gave me across the mouth. I've never really been HUGE into spice (the most I ever put on was tabasco, sriracha or frank's red hot), but now I think I want to delve a little further into this discovery of mine.

I've bought two bottled of El Yucateco (the chipotle and red habanero) and I thoroughly enjoy them. Do you guys have any other suggestions? The ones I want to try are Queen Majesty Blueberry and Black Coffee, Hot One's and Yellowbird Habanero; but I don't know if these would 'ease' me into the world of spice.

What do you all recommend?