Am I the only one (mildly) disappointed with Xanathar's Guide to Everything?
TL;DR: I am excited for Xanathar's, and I will be buying it. But I am disappointed that Wizards did not make it into a compendium which included more, if not all, existing supplementary content.
As the title says, I'm (mildly) disappointed in Xanathar's Guide to Everything.
I've been looking over the contents of the book before it comes out, and I'm just left wanting more.
I was really hoping that Wizards of the Coast would make Xanathar's into THE supplement book for 5e.
Ideally, Wizards would have included all racial, subclass, and background options available, including all their new content and all existing content. I would have also liked them to have included the Artificer and Mystic classes, on the condition that Wizards would be able to balance them.
Before you say I'm asking too much, my reasoning is broken down to three main points.
-
Xanathar's currently appears to be just under 200 pages while the Player's Handbook is around 320 pages.
-
We are being asked to pay the same price for Xanathar's as the Player Handbook ($49.95US according to the Wizards' website.)
-
All the additional material I'm asking for except for the Artificer and Mystic classes would take no extra work for Wizards. It already exists.
I understand that an issue would be that a lot of supplemental content has already been purchased by people. But the advantage of including all the existing supplemental content for people who have already bought it would be that they get a lot of new content(and yes, I recognise that there is a lot), but they also get all the supplemental character options in a single book.
If you look at all the supplemental character options which have already been published, you have it in many different sources. In order of release, they are:
-
Dungeon Master's Guide (Death Domain Cleric and Oathbreaker Paladin)
-
Elemental Evil Player's Companion (4 Racial Options)
-
Sword Coast Adventurer's Guide (1 Racial, 11 Subclasses and 11 Background Options)
-
Curse of Strahd (1 Background Option)
-
Volo's Guide to Monsters (7 Racial Options)
-
Tomb of Annihilation (2 Background Options)
-
The Tortle Package (1 Racial Option)
Yes, I know there is double up on some of the options between supplements, and yes, some of options are campaign specific, but in my mind there is a lot of additional material that Wizards could include in Xanathar's.
And please, don't get me wrong, I am excited for Xanathar's. I am looking forward to all the new character options. I am looking forward to all the new Dungeon Master's Tools and clarification on rules. Hell, I am looking forward to the list of names.
I just wish that there was more existing material included in the book.
Edit: Added a TL;DR
Posted Oct 30, 2017, 10:47 AM UTC · edited
This brings up a related point for me. If AL is going to do PHB + 1 as their character-building rule, the +1s should all have roughly equal amounts of content. XGE will likely have far more content for players than EE:PC, SCAG, or Volo's, which will make the rest of the content that isn't in XGE that much harder of a choice.
90+ new spells? Yeah. Your Genasi doesn't get to use those. Sorry.
That is also an issue. I can see why in regards to AL that they wouldn't want to do what I hoped they would, but it would make things a lot easier for a lot of people.
Even physically it would be easier for people. Say you go to a non-AL campaign and you want all the options. You only need to take 2 books opposed to every other thing.
Agreed. It's why i'm glad to hear that you can finally get PDF book copies on D&D Beyond.
Mhmm, I am glad that it is now an option. Though I'm still more likely to buy the book.
You can? How?
Dunno, one of the mods here told me you could during a discussion of why people pirate the PDFs.