r/dndnext•
khellick

Am I the only one (mildly) disappointed with Xanathar's Guide to Everything?

TL;DR: I am excited for Xanathar's, and I will be buying it. But I am disappointed that Wizards did not make it into a compendium which included more, if not all, existing supplementary content.

As the title says, I'm (mildly) disappointed in Xanathar's Guide to Everything.

I've been looking over the contents of the book before it comes out, and I'm just left wanting more.

I was really hoping that Wizards of the Coast would make Xanathar's into THE supplement book for 5e.

Ideally, Wizards would have included all racial, subclass, and background options available, including all their new content and all existing content. I would have also liked them to have included the Artificer and Mystic classes, on the condition that Wizards would be able to balance them.

Before you say I'm asking too much, my reasoning is broken down to three main points.

  1. Xanathar's currently appears to be just under 200 pages while the Player's Handbook is around 320 pages.

  2. We are being asked to pay the same price for Xanathar's as the Player Handbook ($49.95US according to the Wizards' website.)

  3. All the additional material I'm asking for except for the Artificer and Mystic classes would take no extra work for Wizards. It already exists.

I understand that an issue would be that a lot of supplemental content has already been purchased by people. But the advantage of including all the existing supplemental content for people who have already bought it would be that they get a lot of new content(and yes, I recognise that there is a lot), but they also get all the supplemental character options in a single book.

If you look at all the supplemental character options which have already been published, you have it in many different sources. In order of release, they are:

  1. Dungeon Master's Guide (Death Domain Cleric and Oathbreaker Paladin)

  2. Elemental Evil Player's Companion (4 Racial Options)

  3. Sword Coast Adventurer's Guide (1 Racial, 11 Subclasses and 11 Background Options)

  4. Curse of Strahd (1 Background Option)

  5. Volo's Guide to Monsters (7 Racial Options)

  6. Tomb of Annihilation (2 Background Options)

  7. The Tortle Package (1 Racial Option)

Yes, I know there is double up on some of the options between supplements, and yes, some of options are campaign specific, but in my mind there is a lot of additional material that Wizards could include in Xanathar's.

And please, don't get me wrong, I am excited for Xanathar's. I am looking forward to all the new character options. I am looking forward to all the new Dungeon Master's Tools and clarification on rules. Hell, I am looking forward to the list of names.

I just wish that there was more existing material included in the book.

Edit: Added a TL;DR

Posted Oct 30, 2017, 10:47 AM UTC · edited

064
moonshadowkatiAddicted to Rogues•

This brings up a related point for me. If AL is going to do PHB + 1 as their character-building rule, the +1s should all have roughly equal amounts of content. XGE will likely have far more content for players than EE:PC, SCAG, or Volo's, which will make the rest of the content that isn't in XGE that much harder of a choice.

12
meoka2368Knower Of Things•

90+ new spells? Yeah. Your Genasi doesn't get to use those. Sorry.

7
khellickOP•

That is also an issue. I can see why in regards to AL that they wouldn't want to do what I hoped they would, but it would make things a lot easier for a lot of people.

Even physically it would be easier for people. Say you go to a non-AL campaign and you want all the options. You only need to take 2 books opposed to every other thing.

5
moonshadowkatiAddicted to Rogues•

Agreed. It's why i'm glad to hear that you can finally get PDF book copies on D&D Beyond.

1
khellickOP•

Mhmm, I am glad that it is now an option. Though I'm still more likely to buy the book.

1
petricup•

You can? How?

1
moonshadowkatiAddicted to Rogues•

Dunno, one of the mods here told me you could during a discussion of why people pirate the PDFs.

1
legaldrinkingage•

So it sounds to me like you don't want to buy all their books, but just one book with everything in it. It makes sense, yes, but it would also be very bad business for WotC to do it that way. Xanathar's isn't supposed to be a PHB2 or an upgraded version of the PHB - it's supposed to be like an expansion pack.

9
khellickOP•

I've got the 3 core books, and I'm going to buy Curse of Strahd, Volo's and Xanathar's once the latter is released. I don't have an issue with buying the books, my main concerns are value for money and ease of use.

I disagree it's bad business sense, I think that needing to purchase a large number of books if you want to have "all" the content, then I think it puts potential customers. But if you go to the vast majority of players and say "These two books are all you need to make a character and have every available option", then I think a lot of players would prefer that.

I don't think that Xanathar's would be PHB2 with what I suggested. It would be a compendium of all pre-existing content, plus some new content on top. It would still be an expansion pack. To use video game terms, it feels like to me that Wizards is releasing a lot of small pieces of DLC, and a few large pieces of DLC, which a lot of the content won't be of value to the majority of customers. I'm wanting an expansion pack. I just don't see it as that so far.

-3
Zathrus1•

So you want them to republish every character creation option from every source every time they publish a splat book? Or is this one special somehow?

And what about the customers who have bought the previous books? Why should they pay for a book that would be mostly republished content? There are people complaining about the small amount of republished content in XGE as it is.

I’m fine with the middle ground they’ve chosen — it gives a good bit of value to both groups.

7
khellickOP•

I would like Wizards to publish compendiums of supplementary content every so often, including pre-existing and new content, so that are to purchase content from previous releases which did not appeal to them in ways which does appeal to them.

And what about the customers who have bought the previous books?

I think that is players bought SCAG and/or Volo's, they would still get a massive number of class options in it. They would have all the new ones, plus all the options which are only available in adventures.

And apart from SCAG and the The Tortle Package, I think every release which has character options has enough value in them that players will still be fine paying for them. Volo's has it's monsters, the DMG it's content, the Elemental Evil companion is free, and the rest are adventures.

Yes, I would like more content in Volo's but I am primarily going to buy it in two weeks along with Xanathar's for the monster options as a DM.

I think having a supplementary compendium would be really useful to players and DMs. In terms of price and the ease of use, it makes a lot of sense for players to buy it. I think Volo's would still get bought by a lot of people for the monster options. The only book I think would become obsolete would be SCAG, but that is a really bad value proposition imo to start with.

Why should they pay for a book that would be mostly republished content?

I think that the majority of content would be those that people had not already paid for, and there is still a lot of new character options plus the rules section.

Lets say that people have previously bought every single core and supplementary rulebook and every adventure Wizards have released. I don't think this is the majority of 5e D&D players, and I also think that the new character content and the ease of having all the previous supplementary character content in a single location, along with the rules, is worth it imo.

-1
Zathrus1•

Republishing every character creation option AND adding a ton of new content isn’t viable though. Yes, there’s some filler in XGE, but doing what you suggest would be far more than the 17 pages of names. And republishing content isn’t free — you still need to ensure the content was copied correctly (even with cut and paste), it still needs to be laid out, proofs, etc. It may cost less, but it’s by no means free, and it’s ALWAYS at the cost of new content.

The 3 core books are priced as they are with the expectation that they will sell for the life of the game. So you can reasonably defer costs over a longer time period. Any supplement will have lower sales, both because not everyone will purchase it and because it will have a shorter shelf life. So suggesting that it could be the same size as the PHB isn’t going to fly economically.

And if you make it a practice to reprint things then those supplements are going to suffer even worse sales. “Oh, yeah, Foobar’s Most Excellent Grimoire sounds nice, but next year’s Gregarious Greg’s Ultimate Ultimatum will have all the content anyway, so I’ll just wait for it.”

And, for reference, most of the people I play with do have every book and supplement, or at least every one since they started playing (and I play mostly AL, so I know a LOT of DMs). But we’re in NA, so it’s not as cost prohibitive. For things like the one background from CoS, if you really want that for some reason then it’s available electronically through a variety of means, and under US law copying that one or two pages would probably fall under fair use. (And, again, I know you’re not in the US and fair use doesn’t apply... but it’s one of the few good things about US copyright law!)

4
Craios125Paladin•

THE supplement book for 5e

I mean, it is? It's virtually the same as the DMG, minus the encounter stuff, and more class stuff.

Ideally, Wizards would have included all racial, subclass, and background options available, including all their new content and all existing content

Why would Wizards republish the stuff they have already printed out?

Xanathar's currently appears to be just under 200 pages while the Player's Handbook is around 320 pages.

Have they published the length? Because FYI Volo's was like 220 pages, too.

We are being asked to pay the same price for Xanathar's as the Player Handbook ($49.95US according to the Wizards' website.)

So was Volo's. Also, Xanthar's Guide To Everything is currently 29,97$ on Amazon.

All the additional material I'm asking for except for the Artificer and Mystic classes would take no extra work for Wizards. It already exists.

They re-balanced almost all of it, though I see and agree with your point.

but they also get all the supplemental character options in a single book...

...which means nobody would even have a need of the DMG, PHB and Volo's if they want more options. Why would WotC ever do that?

8
khellickOP•

I mean, it is? It's virtually the same as the DMG, minus the encounter stuff, and more class stuff.

Is it currently? I'd say no. But I think it had the potential to be.

Why would Wizards republish the stuff they have already printed out?

Because people who don't want to buy Volo's because they have no use for monsters or thing that the other supplement material isn't worth the money would be more interested in buying Xanathar's.

Have they published the length? Because FYI Volo's was like 220 pages, too.

If you look here, it shows that the book is just under 200 pages.

So was Volo's. Also, Xanthar's Guide To Everything is currently 29,97$ on Amazon.

Unfortunately that doesn't really benefit me, because I'm not in the US. So all Wizards products are always at the retail price for me, no matter where I buy them.

They re-balanced almost all of it, though I see and agree with your point.

They still have a lot of the material already existing. To my understanding it is far easier to rebalance existing material than to make completely new material.

...which means nobody would even have a need of the DMG, PHB and Volo's if they want more options. Why would WotC ever do that?

I'm not sure how many players will buy the DMG or Volo's, unless they are specifically DMing. It's a lot more attractive to new players if they are told "If you want to make a character with all the options, you need these 2 books" opposed to "You need this one book, but if you want all the options you need all these other books"

The DMG has no real use for players who don't want to DM. As does Volo's imo.

2
Craios125Paladin•

Is it currently? I'd say no.

  • Class options

  • Magical Items

  • Optional Rules

Uh yeah, seems like it is, currently.

Because people who don't want to buy Volo's because they have no use for monsters or thing that the other supplement material isn't worth the money would be more interested in buying Xanathar's.

Or they would have to buy both. WotC are a business.

it shows that the book is just under 200 pages.

Touche.

Unfortunately that doesn't really benefit me

You ignored the first part of that message.

It's a lot more attractive to new players

But it's a lot more attractive to WotC to have everyone buy every book.

5
khellickOP•

Uh yeah, seems like it is, currently.

They have no racial options or background options from what I can tell. So it's not imo.

Or they would have to buy both. WotC are a business.

But I don't think most of them would look at the relative content and buy both. If large portions of the content isn't appealing to the player, such as Volo's for non-DM players or SCAG for those who don't use the campaign, then why would the characters buy those books?

I agree that a lot of players, specifically DMs, will buy all the core and supplementary rulebooks, but I don't think many of the other players.

You ignored the first part of that message.

In regards to the price of Volo's, I also think that relative to the MM, which has 350 pages, that Volo's is a bit content-lite.

But it's a lot more attractive to WotC to have everyone buy every book.

Again, I don't think everyone will buy every book. I think that a core group of players will, but a lot of players won't buy every book simply because that a lot of the content isn't useful to them. If you make it easier for them in terms of cost for players to buy the content they want, they are more likely to buy it imo.

1
JestaKillaWizard•

A given group only needs one copy of each book to have every book available to them. But even so, not every group needs every book. I have no interest in SCAG, because it's more of a setting book for the Forgotten Realms than anything of use to me, so I'm glad they reprinted a few things from it in Xanathar's. That's an issue of a product aimed pretty much entirely at people using the FR. If you're not, SCAG is a pretty expensive way to get like 20 pages of subclasses or whatever it is. But the point is, a book for Eberron is going to have limited appeal to non-Eberron players, and people who hate post-apoc flavor are not going to bite at a Dark Sun book.

Buy what you want. Use what you want. Ignore the PH+1 limit in your home game. But don't expect the guys who make a living off the game to undermine their income by reducing the number of supplements out there or by increasing the overlap between them.

1
Craios125Paladin•

They have no racial options or background options from what I can tell

So? Neither does the DMG.

But I don't think most of them would look at the relative content and buy both.

Guess again. It happens very often.

1
eagle2401•

Your argument is based on two assumptions:

  1. Page length is a good way to compare books

  2. That XGtE should have as much content as the PHB.

Well I don't think page length is a great metric for comparing books. Even if it were, a large portion of the page difference is just the rules of the game.

The second point here is that the players handbook can be reliably found for $30. Rather than saying that XGtE has less value for being the same price, you could argue that the PHB has more value for being at that price. That would mean that the PHB is a great deal (which is good, since it's required to play the game) and XGtE is an average deal. And that's based on the assumption that XGtE isn't as good as the PHB.

But seriously, the quality of content in Xanathar's is what's drawing me to it. I think all of the subclasses being released look really fun and well designed, meanwhile a lot of the PHB sub classes are pretty meh in comparison.

Really, we should he comparing XGtE to the sword coast book, which is the closest thing to a PHB supplement that we've gotten so far. I think XGTE has way more content to be excited about than that book.

8
khellickOP•

Well I don't think page length is a great metric for comparing books.

True, different books use their pages in different ways. So it can be a poor metric.

The second point here is that the players handbook can be reliably found for $30.

I'm sure it can be, in the US. But I'm from Australia, and I have not seen a single store here selling the PHB for under $60, which is the standard price here. And when I look at buying from Amazon or other online retailers, they do sell it at a cheaper price, but the shipping negates the difference. So for me, the amount of content I am getting for the price is a larger issue, as I haven't found anyone selling any D&D product at a discount.

That would mean that the PHB is a great deal and XGtE is an average deal.

Both the PHB and Xanathar's have large sections of content on rules. Yes, the PHB rules are the core rule for running the game while Xanathar's rules are optional, but my point was that the different in pages is next to nothing when it comes to the costs of printing and shipping.

But seriously, the quality of content in Xanathar's is what's drawing me to it.

Yeah, that's true. And it's really appealing to me.

Really, we should he comparing XGtE to the sword coast book

A-FUCKING-MEN. I completely agree. SCAG is almost completely useless for me, definitely not worth buying. And that's with SCAG's discounted price.

4
JestaKillaWizard•

SCAG is focused way too much on being a setting book to be worth the price to non-FR players, in my opinion.

1
lizardfolkwarrior•

SCAG has more than one racial option. I think it has three, maybe more. (It has the Ghostwise halfling, the Winged tiefling, and some Half-elf options).

4
khellickOP•

Ahhh, thank you for correcting me. When I flicked through it earlier I only saw the Duergar I believe it was.

The tiefling options are all variant options, which I imagine will be included if they publish an expansion of the tiefling racial options which I think they eventually will do.

And from memory the half-elf options were only cosmetic?

1
lizardfolkwarrior•

I think the half-elf options replaced the profiencies with minor cantrips, but im not sure, will check.

1
lizardfolkwarrior•

They lose the "skill versatility" trait, but get some minot other power, depending on their heritage. From example, an aquatic half-elf gets a swimming speed of 30.

1
khellickOP•

Yeah. It's not really a full subclass option but more just thematic alterations.

1
Dprquinn•

I was hoping for a bit more too. Don't get me wrong, still very excited. But way back before it was announced I was sure it would be the Planeswalker's Adventurer's Guide and include the new classes etc.

I understand now why they aren't in there, it just seemed we were trending that direction at the time. I'm a bit bummed that there aren't too many surprises - SCAG had very little from UA, for comparison.

3
khellickOP•

Of course, I'm excited for it too.

Yeah, I get what you mean. I understand that making a lot of completely new content, and then making sure everything is reasonably balanced to a set of core rules and to the other content in the material is hard, time consuming, and costs a lot of money, so I'm not particularly surprised that they have included SCAG content.

1
Aarakocra•

Economically, a publisher like WotC has to balance increasing the desire to purchase new content with liquidating existing stocks of old content. Notably, everything in EEPC besides the Genasi will be released with Xanathar's based on what I've seen, because a free module means that including the content elsewhere does not compromise the (nonexistent) stocks of books.

SCAG, though? They have to consider that if they republish all the subclasses and the cantrips, what reason do most people have to buy the books? They can include some of the content, but re-releasing all of it means that any unsold SCAGs rely on DMs who want the lore content. When that supplement is cleared out or WotC judges that anyone wanting the content will have already purchased the book, they will reduce prices and look at including everything in new books. Once SCAGs do not need to sell, the subclasses can be re-released as easy additional content in a PHB2 or relevant other books.

The same process would occur with Volo's and the DMG. They won't release the contents of those books elsewhere until they feel reasonably certain that doing so will not compromise sales of existing materials.

That is why Wizards don't just release all content into new books. It may be aggravating for players, and especially for AL, but a business has to consider not just what is beneficial for the new books, but whether it compromises other products. A PetSmart isn't going to buy pallets of this nice new food when it has a surplus of the same niche already. The store would try and get rid of existing stocks and THEN buy the great new products to sell.

3
khellickOP•

Economically, a publisher like WotC has to balance increasing the desire to purchase new content with liquidating existing stocks of old content.

True, I understand that much.

SCAG, though?

SCAG was a really bad release imo. A lot of the material is lore based, which is really limiting. Yes, there are quite a number of character options, but I don't think it's enough to attract players who aren't interested in the Forgotten Realms lore.

The same process would occur with Volo's and the DMG.

I think both of those books are far more useful and valuable for players to own.

That is why Wizards don't just release all content into new books.

I get what you're saying, but apart from SCAG I think most of the other books with class options have enough material that they still warrant purchasing.

2
Aarakocra•

That's the thing, if they really did reprint the player options into Xanathar's then the parts that make those other books really useful and valuable quickly drain away, at least for players. The DMG is an odd one because there is little reason for any non-DM to really use it because any approved content would be a general approval anyway, and then things like magic items aren't under the control of the players at all. Put simply, the DMG is basically a DM-only resource and so out of the span of this discussion. Volo's would remain as a useful DM tool, but reprinting the player races would mean that the only players who need to bother with the book are those who need the monster stat blocks, such as conjurers or a Moon Druid. Yes, they could maybe manage just fine as DM resources, but they have to make books profitable to justify publishing them and low sales of DM-only resources seriously harms that goal.

2
khellickOP•

That is true. Wizards have definitely been designing their books so there is something for everyone. Which is good in some ways, but also bad in others.

But yes, profitability for some books would go down. I'm just curious how many additional people would just buy a single large book outright.

1
NihilCantabile•

What ?? You didn't like the 17 pages of names??? What kind of fanboy are you?!!

2
tomcat8400Sorcerer•

I am mildly disappointed in Xanathar's, but only because they didn't include the skill feats.

I'm still going to give them my money though, so I can't be too upset.

2
khellickOP•

Yes, I've heard that a lot. I think it would been nice to have them that too, but I understand that a lot of things touched upon in Unearthed Arcana is still very much in development.

I mean, I'm still giving them my money. I want Wizards to continue to make good content. I just wish they would make it easier for people to consume it.

1
xfactor13891•

I don't think the Skill Feats were received overly well. I personally found them pointless because all they did was have my players waste a feat for something I would have let them do anyways.

For the extra skill and a Plus 1 to an ability score for some minor added bonus, I didn't see them as that valuable. I would already allow my players to do acrobatics checks to negate rough terrain. I would already allow my players to use their animal handling to try and coax a friendly animal to help them. So to give up 1 point in an ability score just didn't seem like a fair trade off to me.

1
tomcat8400Sorcerer•

In contrast, I had a tough time envisioning a wizard who didn't take Arcanist, or a druid who didn't take Naturalist. Expertise in your class's main skill coupled with good spells and a bonus to your main stat was just too good, and the +1 could easily even out a score and keep you on track if you planned your character for it.

3
xfactor13891•

I honestly have a problem with that, If something is so good that you can't picture a class not taking it... Then I feel it was poor design. That is probably an unpopular opinion, but I feel that if you are going to make a feat it should be a neat option that makes you think "Man that would be cool" not "Man I gotta have that!"

3
tomcat8400Sorcerer•

That's a fair point that I hadn't really thought of. I guess not having expertise in my main skill bugs me, and the skill feats seemed like a wonderful way to help that. The d20 vastly outweighs the skill bonus even at mid levels, so I've gotten this idea in my head that to be "good" at a thing, double proficiency is required. It's not an idea that's right, just one that's seeped in.

So for most people, I don't think it would be required, but if I'm going to play a wizard, I want them to be experts in their field, not just good at it.

1
Shazoa•

The expertise was the main draw. Being able to get arcana expertise for wizards, or nature expertise for druids etc... it was a good way of allowing that while still gating it behind an ASI. The bonuses were just that, because a +1 and expertise is good enough.

There are already things in the game that can be duplicated through improvised actions such as the battlemaster disarm and push maneuvers. I don't think that's really a problem, the features or feats just give you s reliable way of getting that functionality.

1
faeyinn•

Yeah, I'm also mildly disappointed in it. I hate the Hexblade so bad and they've not put in much for the Wizard, I guess because they don't want to give the best class more nice things. And the 50 pages worth of example names is pretty trashy.

1
khellickOP•

I don't know much about the Hexblade, so I can't say either way. And yes, I would have like another 2 Wizard subclasses. I'm actually okay with the 20 pages worth of names. As a DM I think it will be useful to me. And as long as they're interesting, I don't really have a problem with it. They better have a pronunciation guide and a break down of the name in terms of meanings and cultural/historical significance.

1
Vincent210Hexblade Manhunter•

You're getting panned for this, but after reading over the thread I'm inclined to at least understand where you're coming from.

If every single WotC book in my area was a full $60 no exceptions, as a customer I would have a lot higher standards as to what books I want sold to me, and how much content gets packed in.

Something like SCAG would be an insult to me, and I'd be really interested in seeing the highlights (martial cantrips, Bladesinger, Swashbuckler, etc.) being reprinted into XGE.

Using that as a segue, that's exactly where I'm mildly disappointed with the XGE myself. If we were going to have only a handful of reprints from SCAG to XGE, it should have been the martial cantrips and Bladesinger, not Sun Soul and the Rogue sub-classes.

Open up the PHB + 1, write a more generic Bladesinger background without the Elven restriction, consolidate Wizard sub-classes alongisde the new spell lists so no Wizard feels handicapped when touching the new content, and let War Wizards (War is in the name, people!) get martial cantrips.

Stone Sorcerer would've also been nice, but I understand not including it completely, so I can't say it's a sticking point for me. It's not necessarily unbalanced in and of itself, but it could use a little more time in the oven because, if anything, it feels kinda undertuned if it was supposed to be a fancy gish, and would've been heavily moreso undertuned by the fact that the martial cantrips were not reprinted into this book.

In summary:

  • Should've had Bladesinger, with alternative lore options

  • Should've had martial cantrips (Booming Blade, Green-Flame Blade, Lightning Lure, etc.)

But two minor gripes about an otherwise major book is trifling. I love what XGE is even still, and still consider it to be the book to have for the game as we move forward. I don't consider naming pages filler (I spend an unreasonable amount of time trying to get proper-sounding names for my characters and come up short half the time. I'm not going to expand that time googling names, so a 17 page list appeals to me), the DM rules are pure dream-stuff to me (AoE rules, Armor sleeping rules, Falling rules? SIGN ME UP), and a list of 25 sub-classes and a huge deposit of new spells is fantastic, and blows the numbers you're quoting from other books out of the water. 13 Races and 13 sub-classes from all previous content barely tops the 25 sub-class number combined so I'm feeling pretty well-treated for value.

Hope you have fun with the new content, even though you're a little disappointed.

1
khellickOP•

If every single WotC book in my area was a full $60 no exceptions, as a customer I would have a lot higher standards as to what books I want sold to me, and how much content gets packed in.

SCAG is the exception ($50 I think) but most of the content isn't really worthwhile for me to buy it. There are a few subclasses and racial trait variant options, but those are about it for what is actually useful to me.

So yeah, the highlights are something I'm looking forward to seeing.

write a more generic Bladesinger background without the Elven restriction

Yeah, the Elf restriction for Bladesingers is annoying to me. I dislike having class options limited to races. Sure, say something like "The elves are the most notable of the Bladesingers", but have it open to everyone.

consider it to be the book to have for the game as we move forward

I completely agree, for both players and DMs it's going to be a really useful book.

I don't consider naming pages filler

Same here, pretty much for the exact same rules as yourself.

Hope you have fun with the new content, even though you're a little disappointed.

Yeah, I will definitely do so. I'm going to be running a new campaign (CoS) on the 7th, and except for a couple of classes which take their subclasses at level 1, I'm sure a bunch will be using the new content. Plus I'm going to look over all the rules outside of that.

1
JestaKillaWizard•

Reprint stuff from the DMG? Oh HELL no.

Your suggestion amounts to making people pay for a lot of material again. That turns some potential customers off, meaning fewer sales. And a bigger book needs to sell more copies to maintain profitability at the same price point. Plus, if you pack all the character options from, for instance, Volo's Guide to Monsters in there, you are undercutting potential sales of Volo's as well as the new product. No thank you!

1
QuastorsPact of the Dungeon Master•

I was really hoping that Wizards of the Coast would make Xanathar's into THE supplement book for 5e.

Well you hoped wrong then and should get better at managing your expectations.

Xanathar's currently appears to be just under 200 pages while the Player's Handbook is around 320 pages.

The PHB is a core book and those are generally bigger than supplements.

We are being asked to pay the same price for Xanathar's as the Player Handbook ($49.95US according to the Wizards' website.)

I'd say don't buy it, but it seems Wizards has their gunmen surrounding your home already.

All the additional material I'm asking for except for the Artificer and Mystic classes would take no extra work for Wizards. It already exists.

Neither of those are remotely ready to publish. Artificer is an incoherent mess which requires a complete rework IMO and is mechanically weak.

Mystic only needs rewording of about 3/4th of their powers to work right, so they're closer, but still have deep issues to solve before they should be shipped.

But the advantage of including all the existing supplemental content for people who have already bought it would be that they get a lot of new content(and yes, I recognise that there is a lot), but they also get all the supplemental character options in a single book.

I'm not really interested in buying stuff I already have again. Replacing all of the old stuff with new content would be better. I would prefer it if none of the SCAG stuff was there tbh.

0
khellickOP•

Well you hoped wrong then and should get better at managing your expectations.

Obviously.

The PHB is a core book and those are generally bigger than supplements.

Of course, but I would like supplements to be around the 250 page mark. Under 200 pages is really pushing it for me.

Neither of those are remotely ready to publish.

Yes, I know. While I would have liked them to be included, I completely understand that they aren't ready.

I'm not really interested in buying stuff I already have again.

Yeah, I know that a lot of people are like that. For me the ability to easily transport all the content is really important, which is why it would be worthwhile.

1
ApplejaxcF2/R2/R2/M2/P2/C8•

I'm disappointed by just about everything Wizard's has done since 5e. Class balance, monster choices, race options in Volo's, magic item balance...

Every time I see the smug nerds barely containing their excitement in every "Look at Samurai" or "Look at Divine Soul" interview things that come out once a week, I lose more and more confidence in my purchase.

-5
EnergyIs•

Idle curiosity : what do you want?

2
ApplejaxcF2/R2/R2/M2/P2/C8•
  1. A better dungeon masters guide (although it's a tad late for that), with better formatted and designed magic item values and loot tables
  2. Eberron, Dark Sun, and Dragon Mech (in that order) for 5e
  3. A handful of wishlist monsters, like chokers
  4. Volo's monstrous player races to be less silly, and less incongruous compared to their MM entries (extra bugbear reach, +1 int hobgoblins, etc)
  5. Less weird extra mechanics that fail to be streamlined with the rest of 5e and aren't as interesting as 3.5, finding a perfect middle ground of just being annoying. A lot of the UA feats did this (to a lesser extent: "if you attacked with advantage, and the second dice also would have hit, you can pick one of these 4 things to do").
1
xfactor13891•
  1. What exactly about the DMG don't you like. It has everything I would want in a DMG besides random encounter tables. They deliberately left the things you mentioned vague to allow the DM the ability to make them unique in his world. A Legendary Item in my world might be worth Millions of gold because of how rare magic is, but in your world a Legendary Item is common place and you can get one for 50,000 gp. I honestly love their tables for rolling loot.

  2. So you're upset because they haven't released any of the campaign settings you wanted them to release? That doesn't seem fair to say that they have done a horrible job because "This this and this aren't released."

  3. I don't see the problem with the amount of monsters the MM has released. One of my major problems with Pathfinder RPG was that once they got into 4-5 bestiaries I had so many monsters I didn't know what to do with them. I think the 5e MM has enough monsters and DMG has great rules for creating our own monsters. If you desperately need the Choker go buy The Critter Compendium off the DMsguild website and you'll have all those classic monsters you want.

  4. Volo's races were fantastic, I don't see how they were silly. In fact I have played a few of them and they were really fun.

  5. UA is not official material, it's playtest, I don't allow it in my games so I fail to see how there are weird Extra Mechanics. If you don't like the little things then get rid of them. You are the DM run the game you want to run. Unless your not the DM in which case become the DM and you can run them the way you want to run them.

1
ApplejaxcF2/R2/R2/M2/P2/C8•
  1. It's too vague to be useful to experienced DMs, and it's too specific to be useful to new DMs. It front loads a lot of work and expectations for the DM that are criticized as presenting a new DM with unnecessary and unneeded pressure. The 3.5 DMG's formatting was better, with world creation not being the first issue.
  2. I'm not upset because they haven't released EB, DS, and DM; I was asked what I wanted.
  3. It isn't the amount of monsters (though I will always want more); it's which monsters. This is a minor gripe, especially considering the ease of converting 3.5 content to 5e. Again, I was asked what I wanted.
  4. Volos races are not fantastic. They're silly and incongruous.
  5. I know UA isn't official material; it's the play test material, however, that reveals what's in the future of 5e-and it has consistently been dubious choices that fail to fill me with confidence. If one or two UAs were questionable, and the rest were meh or hopeful, it wouldn't be an issue; so far every UA has made me think "Well that's obviously an oversight" or "That doesn't look like it fits into the rest of 5e" or "that's clearly a direct upgrade to another option." The Favored Soul, for example: More powerful than a sorcerer, then nerfed, and then made entirely uninteresting, and then dropped completely and replaced with "Divine Soul" because WotC doesn't want to meet player expectations of the FS, as per the 3.5 class, and wants the cop out. It doesn't matter whether it's official content or not-it's the only indicator we have of the intentions of the future of the game, which seems bleak. This is my biggest 5e complaint: UAs are over powered, or uninteresting, or dumb, and then new books come out with the same problem, and every time someone points out "Hey, it looks like they tried to retool X from the UA but the feedback they received must have been ignored/poor, next time let's do a better job reporting on UA" everyone's response is "shut the fuck up, it's play test material not official material just don't allow it in your game."
1
EnergyIs•

The dmg is great. It has tons of items and lots of good advice for worldbuilding. Volos guide pc races seem slightly weird but it doesn't bother me. Ua is Ua to get feedback. So critiquing it as if it's default is missing the point. I haven't heard of dragon mech what is that? Dark sun and ebberon would be great.

1
ApplejaxcF2/R2/R2/M2/P2/C8•

it has tons of items

Define "tons"

good advice for worldbuilding

I disagree

So critiquing it as if it's default is missing the point

I'm not critiquing it as default. I'm critiquing it as a pattern of questionable decisions that have resulted in end products I don't like.

I haven't heard of dragon mech what is that?

Unfortunately, no one has. It's probably for the best because, honestly, it's a stupid campaign setting.

Dragon Mech was a campaign setting back in the day that never gained widespread recognition/popularity. Essentially, it turns out the moon is a giant fucking egg for big-ass space dragons (which are a billion times more powerful than lame earth dragons). One day it cracks, and the massive chippings rain down on earth as successive meteor showers that completely destroy the surface world and force everyone into living underground.

The resulting world is a blasted wasteland of sand and devastation, where lunar dragons have established themselves as the apex predators and random meteor showers deliver more and destroy more.

The various races have discovered steam-powered technology, magical machinery, necromechanics, clockwork contraptions, and slave power, and use them to drive Dragon Mechs, which are anything from individual power suits to Gundams to massive, walking fortresses.

As you can imagine, the DragonMechs and the lunar dragons get into a lot of fights. And it's awesome.

It added a class that slowly replaced body parts with steam contraptions, making the character more and more dependent on coal for functionality (and eventually to live at all), as well as engineers, machine-priests, and everything else you'd expect.

Oh, and all the earth gods are getting their ass kicked by lunar gods.

It's the weird, kind of depressing and overwhelming campaign setting where no matter how cool your mech is or how powerful you become, you're losing. The whole earth is losing. You can't fight meteor showers and lunar dragons and space gods. You're fucked. You're lucky if you don't just plain starve to death.

Edit to my list of desired campaign settings: I'd like to see DragonStar brought into 5e as well.

1
LexieJeidSocial Justice Paladin•

Why are you even here?

1
ApplejaxcF2/R2/R2/M2/P2/C8•

Because the op asked if anyone else was disappointed, and I'm tired of a circle-jerking subreddit blowing smoke up WotC's ass when the quality of their content has been in steady decline since 5e? (Which, in itself, I enjoy immensely-just not anything thusfar published to UA or released after the MM/PHB)

0
KhrFreak•

I think LexieJeid was asking why you're in the 5E sub if you don't like 5E

1
ApplejaxcF2/R2/R2/M2/P2/C8•

I like 5e.

I don't like anything WotC has done with 5e, post-release.

1