ELI5: Why can’t you add 2 110v household wires together to create 220v?

Physics

AC confuses me.

I can connect to AA batteries together in series and get 3v.

How come two 110 volts AC wires can’t be added together to create 220 volts AC?

For example, I want to charge an electric car fast but I don’t have a 220v outlet.

It seems to me like you should be able to take two separate 110 outlets, plug the into a box that puts them in series and blam-o0: 220v.

What prevents this (I’m assuming this violates some law of physics) from being a thing?

Posted Oct 30, 2017, 8:16 PM UTC

3077
krystar78•

you can.....if they're on different phases.

power coming off the grid is 2 phase, 2 sine wave voltages that are 180degrees offset from each other. when electrician wires up the electrical panel, each circuit only gets one of those phases. but if he wires up a circuit with opposites different phases, it'll be 220v.

there are products that allow you plug in 2 outlets to make a 220v.

http://www.quick220.com/

26
Sound_SpeedOP•

Wow, thank you for your answer. I have tried Googling this but I think was missing the right terminology to get the right answer (or to find quick220)

...but this spawns a whole new set of questions:

So when power comes into my house in 2 phases, does that mean that half of my circuits are out of phase with the other half?

And, does the quick220 just shift the phases? I notice that it doubles the voltage but not the amps (I think my confusion comes from thinking about electricity like water in a hose...) And how is this product different from a Variable Frequency Drive?

7
vahntitrio•

Correct. You have 220 V sent to your house. 110 V outlets are wired line to neutral, 220 V outlets (like your oven) are wired line to line. The circuits can be on either phase, and are usually alternated throughout a house.

8
slipperymagoo•

The term you're looking for is split phase.

5
Pseudonymite•

Yep, two phase is 90° out of phase and extremely rare.

1†
GoodDave•

Mno. Two phase is separated by 180.

Edit: Its 120 not 180. Exhaustion makes the brain have funny thoughts.

-1†
krystar78•

yes. if you look at your panel, there's left side and right side. any two adjacent spots on same side will be on diff phases. usually odds run on the left, evens on the right. 1 & 3 will be out of phase. 3&5 will be out of phase. 2&4, 4&6.

dunno how quick220 internals work...but it has 2 cords that you plug into two wall outlets that are on different phases. then you get 220v output that you can plug in your EV charger.

3
Sound_SpeedOP•

I had no idea about the sides of the panel.

Do electricians have to consider phases when wiring a house beyond the electrical panel or is it random?

3
krystar78•

i'm sure they try to spread the load between different phases. it won't help to put all the heavy loads on same phase. dishwasher, kitchen, laundry, hvac, and electric oven/microwave are prob going to balanced on different phases.

4
Mdcastle•

Shared neutrals are becoming more uncommon with arc fault circuit interrupter requirements, but you used to be able to do three wire circuits, you'd take a hot from either side and one neutral and run them to say the kitchen where you'd have the two 20 amp circuits required by code. Because the two hot are out of phase the neutral would never carry more current than either one of the hots. This worked out good too because the kitchen is where you'd plug a lot of high power appliances (microwave, coffeemaker, griddle, toaster oven) in so it would spread them out between phases.

3
edman007•

As someone else said, in a panel the phases alternate. So you'll typically have 40 breaker slots, and they alternate both numerically and vertically. So L1 is 1,4,5,8,9... and L2 is 2,3,6,7. You can see it here.

Thus typically, they don't do anything to balance the load, you just install sequentially and it will be even, or as good as you can predict anyways. Large loads (dryers, electric stoves, central air) are basically always 2 phase, so they are always loaded equally.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
ChubbyCheekedChap•

Not two phases.

0
whitcwa•

The 240 and 120 volts come from a center tapped transformer. The center tap is neutral and the ends of the windings are at 120 with respect to the center, but are 180 degrees out of phase.

A VFD is used to control a motor. Some can generate three phase AC.

3
Sound_SpeedOP•

Thanks. Like I mentioned in the original post, AC confuses me.

My specific question was the simplest one that I could distill from a bunch of questions that have been bothering me for a while.

1
The_camperdave•

It's kind of like a seesaw. When one phase goes up, the other goes down. Neutral doesn't change.

1
8D97E334•

I'm deeply ashamed, because I should know that.

Anyway, why don't the currents interact destructively as they are in opposite phases ?

edit: Ok I'm probably wrong to think about it in terms of current.

3
mmmmmmBacon12345•

We live in a constant voltage world, current is a result of the applied voltage.

Since you're applying the voltage on different lines they don't "interact" really, but the load does see one wire going up to +170V while the other is going down to -170V then sees them both heading back towards 0 then going to -170 and +170

If you were to connect the lines together they'd interact destructively, in the form of an arc flash and a fire

3
8D97E334•

Right ! Thanks for the explanation :)

1
The_camperdave•

why don't the currents interact destructively as they are in opposite phases ?

They do...with respect to neutral. Think of a teeter-totter. Each phase is like half the teeter-totter. When you're pulling 120V, you're pulling either from the left half or the right half of the teeter totter and the center of the teeter-totter. When you're pulling 220V, you're pulling from one end to the other. The center isn't involved.

1
ChubbyCheekedChap•

Phase? NO.

Please correct your post.

99.999999 percent of USA houses use single phase power. With two 110vac runs with a common neutral.

These are not two phases.

3
snerz•

Of course you got downvoted for being correct. Split-phase is not two-phase.

2
Pseudonymite•

I got some idiot arguing with me further up the thread, they tried to correct me for saying that two phase is 90° out of phase.

He claims that it's common in his industry to call split phase two phase. But he won't say what that industry is.

It bugs me when people try to bullshit about stuff like that. On one hand, it really doesn't matter. But on the other, I worked hard to learn what I know, and to be allowed to work on power systems.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
valeyard89•

220, 221, whatever it takes.

1
FBX•

They may be 110v from neutral, but are they 110v from each other? If you have a 9V battery and hook up two leads to the positive and a third to the negative terminal and put them in series, you're not going to get a 18v potential on the circuit, you just get a circuit with varying resistance.

All of your 110v outlets in the house are (if wired properly) in parallel with each other at the breaker box and on the same phase, so not much will happen if you attempt to put them in series. You can put a 220v breaker into your box off the two hot leads coming from the weatherhead to get a 220v outlet.

5
Sound_SpeedOP•

Your 9V battery example helps, thanks.

3
jjs2424•

Voltage (electric potential energy) is a relative quantity. So, whenever you see a voltage you have to ask "relative to what reference point?"

In the case of your house, all your outlets provide a voltage relative to the common ground for your house. So if you daisy chained two outlets together in series, you'd have a wire at 110V above ground connected to the ground connection of another. Which is just a giant short. But let's pretend that wasn't the case.

If you connected the hot terminal of a 110V-above-house-ground outlet to the ground terminal of another, you'd just get a hot terminal with 110V-above-house-ground and a ground terminal at 110V-above-house-ground, or no voltage difference at all.

Batteries produce a voltage difference between their two terminals. So if the "negative" terminal is at 10V and it's a 5V battery, then the "positive" terminal will be at 10V + 5V = 15V.

Note that this has nothing to do with AC vs. DC.

5
Sound_SpeedOP•

Ok, I think I am beginning to see where a lot of my misunderstanding comes from...there is no negative terminal equivalent in an AC.

Just to clarify, AC voltage is measured in my house relative to the ground (0v), correct?

And if I take the two phases running into my house and they run together, with opposite phases, the voltage differences would be 220v (?)

(Thank you for your answer, at first I was not getting what you were saying until someone else in this thread did a ELI4.)

3
whitcwa•

It can work, but it should never be done! If there is a fault, a 240V breaker will open both phases. If you make a 240V source from two 120V outlets, a fault may only trip one phase leaving the other hot.

6
Sound_SpeedOP•

I am actually not planning on doing any home wiring (I stop at changing fixtures and adding dimmers). I'm nowhere near knowledgable enough to mess with the panel or 220v - I will leave that to an actual electrician at this point.

My example was purely hypothetical but thank you for clarifying that it should never be done in real life.

2
jjs2424•

Yes, if you disconnected the neutral from one outlet and connected it to the hot side of another, but out-of-phase, you could (at the moment of maximum voltage) get +110V on one terminal and -110V on the other, for a total voltage difference of 220V.

3
FigBug•

It's not that hard to add a 220v outlet yourself. There are a decent number of YouTube tutorials. It costs < $100 for the breaker, some wire, the outlet, etc. It's easiest if you have an unfinished garage / basement where the electrical panel is.

3
cejmp•

If you run a wire from a 110v outlet and another wire from another 110v outlet, you have not increased the 110v being supplied to the outlets.

The outlets are not the power source, they are a distribution point.

2 Batteries in series are 2 different power suppliers. An outlet is not a power supplier, it's a branch from the distribution panel or load center.

3
devonica•

You don't get 110 V. In North America you are getting 120/240 mostly in old residential buildings. Single phase. Two poles. That's what you have at home. It's a single phase... both poles are 180° apart. Thus making 240 between the two poles. Read up on it..

3
Sound_SpeedOP•

I'm looking it up now. Most of my misconceptions regarding AC came from knowing a bit of how DC works.

I was having trouble finding easy to understand info because I was lacking a few pieces of key terminology.

I now have a good starting point to read up on it now.

3
DoctorDblYou•

You think this is confusing just add in 208V and 347V to the mix, it’s taken me years to understand. Not an electrician btw

4
devonica•

thats just a potential between two legs. You get 120/208 from a Wye transformer. All newer installations aren't 120/240, they are 120/208. Voltage between Neutral and one of the legs is 120 V, between two legs is 208 in a single or three phase system. its 208 because of the relationship of the phases and the fact that they are 120 degrees apart.
120 * sqrt(3) = 208

In Canada commercial installations get 347/600 three phase

347 * sqrt(3) = 600

There is a neat mathematical proof for all this. but you gotta be somewhat good in math to understand it.

1
DoctorDblYou•

Yes my current job site has 600V/200A 3P & then I have a transformer to 120/208 . I just don’t know if it’s right when I’m looking at it. Good thing I’m in charge :)

1
sonicjesus•

Putting aside the issue of split phase power, the reason it doesn't work like you expect is that a line coming into your house is like having one battery, and each outlet is simply connected to in a chain.

3
Sound_SpeedOP•

This is by far the simplest explanation. Thanks.

2

You can modify the voltage via a voltage doubler. The main problem for AC's is, that if you have two sources, they dont alternate at the exact same time. This prevents a simple linking like you would do with a DC.

2
defakto227•

Always thought voltage doublers were for DC circuits only.

2
whitcwa•

Correct. They use pulsating rectified DC.

1
satertek•

Yes. Voltage is just a subtraction problem.

Once every 1/60th of a second, half of the lines in your house are at 110V, and the other half are at -110V.

If you take power from different lines you get 110V - (-110V) = 220V

But if you take two of the same line you'll get 110V - 110V = 0V

(And whether you call it 110V, 120V or 120/240V doesn't really matter...it all refers to the same thing)

2
[deleted]•

[removed]

1