Asking employer that didn't rank me for feedback

Co-op

The one interview that I had (which I felt went well) resulted in a not ranked. Since my track record for interviews is less than average, I would like to find out where I was lacking. Do you think it is appropriate for me to send a message to the interviewer politely asking for feedback on my interview performance? (He never gave me contact info so I would be guessing his email address.)

Also, do you think that is something I could get in trouble with CECA for?

Posted Nov 1, 2017, 4:45 PM UTC

713
[deleted]•

I've done this before but have only gotten very generic answers back, so it wasn't very helpful.

7
Attriamarch of the geese•

probably not a good idea if he/she never gave you their contact info

I've only asked them about my interview performance when I was extended with a business card after the interview (same goes for thank you emails as well)

5
ilovecorntoomuchCS Major, Psych Minor•

Pretty sure interviews are for their benefit and not yours. don't expect a feedback.

3
jakub_g14•

I did this in first year and got some feedback on my resume. It's worth a try, but most managers are busy and will likely give you generic feedback.

3

dont do it

2
anothercooperOPengineering•

any particular reason why?

1
nuzlockerom120•

Because they dont care. As an employer they are looking for the best person for the position, and have little or no incentive to help someone improve their interview skills.

As well as some people have mentioned, it could open them up for liability.

CECA does however have incentive and wants you to succeed, so if you are looking for feedback those practice ones would be the best to do. Best of luck bro.

1
trustyTowelCS 3B•

A lot of people already said it's not a great idea, but just a suggestion if you still really want feedback - it might be worthwhile to go to some interview practice workshops. Different orgs on campus hold them every once in a while, I'm sure the eng faculty in particular has a bunch.

2
CoopSalaries•

Heads up that some companies have policies against giving people feedback on why they weren't hired, because they're afraid it opens them up to discrimination liability. So don't be surprised if you ask but either a) don't get feedback b) don't get genuine/complete feedback.

2
cheekyyucker•

literally will get no information in return. Employers are equally cunty about this, it's a prisoners dilemma

1
Mohtheproo•

Was it the Help desk IT at the uni? If so pm me

1
nero626123•

i did it last year and i ended up getting the offer lol

1
kw2002•

I've done this before, don't see anything wrong with it. Don't expect much specific feedback though, they probably don't really remember the interview, and would have to refer to notes.

-1