r/kpop•
amethystee

Characteristic Sounds of Your Favorite Group(s)?

[Discussion]

Random discussion topic which popped into my head. What are the characteristic sounds, melodies, genres of your favorite group(s)? What kinds of things, if heard, would make you recognize a song's artist on the spot?

I'll start off- MAMAMOO is known for their funky and vocally-oriented songs. Some trademarks I'd point to are AHH OOP! with the funky and retro styling. They really like to have harmonies (since the group harmonizes so well) and big band/band accompaniment in songs (for example, Mr. Ambiguous.

As individuals, Hwasa really like to sing dramatically and with a sultry tone, so a lot of times you get little cat growls or similar lines in their songs. Moonbyul's raps usually come off as a little boyish and punchy, which is always fun.

Posted Nov 11, 2017, 11:02 PM UTC

5363
piff1214GOTWICE | Sana •

Twice has a very distinct song formula.

129
kKunoichiSURISURI ♠•

Haha so accurate. Likey is like a return to before but all jumbled up like it has Jihyo and Mina switch around now for chorus and bridge

35
fujipommeshimmy shimmy coconut•

It also starts with Sana instead!

13
mylord420Don't Lose Your Temper So So So Quickly •

Why is there a picture of momo in the "sana does something cute" for TT?

3†
piff1214GOTWICE | Sana •

That’s Sana. She is just wearing a wig.

19
mylord420Don't Lose Your Temper So So So Quickly •
5
FoxtrotTango•

The biggest thing that sets SHINee apart for me is how every single member's voice is distinctive. And not just within the group, within kpop as a whole. Like, blindfold me and play 100 different idols singing and I'm pretty sure I'd be able to pick out Onew, Jonghyun, and Key with very little trouble. And that quality for me makes their songs more memorable - they harmonize well but they also each add their own flair. It doesn't hurt that their voices usually bring different ranges either, it makes everything sound more dynamic and not so one-note, which is a problem a lot of music has, pop, kpop, and otherwise.

Past that they have the high production values you'd expect from an SM group, but I'd also just describe a good portion of their catalogue as classic, the kind of R&B-pop fusion that never really gets old. It always feels one step ahead of the trends (counter-intuitive as that sounds), not necessarily in an experimental or flashy way but in a way that usually ^usually ages well, and they are fantastic at delivering a punchline with their music. Like, there's a build-up, but then there is most definitely a delivery, instrumentally or vocally or both. They're just pleasant to listen to.

Also, dibidibidis.

83
Muffin278•

Don't forget *whispers "SHINees back"

27
salarygirlIts B.A.P, Yes Sir! r/BAP | r/SHINee | VIXX•

back back back back, go!

8
salarygirlIts B.A.P, Yes Sir! r/BAP | r/SHINee | VIXX•

Is SHINee considered public friendly in their home turf? I know their earworms and Minho are something the general public identify them by, but broadly speaking?

1
FoxtrotTango•

Not in Korea, so can't say with any authority, but I'd be curious to know as well.

My totally unsupported perception is they're overall well liked and have decent recognition for an idol group, though probably only through a handful of title tracks/earworms like you mentioned. It seems like their market from the beginning leaned towards an older demographic, and my guess is that has helped them in both maintaining a fanbase and garnering some level of public respect outside the school-age crowd. But even with the positive view I doubt the average person could identify most of them by name or anything.

1
ghetto_marshmallow2Red Velvet Supremacist™•

What I like about Red Velvet is that no matter how different their concept is or even how different the genre is, the song still sounds very Red Velvet. I'm not sure exactly what it is that gives each song the characteristic sound, but sometimes I think it may be because they all, (but Seulgi and Joy especially) have very unique voices and their voices perfectly suit each other's. There also seems to be a fantasy-like sound in their music that makes it seem like you're in a fairytale, but I also don't know what specifically causes that.

79
heoldaebaksagunsone•

They have great group harmonies. Their choruses for title songs are always sang by the whole group rather than one or two members.

52
drewleean1Red Velvet•

Except for One of These Nights but they still had some great harmonies.

8
heoldaebaksagunsone•

Ah thank you for the correction. I was trying to remember but you're right. Though I think for the final chorus which is more climatic than the others, they do sing it together.

10
jananansiYuris "spicy" line in All Night•

What kinds of things, if heard, would make you recognize a song's artist on the spot?

SNSD change concept/sound all the time, the only thing that's fairly reoccuring is a Taeyeon highnote and the occasional cheesy english intro.

75
serowajinSNSD | BTS | Bolbbalgan4•

I'm still half convinced Yoonas intro in All Night was satirical

52
onceuponathrowEXID•

Nah, she was just replying to Tiffany's line from Party.

25
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
mylord420Don't Lose Your Temper So So So Quickly •

Cheesy English somewhere in the song.

"Tell me boy .. oh oh oh OH!"

" DJ.... PUT IT BACK ON ! "

" P A R T Y ITS PARTY TIME"

20
suitsffsSistar•

Tbf half of kpop has cheesy (or cringy) english lines

8
wonderfullyedibleSUGA's tongue technology / Somin's body rolls / Tymee time•

Do you believe the situation? Yeah.

6
shownu25•

Couldn’t agree more. Also, what does your flair mean?

5
jananansiYuris "spicy" line in All Night•

I just have an irrational love for Yuri saying spicy (and that part in general).

I don't know why, guess it's the power your UB has on you :P

16
ArysOakheart트와스틴벨벳시대 | IGAB•

Literally one week of promotions. Seriously what the actual fuck??? Why even bother in the first place then?? Still baffles me.

14
jananansiYuris "spicy" line in All Night•

I used to be bitter but now I'm mostly thankful, they're the first gg to even get a 10th anniversary album and we got a lot of performances for the fanmeet (also another try not to cry challenge)

8
heoldaebaksagunsone•

It's always been a small gripe of mine that Sooyoung didn't have an English word in her line there to follow seo's "baby face" and yuri's "spicy".

10
annalooey•

Omg!! When I first heard it I was like did she just say spicy? AND NOW IT'S MY FAVORITE PART OF THE WHOLE SONG

2
browniesandpuppiesyellow popcorn•

I used to hate the cheesy English lines when I was younger, but I absolutely adore it now.

1
TehSteakKARD - AoA - EXID - Red Velvet•

#HEY

#BRAVE SOUND

74
griffbendorIt's 11:11 I'm Genie for your Wonderland•
  • Wonder Girls: Always the retro-sounding synths! They were known for their throwback concepts/songs for a reason. No matter what song it is there's always something distinctly "retro" about it. Nobody/Reboot in general are good examples of this, but also Sweet and Easy/Be My Baby/etc. have a sound that is "dated" but they're still fairly catchy, ya know?
  • SHINee: Harmonies but besides that, modulation central and vocal colors. In their chiller songs, modulations aren't as present (1 of 1, View), but stuff like Married to the Music, Sherlock, Why So Serious?, etc, so many modulations. I'm pretty sure there's like 5 different keys used in Why So Serious, which is fairly ridiculous. Besides that, the most distinctive thing is their vocal colors; it's pretty easy to distinguish between Jonghyun, Onew, and Key on their songs. Minho and Taemin might take a little longer to pick out (it took me a fair amount of time, sometimes I get Minho mixed up with Key), but in general they all have really distinctive tones. And for a smaller group, it really helps.
  • Red Velvet: Harmonies! If you will usually hear Seulgi singing the main harmonizing lines in the chorus, she's the distinct part of the harmony and everyone else is working around her. Not sure why, but you can always hear her more prominently in the chorus harmonies than the other members. Seulgi also used to do all the opening lines up to Russian Roulette; that's changed now. We'll see if it's a return to form with Peekaboo but I'm pretty sure they've changed it up. Oh yes and one more thing, WenSeul harmonies + Irene/Yeri harmonies and Joy meeting those two duos somewhere depending on where she's needed.
  • EXO: Chen's voice. No seriously, it's such a clear tone and it provides a lot of character to their song. Besides that, I would say they have the "R&B" style vocals down pretty well; even though they're singing one of the farthest things from R&B, it still sounds that way in their voices. Especially with D.O., it's pretty prominent. IDK if I explained that right but that's what I hear. Musically, they always contrast the "softer" voices of Xiumin/Suho/Lay with the "clearer" voices of Chen/Baekhyun. And of course, it's not an EXO song with an iconic line from Sehun, whether it be E-X-O, shawtyimmapartytillthesundown, thatsrightmytype, or it'sabouttogogo.
  • SNSD: I could talk a lot about this but I'm just gonna link this instead: every SNSD title track at 1:40, basically the key here is that Sunny is ALWAYS singing at 1:40. Which is ironic because Jessica sings the least at 1:40 and that's her/SNSD's iconic IGAB line haha. But besides that, Taengsic harmonies in earlier songs/TTS front(wo)manning the vocals around 2013/2014, Hyoyeon getting a rap verse, and Tiffany always getting the iconic English lines (HEREEE COMES TROUBBLEEEE, WE BRING THE BOYS OUT, DJ PUT IT BACK ON, HEY GIRLS DO YOU KNOW WHAT TIME IT IS?, HEY CHA CHA CHA CHECK IT LET IT GO!, LISTEN BOY MY FIRST LOVE STORY!, you get the idea).
48
caphad•

Yep. You hit it right on the nail for EXO. It's very interesting how SM does the contrasts with the guys voices like you said which completely shifts the tone of the song. It's brilliant. The sheer variety in their singing voices is one of the things I like a lot about exo songs.

Of course there's D.O. whose voice isn't completely clear or soft helps make the song sound smoother/more chill (dunno if this describes it right) with his ad-libs and runs.

12
griffbendorIt's 11:11 I'm Genie for your Wonderland•

Yep, totally agree, I love all the different voices in EXO! Although some of them sound really similar, in the end it's the way they use their voices/make different colors that makes EXO's music so much fun! My one complaint is that they never get to really use their lower/middle ranges in a lot of their songs.

And I think with D.O. it's the fact that he sings what he's comfortable with and usually sings pretty calmly. He knows what works for him and doesn't try to really push or pressurize his voice, so he has a very smooth tone overall. It really is ideal R&B tone and it's really nice, he could definitely do that or jazz-style music, I would love to see him try doing a blues-style song or Frank Sinatra cover sometime!

6
wecoytef(RV + MAMAMOO)•

You see I usually hear Wendy and Joy more in their group singing/backing vocals lol (though it totally changes based on the song)

RV have such a great ensemble blend that it's pretty hard to pick out individual voices though.

2
griffbendorIt's 11:11 I'm Genie for your Wonderland•

Haha, I'm biased so I usually listen for the Wendy/Seulgi harmonies the most out of any of them, but you're right in that Joy/Wendy do harmonies together too! It does depend on the song, they do a lot of different combos but since I like Wendy/Seulgi's harmonies the most those are the ones I listen for!

Definitely agree it's hard to pick out their voices though, Wendy and Seulgi I can pick apart but Irene/Joy/Yeri I have trouble with since they can sound similar to each other at times. I think what helped me was listening to them harmonize/sing acapella to Stick With U really helped me learn to recognize them in harmonies.

2
satanspebble•

For Monsta X, there's always something really punchy and deep even in their relatively softer songs (like In Time from their latest album, or All In). I know many people feel like their song style isn't suited for the korean audience because of how heavy it is but personally i love how their songs manage to balance the beautiful vocals (like Kihyun's voice) with the rap of Jooheon and Changkyun (which are super distinct) and i just overall love that they have a weird way of marrying the hard punky music with wonderful singing!

edit: don't forget jooheon always shouting his name in a song

25
theninetyninerthe biggest hit•

before i even actually got into monsta x (i downloaded their albums and listened to their songs, before actually watching their MVs and learning about them), jooheon was my favourite member, because he would always say his name before his rap, and i memorised him quickly :D

3
satanspebble•

everyone loves jooheon! i like how he sounds so incredibly badass when he raps but is actually a soft, scaredy cat in real life

4
mylord420Don't Lose Your Temper So So So Quickly •

Dreamcatcher - FOOKIN' METAL

AOA - Hey. Brave Sound. Hey.

T-ARA - the best dance moosik ever

Kara - the 2nd best dance moosik ever

Wonder Girls - Retro Queens

Mamamoo - good vocals, every voice stands out. Its very easy to identify their voices, especially Hwasa.

Gfriend - hard to explain, but you know a Gfriend song when you hear it. Also the guitar solo in every song.

23
MeepsNcheeseSuper Junior|SNSD|KARD|BgA|Conan Oppa•

I feel like how I recognize a Gfriend song is that nearly eeeeverything's keyed way up there from their vocals to their instrumentals. Not a gripe or anything, but notably up there LOL

5
conkertin•

There's a pretty funny BTS joke I've seen being thrown around about their song format that, while not accurate in any way, sounds like it is at first.

Jungkook first verse, RapMon rap long as fuck, Suga rap verse, Jungkook chorus, Jungkook verse, J-Hope verse, Tae and Jin say half a word, Jimin screams, Jungkook verse

THE END

To be honest though, I can't really think of any songs of theirs that actually follows this. It just feels so real for some reason.

BTS changed it up a lot recently before it got too old, but there are a lot of tropes in their older songs, some of which that stayed. Jimin screaming, Suga talking about Daegu (it got to the point that even he made a line about it....in a verse about Daegu), V growling, Suga banning the song from broadcast, Jin slow bridge, Jungkook taking up most of the song, and lots of background ad-libs.

Sometimes, I miss some of them. I especially hope Suga's love for Daegu comes back. It's been a whole year since his last mention of Daegu in music, with 8 on his mixtape. Throwback to his BigHit Audition Rap Battle when he made 8 Daegu related lines/random shout-outs in less than one minute, ten seconds total (there was a break for his rival rapper to rap). Someone compiled a bunch of Suga Daegus and it's long enough to be a song.

23
tinaoe•

Suga banning the song from broadcast

gold.

I'm actually curious if the Daegu love will ever return, I'm like 60% sure I read somewhere that in the end, it was more BangPDnim's suggestion than Yoongi wanting to rap about his hometown again lmao.

5
conkertin•

Are you saying that Hitman Bang suggested him to do it or suggested him to stop doing it?

1
tinaoe•

I think he suggested the topic or suggested that he'd talk about Deagu again. I can't for the love of me remember where I read that, I'll see if I can find it.

1
asddsalkjjkl•

I thought of their LaLaLas

4
kKunoichiSURISURI ♠•

TVXQ's classic sound was this SM-specific genre called SMP with almost orchestra-like inst mixed with rock and intensity lol coupled with powerful choreo prime examples are Rising Sun, Keep Your Head Down and Catch Me. I mean their main style's pretty much changed up a lot recently but their albums will always have these sorts of songs without fail.

18
vlayse•

VIXX title tracks I'd usually recognize from the members voice, since they have tried a lot of different things for their titles. N and Ken are the easier to recognize for me, with N's being this soft honey-like voice and Ken's a really powerful voice that is just easy to identify i think. But leaving their title tracks aside i think VIXX music style shines in their B-sides, in them you can actually notice their "style" in sound.

14
anisopterasaurusCha Hakyeon leg soup•

Honestly, Leo is what does it for me. But each of them sounds so different and unique, but if I am listening to a song and don't know what it is (rare - these are my baes), when I hear Leo I know it's Vixx

8
salarygirlIts B.A.P, Yes Sir! r/BAP | r/SHINee | VIXX•

Please...please explain your flair. The Chabooty gives me all sorts of feels.

6
anisopterasaurusCha Hakyeon leg soup•

instead of frog leg soup, i think Hakyeon leg soup would be delicious. i love food, and i love Cha Hakyeon, so best of both worlds? ;)

2
bluemysteric•

f(x) are the queens of "experimental pop" — that is, pop music that has some interesting mixes of genres (now it's less experimental I would say but who knows; they may surprise us). They also are known for "quirks" in their songs: high-pitched sounds or odd-for-the-song intonations. They also used to be associated with frequent "nanana"s but not sure if that's still well-known now lol.

Some of Pristin and LOONA's music reminds me of f(x) in terms of intonation and interesting genre mixes (especially "Loonatic" by Odd Eye Circle like wow that is an f(x)-as-fuck track if you ask me holy shit). It's great that Pristin covered "Rum Pum Pum Pum" once so I assume they're influenced by them.

13
AndasuT-ara Mamamoo GFriend Seventeen•

EXID - all their songs sound like hoe anthems EXID have a very distinct sound that nobody else can really pull off. They have a very bassy, sexual yet not overly sexual, sound that they've really made their own with Actual God of Kpop Shinsadong Tiger.

Seventeen - Aside from having an incredibly cheerful sound, one thing I've noticed about a lot of Seventeen's title tracks is they like to use backing tracks that for the most part sound like they were made with real instruments (even though they're not). DK, Seungkwan and Hoshi's vocals really help set the tone of the song and give the others something to bounce off.

12
PM_ME_HOONY_PIC•

Recently, their song's title are two words - repeated. Joke aside they like to do different style of music so it's kinda difficult to choose what would be their characteristic sounds. But I must say that since Taehyun left, they always use the same order when they sing. I guess it's something.

10
gills__행복하자~•

For WINNER, I think there's this quality to their voices where everything they produce sounds very sophisticated. Plus, a lot of contrast because of their distinct vocal timbres. Also, no awkward rapping.

8
unitzero13T-ara•

Classic T-ara has a very distinctive heavy electronic beat driven sound, their songs go hard and are energetic club anthems also I think Soyeon's voice is unmistakeable (and sorely missed). Almost forgot also REALLY shitty english verses lol.

9
mylord420Don't Lose Your Temper So So So Quickly •

I likely likey dis I likely likey dat. i like dis like dat YEAH.

Fucking snake

6
killswitchXengageDelulu Cube Stan•

Beast - its about heartbreak

9
fduniho•

There is a singer in AOA with a very distinctive voice. If I hear her, I know it's AOA. Wonder Girls has had a rapper with a style and voice I would recognize. I think I can also recognize some singers from SNSD, f(x), Kara, and After School. If I hear Raina from After School, and the sound is jumpier and poppier with only two other girls singing, then it's probably Orange Caramel.

8
_schistykidexo|rv|snsd|shinee|bts|gfriend|bigbang|twice|suju•

i think it's jimin from aoa. her voice is really distinct in their girly girl singles.

5
fduniho•

I think you're right. I found a video of hers. The voice was the same, and she looked like the same singer. She has a voice that works best as a spice. It's appealing when she is with a group of other girls who have more regular singing voices, but her voice isn't as appealing when she has to carry the whole song. I feel sort of the same way about Jessica from SNSD, but not to the same extent. I loved how Jessica added her distinct and easily recognizable voice to SNSD songs, but compared to Jimin, her voice sounds more regular.

4
fduniho•

I guess I would call her voice a signature voice. It's normal to write a signature in a distinct cursive, but not a whole document.

3
DJJohnnymeisterstan WJSN and Lovelyz | /r/ Eunseo Owner•

Lovelyz and OnePiece retro synths

but they are not working with OnePiece for this comeback, so we'll see how this goes

8
Sirah81VIXX | MAMAMOO•

A always think that Suju's choruses sound a bit auto-tuned even when they are not overly so, but it often comes to Siwon's nasally voice, Ryeowook's melodic voice and mid-range members like Leeteuk, Eunhyuk or Sungmin merging.

1