What are your thoughts on sandbagging in martial arts?
I came across this video and it got me thinking about the whole concept of sandbagging.
If you aren't in the know, sandbagging is a term for competitive arts where someone will compete in a skill division lower than their actual skill level. So for example, a guy who is tapping and fighting on par with purple belts in a BJJ gym will be go to competitions and enter as a blue belt. Since he is for all intents and purposes a purple belt going up against lower ranked people, he should in theory have the edge.
The video in question makes the argument that "everyone is doing it!" and it is a part of the game. That leads to some weird ideas for me.
I have been up against sandbaggers and god it sucks. Like they are just better than everyone in their division and getting stomped out by them is just a hard pill to swallow. I hated it.
But, if like the video asserts, everyone is doing it, then it wouldn't have much purpose as any sandbagger bluebelts going to white will just be fighting other blue belts so it sort of evens out I guess.
And another unintended consequence that could be good or bad, depending on your viewpoints, is it would raise the level of competency of belts to a greater degree. This artificial selection would result in better upper belts than in the past. The bluebelts of now could be comparable to purple and brown belts of the past. Thus, the competition selects for and develops even better competitors.
Personally, regardless of a slight academic interest in this odd case of artificial selection, I would still say sandbagging is a dick move, so if you are a coach, don't do it. Don't crush those little whitebelts hopes and dreams with your wrecking ball of medal hunting.
What are your thoughts on sandbagging and its prevelance in martial arts with competitive aspect? Has it happened to you? Were you the bagger or baggee?
Also, doesn't need to just be in BJJ either. If you have feeling about sandbagging in karate or whatever feel free to air any grievances. I'm interested to hear thoughts.
Posted Nov 13, 2017, 11:53 AM UTC