The end of match commendations screen is positively reinforcing bad players.
There should be cutoff stats that disqualify you for commendation at the end of the game.
Personal most recent example, I don't care that our Zagara captured a whooping 5 camps in 20 minutes on warhead junctions when they died 9 times for it, twice as much as other teammates. They spent the whole game ineffectively trying to split push and had barely more hero damage than my Stukov, all probably done in early laning and then trying to fend for themselves when they got inevitably and repeatedly ganked. They didn't care about defending lanes or objective, just a mindless drone. Yet at the end of the game, they get a medal that encourages their behavior. That's not normal.
Dying a lot and causing your team to lose is a classic but I'm sure everyone can think of others. Top hero damage yet barely any takedowns because it was just useless poking without the team's support or with plenty of death because it was repeated suicide missions. Top damage taken but the death count to go with it. Top xp/siege but no takedowns/hero damage because they just played their own game while the team was getting slaughtered trying to actually win.
I wish that not only did these player get no commendation at the end of the game, but that they got a notice that some stats probably cost them the match. Positive feedback is good but negative feedback is what makes you improve. The number one advice from pros isn't "watch your replays" for nothing. The game also needs to tell player "you lost because you died too much" and "you lost because you were too individualistic".
Posted Nov 13, 2017, 1:55 PM UTC
The biggest issue with attempting to weed out the "bad behavior awards" is that there are a whole lot of heroes who do a whole lot of different things. Trying to adjust the sensitivity of the system to account for who's supposed to be good at what would be crazy annoying. I remember early in the MVP system, Abathurs got MVP nearly every game, because the system was very sensitive to death count. They made an exception for Abathur, his lack of deaths isn't as valuable as a Kael'thas's 0 deaths. But to get a really fair evaluation of a player's performance based on their hero, you'd be making a TON of these exceptions, and making a lot of assumptions as well. Sylvanas and Junkrat aren't very good at securing kills, but they put out a ton of damage. So you'd have to make an exception for them. Melee assassins don't necessarily put out persistent damage, but they're usually better at securing kills. There's another exception. Samuro excels at taking merc camps, but he's an assassin, and may not be in every teamfight to keep map control strong. So there's your first problem, differing roles across heroes/classes.
What about the enemy team? We're kinda in a double support/warrior meta depending on the league. So let's take my first example, Sylvanas and Junkrat. If they're on 1 team, and they're playing against a Lucio and a Brightwing, that's a ton of damage just getting soaked up by massive AOE heals. Even worse if BW and Lucio have a tank who can heal themselves. So they pad their stats but the damage doesn't have a tangible effect. Do you adjust the MVP system to reflect the OTHER team as well? How about their allies? Azmodan might not be able to go off and split push/soak if the team has only one other DPS, so maybe he has to be in every teamfight. Do you penalize his relative lack of siege damage and xp earned?
Even within heroes, you can choose talents for more or less burst damage or sustained damage. And while reworks are infrequent, that can impact the stats a hero is likely to get as well. Another hero could get a Bribe talent, or has it removed, or it could become baseline. It would be difficult, bordering on ridiculous, to have blizzard code in every exception and scenario for what ultimately is a bonus, meaningless little ceremony at the end of each game.
I think the point is fairly clear, but the bigger issue I think is that ultimately, it's a semi-arbitrary system. The MVP awards (or even non MVP awards) that matter are the ones where you get a handful of votes from allies and sometimes enemies.
the system is just trash for these exact reasons, just have an honour system for good behaviour and support
I don't think it's a bad thing that even bad players get commended occasionally. It feels good and it's not like people are so delusional most of the time that they think they're playing amazingly.
Oh give me a break... It only makes their inner Dunning-Kruger stronger and it encourages them to play that same wrong and useless play style the next game.
The problem here is that the system was designed to make people feel good, not to help them play better
i see a LOT of specialists players AFKing in a lane while the team strugles with objectives ... its one thing to not go for a volskaya, it's a complete different thing when a specialist fails to defend boss in warhead junction.
if the game would tell the player ... hey your team lost because of you DUMBASS, instead of giving them a little pat in the shoulder "hey pall, you did great. You where top SIEGE dmg in your team ... good work!!!"
maybe those retards would engage in team fights over major objectives.
The system can't tell who's to blame for your team's loss because there are many factors that lead to it, some of which might actually involve mistakes that you have made at some points during the match but that you have brushed off as "not that big of a deal".
For instance, let's say you initiate a 4v5 fight for some reason. You miss a stun, your tank fails to block an enemy projectile and your main DPS focuses the wrong target. You lose the fight, you look around the map for a scapegoat and here is mr. specialist at top, solo-pushing his lane. Why is his mistake worse than the ones that were made before and during the teamfight?
It's much better to give players a pat on the back for doing something right than to punish them for making mistakes, because the number of mistakes that are being made by all the players during a match is pretty high anyway.
Nah, I think the system is fine the way it is. If someone can't really self-reflect on their own play and think they did really well when they sucked, just because of a stupid stat, they're helpless. Just ignore them and move on.
Then again I mostly play QM so who cares.
D.Va had the same thing, and they also made an exception for her.
I agree that it's complicated to evaluate positive and negative impact across all heroes and playstyles, but disagree on two things.
One is that it's a "meaningless little ceremony". No, I really think that players that see themselves at the end, regardless of if they get votes, think they did a good job. That players on the winning team think they won because of their effort and players of the losing team think they lost despite their efforts. In fact it's a double reinforcement for players like the Zagara I describe: not only are they reinforced in the idea that their strategy was good, they are also reinforced in the idea that the strategy of the rest of the team was bad and shouldn't be reproduced.
The second disagreement I have is that even if it's complicated to judge positive and negative impact, there are stats that aren't complicated at all and should disqualify and death count relative to teammates is one of them. No exceptions. That's a very easy rule to put in place. "You lost and you have more than 0,25 death/min (5 deaths for a 20mn game) and more than 50% more death than the median player in your team? Your playstyle and subsequent deaths almost certainly had a more negative impact on your chances than positive, regardless of your other stats, so you are disqualified for commendation."
Ultimately this may just be an issue of who you're playing with and/or against. I know that when I play Sylvanas or Dehaka, I'm far more likely to get MVP, based entirely on the amount of siege dmg, xp, and camps I can capture. And of course, I can avoid dying too much. So there are always going to be players who overestimate the importance and relevance of Hero or Siege damage.
As for the Zagara example, I have to agree with you. There's no good way around that. And yet, sometimes the entire team agrees that Zagara or Samuro or Azmodan should be split pushing most if not all of the game, and it ends up working or not working anyway. But to the kind of MVP algorithm you suggest, that might look like someone who isn't a team player. But you're right in that it's doubly reinforcing. I don't think that the MVP screen is the answer to changing this behavior, however. The system almost certainly can't be good enough to adequately push players in the right direction based on their performance. It's going to fall to in-game teammates, the player's individual desire to improve, and general aptitude for change that are going to change the behavior. Not a little award at the end of a game (or lack thereof).
On the 2nd disagreement, I think you're generally correct that there are some unambiguous stats. However, depending on the league and situation, they aren't. I play mostly tanks, and it's my goal to die more than my allies. I'll occasionally be forced to sacrifice myself to ensure that my allies escape freely. That may result in me having 5 deaths in 20 minutes, while all of my allies have 1 or 2. This isn't an unambiguous statistic. What about heroes with a death mechanic? It's not common to do so, but Uther, Diablo, Tyrael, ETC (Mosh Pit on death) and Junkrat DO have the ability to impact change by dying. I know I'm getting to a point of stretching here, but if an ETC uses the entirety of a mosh pit, dies, and gets another free one, that's substantial. Point being, no statistic is entirely unambigious unless it's a massive outlier (think Leoric near release when he would just stand near buildings to siege and die repatedly, taking keeps but dying 30 times).
I think they're moving in the right direction, at least in some situations for some unusual statistics. Muradin, for example has that new baseline quest where he gets rewarded for heroes dying within 2.5 seconds of being stunned by his Q. This is a mechanic I've been clamoring about for a long time. I've called it the "alley-oop" award. It's an exceptionally important part of tanking and play-making. And as a tank player, it's annoying as hell to rarely be recognized for that contribution. Don't get me started on body-blocking. Is the MVP award system going to take into account the amount of time spent physically in the way of other heroes? At least with alley-oops, you have a fairly concise (if roughly defined) metric for success. Kill within x time of stun. Playing Arthas means I get an award nearly every game for roots, but not all or even most of those roots were useful.
My point overall: You're right. The MVP system reinforces bad behavior. However, I don't think trying to account for every subtle technique or relative statistic to make the system adept at accurately naming the MVP is the way to move forward. If I were to offer a solution, I would suggest doing away entirely with the algorithm-decided "titles" and singular MVP. Just leave it to the players. Display all ten heroes for 5 seconds and let the players decide who deserved MVP, maybe a top 3 rather than 5. Maybe we tanks, with our generally low stats, will get a little more love that way, and this Zagara player and her merc camps will be motivated to try something else.
Well they're already going to be looking at a bunch of stats in the new MMR system based on machine learning. How about they change the MVP screen to reflect those results? Just include the players that played the best per the machine learning algorithm, and display the stats that affected it.
That's a really interesting idea. I haven't heard any details of this new system, but I've been watching videos about machine learning/neural networks and stuff recently. If it's at all like that, it could be a fascinating look at how a machine would decide the MVP.
Especially new/bad players. They don't understand that being on the end screen doesn't mean a thing.
im glad this kind of discussion is getting some traction. its also the route cause of a lot of the frustration with quick match with respect to team comp and matchmaking 'rules'. theres no way you can implement a system that can fairly weigh up 100+ different heroes with different kits. and i think that honestly attempting to do so is a excerise in futility. make the MVP award purely down to votes, trash the rest seems like the only solution.
I agree entirely. On a small scale it could be ok, but considering the issues they've had in deciding how to match certain heroes just in matchmaking [looking at you, tyrande vs. tassadar/abathur], i can't imagine they'd be able to adequately balance a generally correct algorithm for determining an MVP. Just let the players decide. They might be wrong a lot of the time, but more importantly, it would matter to us, it means more to me that an ally commended me on my play than the computer calculating that I did the most damage and died the least.
Its definitely so much more meaningful when someone says hey, brightwing may not have been mvp, but their play kept our team together and won teamfights, or noting a good initiator and so on, with votes for that player. Mvp seems like a really weird algorithm sometimes, and player votes are much better.
It's almost as if they've spent a bunch of time building a machine learning system so they can figure out what each hero needs to do well and apply it to your MMR...
No reason they couldn't apply the same algorithm to MVP and simply provide awards based on what they claim is their actual performance.
This right here is precisely why I think performance-based MMR is a bad idea - there are far too many variables in hots for some algorithm to accurately assess how well a player does within a given match. I’ll even add another - how can the game possibly account for good or bad body-blocking?
Actually Blizzard can do this. At Blizzcon they showed that future MMR will be based on individual performance, with the parameters of what stats qualify as excellent tailored to each individual hero.
Or even worse. When the last guy in your HL picks Nova on Braxxis for no reason, proceeds to do nothing arguably useful for the map, gets the most kills (due to rotations) and winds up as MVP because of it. This idiot is now walking away with a glowing feeling because "Nova good hero" with this MVP award when me, playing my balls off as goddamn solo tank Zayra gets nothing.
It would be interesting to hear your definition of "no reason" here.
My comp was Alarak, Zayra, Malf, Valla, that pick order.
The scary thing is the upcoming performance-based MMR adjustments are more than likely based on the existing MVP system. They implemented the MVP system a while back with 0 tangible rewards or effects to collect data and tweak it, and now they are going to start adjusting MMR based on those approximately 20 stats they track.
They confirmed it will be based on a different system.
Multiple times.
That's... concerning. Incoming every 3rd GM player is a Sylvanas main.
Dunce cap. "Worst drafter." There's no upvote button for them, just a downvote button. Pick a real hero.
Ouch. I won't entirely disagree with you on JR, he could use some work in the W and E department, but Sylvanas has pretty much always had a solid place in the draft.
Does she, though? The consensus amongst most high level streamers is that she's trash. She has a 1% involvement in pro play (because she's for cheese and nothing else). She's not terrible, but she's not a real hero like Greymane is a real hero, if you know what I mean.
People are going to downvote my post because "I'm the best sylv nyerrrrrh," but a bunch of heroes on the roster bring nothing that some other hero doesn't bring and then some. There's never a time when I look at a draft and think "This draft could really use Sylvanas." Sylvanas just happens in some drafts and you live with it.
Junkrat is undertuned for his mostly pointless but fun design. The 'flying through the air' version of Gazlowe.
Don't know where you're getting your stats, but according to this site, she doesn't have anywhere near your 1% pick rate in pro play (19% popularity).
https://masterleague.net/hero/sylvanas/
Regardless, I guess I know what you're saying about greymane? It seems a bit unnecessarily black and white. I don't know if you just don't play her or if you have something against her, but there are definitely maps and matchups where she's a useful pick. I'm not going to pretend she's as strong as she's been in the past, but she's perfectly viable. Maybe Azmodan's lane pressure and Zagara's global presence makes them better overall than her? I don't know what you're trying to say exactly.
Sure, heroes like Malthael or Lucio are basically a straight upgrade from heroes like Illidan and Brightwing, respectively. There are some that just aren't good enough otherwise to justify their gimmick (D.va, Gazlowe). Won't disagree that there are better choices for those.
I dont see how effective pushing, silence, and damage is useless in comps. She's not for every game but she's certainly not trash
The number of people playing at pro levels are so small that it isn't really relevant to be honest. If your mission is to go pro, okay sure, but you can be successful at all the way up to masters with heroes deemed "unplayable"
She's got a strong map niche, but falls into that same category as "Pick TLV on Garden, and not anywhere else". They may have to rework her to buff her - the issue is she makes it a good bit harder to win objectives, but if you DO win one of the pushing-objectives she multiplies their power ludicrously. "Win more" hero - gotta win a little despite a handicap but then you win more, hard.
That said there is room for that style - if you see the enemy picking a late-game comp, and you're on Mines or either of the Diablo maps, you can take Sylvanus, win the first teamfight and push to an insurmountable advantage off it. It's just a bit too narrow a niche (certain maps, against late-game comps, with a comp willing to go for early game advantage).
Junkrat isn’t undertuned. He’s a relatively high skill solo lane bully. People just play him wrong.
And the consensus among “high level streamers” is pretty transparent. You are referring to chu8.