To what extent can/should we consider thinkers like Warren "mutualist"?

So, alot of American writers pre Liberty had ideas that many of us generally think of as part of the mutualist cannon (Warren, Spooner etc). Now, I'm pretty sure most of them weren't actually aware of Proudhon, or at least didn't exactly hold mutuality at the center of their philosophy. On the other hand, you could argue that, even if these writers didn't prioritise this principle, they described arrangements that more or less operated according to it.

Should we, then, retroactively treat these writers are "mutualism", or simply some other variety of market anarchism?

Posted Nov 15, 2017, 2:37 PM UTC

39
Vaglame•

I'm not familiar with him, any reading you recommend?

2
DaedChannelOP•

He's a pretty important influence for Tucker, who cites him as one of the three independent originators of socialism in State Socialism and Anarchism (Proudhon, Marx, Warren). I'm really only familiar with him second hand (from Tucker, whose interpretations of thinkers are, more often than not, one half his own ideas. Also some peeps online). I know True Civilization is important to Tucker though, or at least it was listed in Liberty as one of the books you could order from him by mail.

2
Vaglame•

Thanks! I'll give it a read

1

Benjamin Tucker is another of those from the individualist anarchism tradition. I know for sure he was influenced by Proudhon.

Does this question really matter? If philosophies such as mutualism and the individualist anarchists cannot work in solidarity, neither will ever go anywhere. I really like what they're doing at the C4SS think tank in creating an umbrella of "left market libertarians." This umbrella describes the many anti-capitalist anarchists who still tolerate the use of money, and certainly includes Proudhon, Warren, Spooner and Tucker.

2
humanispherian•

The problem with these eclectic mixes of elements is that they seldom penetrate very deep in their analysis. If you're organizing around the senses in which Proudhon, Warren, Spooner and Tucker are looking at the world in the same way or proposing the same solutions, well, there just isn't much there. And maybe you would be better off either pursuing the insights of one of the analyses, producing a real synthesis after exploring more than one in depth, or just working from whatever basic ideas attracted you to this very disparate group of thinkers in the first place.

1
humanispherian•

When you're asking these sorts of questions, you have to decide whether you are talking about one or more of the specific things that have been called "mutualism" or whether you are talking about the common denominators in the evolving tradition. There is a traceable evolution from the various pre-1840 mutualisms through the present, which even presents some converging lines of development. Warren was rather far from Proudhon in most respects, but rather close to the author of "The Mutualist, or, Practical Remarks on the Social System of Mutual Cooperation (1826.) Quite a variety of "mutualist" material, including some by Proudhon, appears together in The Spirit of the Age in 1849-50, although you would be challenged to make a single ideology from the pieces. (Proudhon would have been known to almost all the New England radicals, though not in any great depth, and William Batchelder Greene was discussing Proudhon's work in print in that same 1849-50 period.) But then, of course, Tucker went ahead and pulled the various threads together by the 1880s.

So Warren was an influence on what Tucker thought of as "mutualism," while repudiating what he knew of Proudhon's thought. It's probably accurate to say that the definition of "mutualism" as we understand it now was largely the work of opponents and innovators, after Proudhon's death, and that the idea largely functioned as a kind of conceptual foil for anarchism, once the "modern anarchist" movement emerged in the late 1870s. While the reference to Proudhon was retained, it was at least as important to figures on various sides of the question that mutualism was non- or anti-communist and emphasized practical reform, rather than revolutionary means.

EDIT: In a more modern sense, since everything passed historically through Tucker's synthesis, the present influence of Warren is not necessarily what you would expect. Kevin Carson and I had an exchange a few years back in which he seemed to reject Warren's cost principle pretty completely, while I consider Warren's work to have added some interesting tools to our toolkit, despite rejecting some of the more extreme aspects of his individualism.

1
Waterfall67a•

"Uniformity of thought and motion, cannot be produced by any circumstance or combination of circumstances, because we all act or think in a peculiar way under the very same events. Political or social equality is very different from this abstract absolute equality, and qualified by liberty of action, allowing of gradations of skill, talents, capacities, comfort, &c. The inference is plain, we ought not to contend for absolute equality; but admit the law of nature, diversity, for a practical principle, wherefrom is derived the right of social equality in proportion to our powers and abilities to become useful to each other."

Like this.

1
humanispherian•

This is actually very much in line with most of the anarchistic radicals of his generation. But Warren was much less aware of their ideas in most cases than he was of the comparatively naive communists and communitarians around him, so his defenses of diversity sometimes seem a little needlessly defensive.

2
DyingStarsForever•

I mean, does it matter? Like it says in the sidebar "Mutualism is not a specific social, political or economic system" so there's a huge range of people that fits into the description of what a mutualist is, and I definitely can see Warren in there even if he didn't use the term.

Also, we usually don't have a problem with applying the term "anarchist" retroactively and there the issue is much the same. Take Stirner for example, most people treat him as anarchist, but it's possible that he wasn't even aware of the term. But considering what he stood for, does it matter?

0