NYA Signatories (Coinbase) Need to Be Held Accountable after Segwit2X "Disaster"

---------EDIT----------

Heard back from Coinbase today 11/30/17 with below response. Not sure if they are completely blowing this off or just stating that they are delayed in responding.

This is an automated response.

We regret not being able to answer your email support ticket.

Please do not respond to this email, as our team is working through an unprecedented backlog of support requests.

You can chat live with our automated customer support rep, Ada, here: https://coinbase.ada.support/chat/ – Ada can help answer basic questions, keep you up-to-date with current site issues, and assist with website navigation. Ada is always learning and improving!

Thanks for your understanding, and please accept our apologies as we thank you for your patience with us as we grow with the digital currency community.

Regards,

Kyle The Coinbase Team --------/END EDIT-------

I am permanent lurker but created an account today, there are too many price threads and while it is good to be rising we can't let the signatories of the NYA off the hook.

What happened to the Segwit2X fork is a complete disaster of Titanic proportions. While most of us knew it was not the right approach I don't think too many could foresee a dead fork attempt on day 1. Had there actually been enough community support this would have damaged Bitcoin (and probably alts) irreparably for many years. These companies tried to steer the entire ecosystem into a brick wall. It was completely short-sighted and they would have taken their whole companies down with them. Now they are allowed to remain in business only because of the core developers and outspoken community, they should be thanking us with every ounce of their existence.

I chose to call out Coinbase because that is the only people I do business with. I emailed them before the fork warning them about Segwit2X not being acceptable, and they ended up deciding to split the symbol so maybe our e-mails do work. This morning I took the time to e-mail Coinbase again. I suggest that if you do business with any of the other signatories that you find alternatives until they come out to either competently defend their position in a transparent way and/or address how they will actually support the community in a meaningful way going forward. Hijacking Bitcoin with no long term goals, dropping core dev support, and dividing the community should not be something that is easily forgotten.

---MY EMAIL - Feel Free to Customize---- Due to Coinbase commitment to the NYA and Segwit2X movement I will no longer be using Coinbase for my Bitcoin and Litecoin purchases. The fork was contentious to begin with, and then ended up being so buggy that it never even triggered properly rendering it DOA. Had the Bitcoin community followed the desires of the Segwit2X movement (that Coinbase owners have supported fully) there would have been downtime and possibly network failure, damaging Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies for possibly years to come.

This was a terrible oversight of Bitcoin's principles to maintain an open and trusted development path with competent developers while needing user and network support, and to proceed with only needed upgrades that are healthy for the network. Based off of how the Segwit2X upgrade happened (or didn't for that matter), Coinbase completely undermined everything that makes Bitcoin strong in order for a temporary fix on a vastly complicated scaling problem.

The supposed network congestion we are experiencing now is nothing that would have happened had the Bitcoin community decided to trust Coinbase's lead in the NY Agreement. Thankfully the community including users and core developers had greater foresight than Coinbase and all of the signatories of the NYA.

Until Coinbase comes out with a public apology and increased commitment to "healthy" development and network functions of Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies, I will not be using you for my purchases. The Segwit2X upgrade was contentious and TOXIC to begin with, and had the core developers and users of Bitcoin not been so concerned with the health of Bitcoin in the long run the upgrade would have been catastrophic and may have permanently destroyed Bitcoin.

Thank you,

-----END EMAIL-----

If we do not punish these companies then something equally as disastrous will happen again. Wall Street is now going to be involved with some of these companies and they aren't always known for making long term decisions. We must do this if Bitcoin and community run cryptocurrencies are to survive, they have to know who they are beholden to in this space.

Posted Nov 19, 2017, 7:24 PM UTC · edited

7825
MrRGnome•

Are we going to see one of these posts everyday? The way many people have taken so personally the politics of businessmen is crazy. I'd rather a full page of meme shitposts than this. We won. Don't direct new business to these companies, but stop with the freaking crusade already. You're going to exhaust the attention span of the community until they are unable to collectively act in their required security role the next time it is necessary. Your whining is doing real damage. Stop it.

1†
MotherSuperiour•

It would have been catastrophic if there was significant backing behind S2x. That is not an exaggeration

14
MrRGnome•

Who said it was exaggeration? The point is we won the game, take a shower and get some rest. This isn't the last game of the season.

Campaigning like this takes one of the fundamental security roles we as a community play and transforms it into an ever present angry mob. Take a breather, we'll need to raise the alarm bells again and when we do it cannot be the commonplace everyday dismissable ravings that this is becoming.

2†
MotherSuperiour•

If we all just shrug and go "Meh, we won" without expressing distaste for their actions, many fear these companies won't learn a lesson that they need to learn.

2
MrRGnome•

This is literally a campaign. Its a bit more than expressed distaste which has also been done to near death.

2
easypak-100•

the game is not won to use your terminology

they are just in a huddle and are regrouping for another push

0
hackinthebochs•

This is dumb. If the core bitcoin devs had gone forward with the fork, they wouldn't have made such an amateur mistake. There was no risk to the network. Trying to punish big players for attempting to move bitcoin out of the stalemate is also dumb. They're a part of the ecosystem just as much as anyone else. Such decisions are a fact of a decentralized community.

-9

15 people in a closed door meeting at a event in New York do not get to dictate to the rest of the ecosystem what Bitcoin is and the direction that it is going.

I'm not opposed to a hardfork that increases transaction throughput. I'm strongly opposed to a bunch of suites dictating to me what that looks like and how it works. This is against the very essence of Bitcoin and must always be resisted, regardless of the intentions.of said 15 people.

10
hackinthebochs•

Forks are a feature of blockchain, not a bug. If the big players decide to fork such that every exchange calls their fork "bitcoin", well that's the nature of a decentralized system.

Now, I'm against useless forks and uncertainty as much as anyone else. But I'm also against pointless drama. The first fork in August should have been both segwit with blocksize increase. It's the lack of compromise that drove us to the cliff. I do not blame those with their own financial interests on the line for attempting to move us out of the stalemate.

-5

The first fork in August should have been both segwit with blocksize increase.

I have great news for you! It was both Segwit and a blocksize increase!

https://blockchain.info/blocks

12
hackinthebochs•

I see a 100k difference. Not significant.

-2†
stablecoinOPredditor for 2 weeks•

The point is that the fork was still powered through specifically without core dev support and incompetent developer(s) was made the lead on the project. All the while they tried to hijack the Bitcoin brand.

If they didn't have core support they should have forked the coin into something different that they could control, like bcash.

5
samsonx•

The coding error was so trivial from a programming point of view that I suspect it either wasn't tested at all (I find that hard to believe) or it was deliberate.

I think it was deliberate.

3
blepcoinredditor for 3 months•

No I don’t think so. Jeff is an imbecile. Who thinks he’s gods gift to earth. The perfect combination for no testing of code. (“This definitely works so no need to test it”)

1
easypak-100•

you are just saying basically that you have no understanding of what is happening, not qualified to inform others

1