r/dndnext•
IndexObject

Magic items as upgradable items instead of treasure?

So long story short, is this a good idea? Giving the PCs expensive weapons that they might have to just throw away makes very little sense for the setting. I'm just wondering if anybody has tried something similar and if they are any pratfalls I should know about. I'm also wondering what level everybody in my party should be at at certain milestones as far as magical equipment goes, presuming the default challenge rating.

Posted Nov 20, 2017, 3:42 AM UTC

5342
onedollarbanana•

You want to look at what Matt Mercer has done with the Taldorei (sp?) Campaign Guide and Critical Role. He has "vestiges " that level up when you want them to.

21
chunchihu•

We've used these, and they are very good.

4
IndexObjectOP•

Is that open source work? Do you have a link?

2
onedollarbanana•

Not open source sorry but maybe you can Google some of the items I.e. Fenthris, Whisper

7
Smashman2004Tau (Human Crossbow Hunter) & DM•

*Fenthras

3
I_AM_HUMAN_00781•

Nope. It's a campaign setting you can buy. It's absolutely worth buying it though. 4 subclasses, new feats, amazing magic items, and the world of Taldorei is fantastic.

4
tribey94•

You can find most of the information regarding this specific aspect of his campaign setting on the Critical Role Wiki under "Vestiges of Divergence", as it is information obtainable from the freely available web series anyway.

I've used them, or at least my own homebrew items using the same fundamental system, and they're very popular with the players. They're a fantastic way to encourage investment and roleplaying a character, because it gives the players a directly tangible reward for engaging with the lore of the item. Keep the ways to upgrade them mysterious, but related to the lore of the item so that the player's don't feel like it's just an arbitrary decision by the DM. E.g. A weapon with lore related to a specific god might 'upgrade' when the player becomes a follower of said god. The trick here is to find a balance between letting them feel rewarded if they choose to make mechanical choices for the sake of roleplaying (e.g. with the example above, if they decide to become a paladin or cleric of said god), but don't let them feel as though they're being forced to make decisions for the sake of roleplaying (i.e. dont let them think they HAVE to multiclass to get the item's benefits).

4
imadandylionBard/DM•
1
lilgizmo838•

Get the book. It's more than worth it.

1
Smashman2004Tau (Human Crossbow Hunter) & DM•

Tal'Dorei. 😉

-1
pseudocide759Sorcererous Rival DM•

3.5 had a similar concept called legacy weapons

18
Fentwizler•

Was the the feat that let you power them up or was that the wow artifact weapon thing?

3
pseudocide759Sorcererous Rival DM•

Artifact weapon style.

1
IndexObjectOP•

I very vaguely remember that, though I don't have my 3.5 books anymore I'm sure I can find the rules to base this off of.

2
pseudocide759Sorcererous Rival DM•

Basic concept is weapons had 4-5 ranks that are unlocked based on level and attunment/quest requirements.

5
SinisterMrBlistersMischievious Bard•

Believe this is on DMs guild as well, for 5e I think.

1
herdsheep•

I do this very frequently, in several different ways.

  • If I can fish out they are the sort of player that wants something like this, I'll let a PC find a Legendary/Sentient weapon pretty early on. Usually it will be broken/sleeping/drained or something, and then over the course of the campaign it will grow stronger, gaining new abilities as it bonds with the PC.

  • A PC seems interesting it crafting, I will let them craft or upgrade a weapon that be special to them, randomly seeding in magic components I just make up, but sense I give them a loot card for "Storm Infused Diamond" they will be like "huh, I want to try to add a Storm Infused Diamond to my swords pommel" and I'll be like "oh, that's a great idea" and they will make some crafting checks, and end up with a sword that does +1d6 Lightning damage or something.

Pitfalls - don't make the weapon too good when they find it. Just give them a Sword. A normal sword. But tell them, oh, that? That's a Legendary Item.

Frequently early on I'd try to make them want to use the sword by making it a +1 or have some special property, and then keeping in balanced and making their upgrades feel meaningful was harder. But if they are the sort of player your fishing for on this, they'll bite if it just says "Longsword, 1d8, Versatile, Artificat". If they don't bite, you probably don't want to try this with that player.

The other pitfall is - don't trying to make them bite on this idea. Some people will love the idea of growing with their sword, some people will love the idea of improving their own creation... some people will love the idea of finding completely new shit that shakes up their playstyle.

These can be really awesome plothooks, but a plothooks value is only as much weight as the players put in it, so try to guide the plothooks to people that want to engage with them, and leave shiny treasure in the world for the exploration players.

16
Bluesamurai33DM•

This is what I do. My PCs are running mini quests that are working towards a common goal for a Goddess and when they complete them, she upgrades the equipment they choose.

Sometimes they pick a nonmagic item to become magical for a wider range of magical tools, and sometimes they choose the same one multiple times for it to creep up that rarity table with special conditions, like 1/day spells or a few charges for special features.

You could also look into the 3.5 books "Weapons of Legacy" for inspiration on evolving weapons. The big thing with them is that you have to complete challenges to unlock the next upgrade of the weapon.

Find some 4e magic items guides. Say what you will about 4e, but it had some good ideas (and some poor implementation, but that's a completely separate topic) and almost every magic item had a magical progression table for a +1 to damage or a daily effect to tack on as it was upgraded.

Last bit of advice, look at the Tal'Dorei Campaign Guide from Matthew Mercer. In it, he has a few example Vestiges, which are weapons/armor based on Weapons of Legacy and dear goodness don't give more than one to a single player hahaha.

5
The_ChirurgeonOld One•

Towards the end of 3.5 I'd considered awarding 'item xp' and the players can level their gear at their discretion. Basically, 1gp of item value is 1xp. Work out the value of the magic items you'd otherwise be handing out as the amount awarded.

2
Bonerin0Wizard•

My DM gives each player a legacy item, and we all love it! I highly recommend this, which contains some legacy weapons, and we also use it as a template to create other items: http://www.drivethrurpg.com/product/172549/Weapons-of-Legacy

2
XepphyFuck this room in particular•

Gave my barbarian rogue that skyrim sword that becomes more powerful the more friends you kill. Reflavoured it to become stronger for each enemy killed from a surprise attack. Went from regular weapon to +1, then to get another +1 to enemies who haven't detected you at the beginning of combat and then to give advantage to those same enemies.

Also gave the paladin a sword that became stronger the more evil enemies slayed. He could share part of the exp with the sword to make it become stronger (IIRC it required 1000, 3000 and 6000 exp, for a total of 10000) to level. Gave +1, +2 and +3 against fiends, and could use his action to use the sword to shine and blind fiends. Campaign wasn't fiend-focused, so it wasn't horribly overpowered.

2
Elduin_Holafina•

That seems like a great idea. I may steal it!

1
global_tornado•

It can be a little boring as PCs will just map out their characters and feel entitled to receive a magic weapon that fits whatever feats they chose.

1
WadeisDead•

As a DM, what is the point of giving out weapons to players who are specifically choosing to fight in a certain playstyle? Like if I took Polearm master and I was the only character in the party that used heavy weapons, what is the point of dropping a magic Greatsword?

Sure, you can say that it was always a magic greatsword when you made the campaign, but does that make it more fun for anyone at the party? No. It's just lazy DMing. Is the player being entitled? Sure, but it is a reward that you are choosing to give to him. Why not make it what he wants?

6
DudesMcCool•

I completely agree! Random loot tables can be fun if you're looking to spice up a side mission with a piece of treasure that might make the party think a little differently, but for major rewards, make it something the party actually wants!

3
Jejmaze•

I've done this once. The party came across an old, sentient statue that gave them one magic item each. The bard received a glove that gave him a slightly better shocking grasp. Later on, he was hit with a lightning bolt which caused the glove to overcharge and meld to his arm. This second stage reduced his Con but increased his Dex. It could have possibly evolved further, but the campaign ended before that happened.

1
Aaramis•

This is something that I've done since 2e, generally as one of 2 ways:

  1. the PCs find a very powerful magical item, but it's properties aren't initially obvious. Over time, perhaps through side quests, or as the PCs level, you can open up the powers to them. This allows you to control the power creep very nicely and make sure they're not too weak or too powerful for their respective level.

  2. I've also introduced them to unusual ores, or other things (such as the gemstones suggested below) that I hint would make fantastic melds with their current weapons if they can find the right smith to do it. You can then modify their current weapon ever so slightly if you wish; something like melding Baatorian green steel to their current steel longsword, which perhaps up the damage die by one (so a 1d10 sword instead of 1d8). Or a magical fire opal found in the lair of a Red Dragon that's infused with a part of his lifeforce after spending so much time in close proximity can be socketed into your Barbarian's greataxe to add flaming damage.

Stuff like that lets your group feel as though they control things a bit too, instead of just "oh hey, I found a shiny new sword. I'll throw my old one away".

1
raiderGM•

I am doing this.

It just becomes a mini-story that gives characters and players something else to think about.

Plus, it prevents treasure from being boring, because they pulled some staff nobody wants.

Here is a variant: make the magic items able to absorb magical properties of other items. It may burn an attunement slot, or it may function on charges.

For instance, the wizard in my group is carrying a Wand of the War Mage. When/If they defeat the BBEG, also carrying a Wand, her wand will absorb the power of the other wand (it will disintegrate) and become more powerful. She will have to do some stuff (Identify, perhaps) to find out what.

The milestones are both difficult and easy. Mercer and Colville both give out loot like mad. Yes, that will impact CR some, but not much. The game assumes players are gonna hit, a lot. No monster is built to be unhittable. I think the bigger issue would be with armor for already armored characters. Giving a Ring of Protection +1 to a Wizard isn't going to do much. Giving a Shield +1 to your Plate Mailed Paladin is going to be a problem in combat. YMMV.

I never played 3.5, but the knock on that game was that players literally NEEDED certain +s from magic or their characters were broken. 5e's mechanics are such that no character needs much magic.

Never give anything above a +3 unless it comes with a cost or a limit. Consider charges. Remember that adding dice can be dangerous/fun! with Crits.

The CR system is somewhat misleading anyway, so if you have to adjust it based on your group, do so.

1
khellick•

In a homebrew campaign I'm developing I have a concept similar to the vestiges of Critical Role (also majorly influenced by said vestiges) called Hallows.

One item is the sword of light. And you go through a series of three quests to gain its true form. The first is acquiring it from its previous champion. The second is a purifying ritual. The third is gaining the blessing to wield it by the weapon's maker or original owner, typically through some sort of challenge.

So essentially, give them an item connected into the lore. Then give them a pathway for them to improve or "unlock" the weapons true potential.

The other option would be doing the Dark Souls ways of doing it, where the character(s) must find and collect a number of materials used to improve the weapon and then take it to a specific smith to make the upgrade.

1
TheFalconOfAndalus•

I do this by dividing the item "level ups" into the tiers of play, I-IV. Once a PC hits level 5, their item can be boosted to Tier II - if they spend the time to activate its new properties (usually a mini-quest). For instance, a PC in my game right now has what I'm calling the Frog Ring, which currently only functions as a ring of jumping. At Tier II, he can go on a mini-quest in which he'll be forced underwater at some point, and the Tier II abilities (swim speed and water breathing) will activate. At Tier III, it gives him permanent Freedom of Movement, and at Tier IV he'll be able to True Polymorph one creature into a frog 1/day, but only one creature at a time (an ability I call Frog Princing).

Magic is relatively rare in my setting, but its rarity is made up for by versatility where it is present. This is likely one of only a couple magic items this PC will get, so I want to make sure it has some versatility that is thematically appropriate (this character has the sailor background and took the Mobile feat at first level, so the Frog Ring fits in perfectly with his concept).

1
SacredWeapon•

IMO, the best way to do crafted weapons is to craft on additional utility to a minor magic item, rather than additional damage/attacks/attack mods.

Example, I have a polearm master paladin. My DM initially allowed me to inherit the party sorcerer's old staff of defense, and craft on a speartip to fight as a hoplite (using as quarterstaff to work with polearm master, but with piercing damage for flavor).

Eventually we met a tinkerer of legendary skill, and in exchange for assisting him with a series of quests that put us in a lot of danger, he developed an adjustable mechanism attached to the staff that allowed me to slot in another one handed weapon on the end; adding an axe made it a halberd; a dagger made it a spear. It required an hour's time to tighten everything down, essentially 'attuning' to the new mechanical connection.

DM decided magic weapons would work too, allowing me to enjoy properties of both, but anything requiring attunement would consume 2 attunement slots. He was careful not to give us too many.

1
Zaorish9•

Personally I thIk it's more fun to incentivize that legend of Zelda feeling of excitement when opening a box rather "Oh yeah your thing is better now".

1
trctelles•

The youtube channel DownforgedCast made "reforged" rules. It cost 5 bucks to download, but it got some really interesting features. They "fixed" the problem with STR and DEX, making two-handed weapons do 1.5x damage when using STR (Because DEX is so strong in 5e), and made a Magic Shards system, where you can acquire these +1 to +3 shards that you can infuse into your weapons/armors/yourself, so that you can start with the weapon you plan to use for the rest of the game. Maybe you inherited your deceased father sword, and it has meaning to your character, so with this system you can just upgrade it instead of tossing it away when you find your first +1 sword.

I bought it and I think it's worth it.

1
Jervaj•

I love that in general but more so for certain character. I love it when a very powerful items progresses from scratch tied to RP.

1
linuxphoney•

I first saw this idea in EarthDawn and I loved it. In a lot of my games magic items do this. They start out as normal looking items at first and eventually develop greater powers down the road. Right now a bard in my game has a +1 weapon that can change shape to suit the wielder. Not super useful, but neat. But it does much greater damage against things from outside reality (a designation in my game world that covers a lot of demons, greater hags, etc). She's never gotten to use that feature, but she likely will tonight. I'm excited to see how it goes.

1
blahlbinoaPaladin of Torm•

I'm doing this with my players in my homebrew group. They all get personalized magic items and as they level up, the item levels with them, so I just add something that goes along with their class theme or add more power to the item gradually. I might have it where they need to quest for a certain item for it to become Artifact level, but I feel how I'm running it I can control the powerlevel of the item.

1