Magic items as upgradable items instead of treasure?
So long story short, is this a good idea? Giving the PCs expensive weapons that they might have to just throw away makes very little sense for the setting. I'm just wondering if anybody has tried something similar and if they are any pratfalls I should know about. I'm also wondering what level everybody in my party should be at at certain milestones as far as magical equipment goes, presuming the default challenge rating.
Posted Nov 20, 2017, 3:42 AM UTC
You want to look at what Matt Mercer has done with the Taldorei (sp?) Campaign Guide and Critical Role. He has "vestiges " that level up when you want them to.
We've used these, and they are very good.
Is that open source work? Do you have a link?
Not open source sorry but maybe you can Google some of the items I.e. Fenthris, Whisper
*Fenthras
Nope. It's a campaign setting you can buy. It's absolutely worth buying it though. 4 subclasses, new feats, amazing magic items, and the world of Taldorei is fantastic.
You can find most of the information regarding this specific aspect of his campaign setting on the Critical Role Wiki under "Vestiges of Divergence", as it is information obtainable from the freely available web series anyway.
I've used them, or at least my own homebrew items using the same fundamental system, and they're very popular with the players. They're a fantastic way to encourage investment and roleplaying a character, because it gives the players a directly tangible reward for engaging with the lore of the item. Keep the ways to upgrade them mysterious, but related to the lore of the item so that the player's don't feel like it's just an arbitrary decision by the DM. E.g. A weapon with lore related to a specific god might 'upgrade' when the player becomes a follower of said god. The trick here is to find a balance between letting them feel rewarded if they choose to make mechanical choices for the sake of roleplaying (e.g. with the example above, if they decide to become a paladin or cleric of said god), but don't let them feel as though they're being forced to make decisions for the sake of roleplaying (i.e. dont let them think they HAVE to multiclass to get the item's benefits).
http://criticalrole.wikia.com/wiki/Vestiges_of_the_Divergence
this'll help you out, friend.
Get the book. It's more than worth it.
Tal'Dorei. 😉