Throwback to when we voted on the blowpipe thinking it would attack at 66% the speed it actually does

Posted Nov 21, 2017, 4:06 PM UTC

Posted Nov 21, 2017, 4:06 PM UTC
The blowpipe is now by far the best DPS on almost everything that doesn't have very high defence. You would need to wear a berserker ring (i) on about seven fingers in max strength to match its dps against a bloodveld.
I checked the dps of blowpipe + rigour in max range against max melee the other day. I found that if melee got a weapon with +120 attack and strength bonus with whip speed, their dps would roughly be the same against mid-level monsters.
Blowpipe is op as hell especially after rigour came out. And its roughly 400 times cheaper than twisted bow.
Edit: And because of blowpipe's fast speed, any new BiS ranged equipment (like Ava's assembler) would boost its dps even more compared to slower weapons.
Chaotic longsword had a strength bonus around that amount, BUT was slower. Yet chaotics are OP
Just sayin'
Chaotic longsword wasn't even BiS, the rapier was the best weapon.
Yeah. I just really liked the CLS and want it in game though. :/
No one is saying that CLS was op, it was clearly the rapier than was the primary offender
But since the bp attacks faster, even if on paper the dps is the same, bp will be better dps. This is because monsters dont have infinite hp. If you hit a monster down to below your max hit, you lose dps. This affects the bp left because the interval between hits is 2ticks compared to 4. If you hit it to 1hp, you fire again and you can hit the next mob in 2ticks. For a whip, youd be 4 ticks behind.
So we have to buff it even more then :)
What's even funnier is that the pipes dps is higher than the chaotic rapier AFTER you include turmoil AND overloads for the rapier, vs rigor and a range potion for pipe.
If you fire 13 million darts the cost in scales will equal a twisted bow.
Assuming you use dragon darts with ava's and rapid speed (1.2 sec), let's do some rough calculations on how long you have to use the blowpipe before the usage costs exceeds the price of twisted bow.
Dragon dart price: 2750 gp (1/5 of that is lost each attack = 550 gp)
Scale cost per attack: ~100 gp (current cost is close to 85 gp)
Cost per second: (550 + 100) / 1.2 = 540 gp per second
Twisted bow price: 1 000 000 000 gp
Time required to reach a cost of 1000m purely from scales and darts: 1 000 000 000 gp / 540 gp/sec = 510 hours of continious use of the blowpipe, or about 1.5m attacks.
The difference being that the cost of the blowpipe is lost permanently, while the twisted bow retains its value. Might as well say barrows gear is OP too because it's so much cheaper/easier to get than bandos yet gives nearly the same defence bonuses. The twisted bow IS better than the blowpipe in many bossing scenarios. Sure, the blowpipe is better if you're killing bloodvelds or something, but that's a huge sunken cost.
Nice
lol
Only 7?
I've seen this happen quite a few times, things get proposed a certain way then changed with the poll. In their defence though they have changed the way they handle these things by updating the dev blogs a couple of times before the polls come out now.
Its also best DPS on all the GWD bosses except armadyl (just because of chin expliot)
Better dps than max melee at Sara? Surely not unless you have a team all with DWH.
DWH specs don't matter anyway because of the superior accuracy in ranged gear. Here's some dps calcs against Zilyana, but of course you can discuss how viable it is to wear this gear against her anyway.
Blowpipe in max ranged vs. tent whip in max melee
Blowpipe in max ranged (including Ava's assember from Dragon Slayer 2) vs. tent whip in max melee
Thanks for taking time to reply with examples, difference in dps is quite a lot higher than I thought it would be as well.
who the hell uses max melee at sara lmao
I don't remember exactly but I think it had more DPS than Veracs but just by barely with just the 15% prayer. I can't check right now, but you can check Bitterkoekje's DPS calculator.
It is correct, just not clear. The Blowpipe is speed 3 on Accurate, but it fails to mention Rapid.
There is no reasonable way to assume they're comparing weapons with different attack speeds on different attack styles.
There kinda is. If I said "this dart is equal to a shortbow on rapid" without mentioning it had a rapid style, which would you assume? Probably that the dart is dart speed... So why would you have not considered that for a dart gun...
The OSRS Team did mess up with the wording, but so did the playerbase for not calling them out on it. If something is unclear in the Dev Blog, it is the community's job to raise the issue so it can be cleared up before the poll. If you just read that and assumed it was shortbow speed and didn't consider how vague that was, then you were part of the problem.
John C had compared it to darts in the official forums balancing post, and implied BP was going to be slower than darts/knives.
Then that is the part that was misleading, but it is what is in the Dev Blog and Poll that matters. If they say "we'll do X" and it isn't mentioned in the poll, they have no obligation to it if they forget since that isn't what was voted on. But if they don't do something as polled, they have to fix it to be what was voted on. So it could even be that John C wanted to make it slower but player voted on it being faster so they had to go with that.
Well if you consider that it being 2t would have made it almost 50% more dps then anything else at the time, you can't really blame them.
I remember Mod John C actually stating that it wouldn't be the best dps ranged weapon in the game, which is a complete lie. If it were the same speed as a shortbow, I think that may have been correct.
The way I (and probably many others) understood it was essentially
The attack speed of the blowpipe is 3 (equal to a shortbow) on rapid.
So I thought that the shortbow part was just clarifying what speed 3 means because not all players know that. I didn't think the text was vague at all, I just understood it incorrectly.
Understandable, but that is still partly on you and not just down to the wording. Speed 3 isn't the speed of a shortbow; it is the speed of darts or a shortbow on rapid. They really should have just said "dart speed", but I still find it surprising no one called them on the wording/speed because, for everyone who read it like you did, someone must have read it as it was intended.
There's a difference between a new tier of an existing style of ammo and a new piece of equipment to use the ammo. If they were strictly introducing a new tier of dart and used that wording, I would find it worth questioning the awkward wording which implies it would behave different than existing weaker variants. An entirely new weapon with which to fire existing ammo should not be assumed to behave the same as the thrown ammo it fires.
I am always careful to consider their notoriously unclear wording to make sure I understand the specifics, and ask for clarification if It seems ambiguous. This was a case of clear wording which didn't seem to require any scrutiny to me, much less a vast majority of voters.
Unclear wording that leads players to vote in changes they didn't specifically want defeats the practical purpose of polling the content in the first place. I don't think putting the blame on players for not being careful enough to make sure Jagex doesn't let that happen justifies the issue.
It doesn't justify the issue at all; it was still a mistake on Jagex's part. But the Dev Blogs are there for reasons like this. If players read it and go "looks good", the OSRS Team doesn't know there is a problem to address.
I didn't play osrs back then but im upset it doesn't look like a giant blunt like originally proposed
You mean a joint? Blunts are not white/beige.
(weed btw)
U can roll a blunt with white rizzla cant u or am I missing something
Blunts are normally made with (kinda?) the same leaves as cigars as rolling paper instead of ... literally rolling papers. AmsterdamIronman btw
In UK I hear blunt used for any kind of joint without tobacco
I looked up white rizla. Those are rolling papers. So they make joints.
ite idk the lingo
[deleted]
Classic blunts are generally made from Dutch master cigar leaves.
Ever listen to Wiz Khalifa? He is all about "not smoking blunts" as they are "less healthy" than just papers, as blunts are generally made with tobacco leaves.
Why is "less healthy" in quotations
they can be
[deleted]
What is the point of this comment
Well I played until EOC day then quit until like mid 2015
throwback to when the entirety of zulrah, its uniques, and venom were polled in a single question
they should remove venom tbh it's only been issues for this game, and it's been disabled in nearly every place where it was actually good. now it just fucks up PVP and forces everyone past 5 wildy to take anti-venom+ or a serp. completely retarded
They made it sound like antipoison would work va antivenom, just require two doses. Nowhere did they mention you would not get any immunity.
I honestly think the blowpipe should be nerfed. The only problem is that some things are balanced around it now...
Could you imagine the shitstorm that would surround a BP nerf?
i don't think a nerf has ever passed a poll. so it doesn't matter, as long as it helps the game in the long run.
NMZ/6 hour nerf is a good example.
No, it's absolutely clear from this how fast the BP is: as fast as the MSB on rapid. Then the BP on rapid is 1 faster, because that's how rapid works.
This should be surprising to nobody.
Problem is a lot of ppl understood it as:
Its on rapid as fast as msb on rapid.
But oh well, I thought common balancing knowlage with the jmods was a thing back then.
So I just assumed that we go from MSB(49 range str, 1.8s/hit) with max hit 29 to 32, but they acctually did from knifes(24 range str, 1.2s/hit which already were best dps against 0 def monsters/pures) with max 22 to 32. (Blowpipe has 60range str with dragon darts)
It was just unrealistic to think that they are acctually talking about a range wep with 50% more dps against low def targets, thats not something somone would do.
There was no uproar against it before the dev stream when everyone realized how op it would be.
They nerfed it by 50% for pvp because they realized how hard they fucked up.
pvp
here's a little taste of what void range was doing to pures on blowpipe release for anyone who wasn't around. exactly what it still does to low def monsters lmfao.
how did this thing get into the game.
Sorry but that video is post nerf judging by the speed of it
This is after nerf.
This is pre nerf: https://youtu.be/Hsec8txWBJ0
TBow and Blowpipe changed this game so fucking much and people complain about Chatoics+Turmoil lmfao
Because without comparison some people have a hard time judging things. People can look back to rs2 and see how busted turm + chaotics were or they can look at twisted bow/blowpipe and think "Oh hey lets not do that for melee".
Id be completely down for a blowpipe/twised bow nerf but the community would never pass it and Jagex doesn't have the balls/brains to nerf anything that this sub doesn't have an autistic fit over i.e. Zulrah drop table.
yep but now there is no future fr ranged weapons anymore. Cant make anything more powerful than BP/TBow llol
i don't even think tbow is that completely broken anymore (in comparison to blowpipe), especially since they've tweaked a few boss magic levels here and there. i think the bolts buff coming is going to make acb not much worse overall, especially if the ones that work on tzhaars work on zucc.
though, it's still the best bow for bossing, and it shouldn't ever not be. raids is too much content to kill over one twisty boi.
stuff like diamond bolts getting a huge damage increase is gonna change a lot of things. hell i reckon they'll be used more in pking than dragon dbolts, just cause super-antifires will be a thing, and tank gear (like that retarded 8m shield that's basically 2 dfs' bonuses) is kind of really good these days.
Staff of the Dead's melee attack is also 1 tick faster than it's supposed to be.
All rewards associated with the Zulrah update were (and still are) OP as hell.
The blowpipe is the same speed as a magic shortbow in pvp atleast.
On release it was 2 ticks in pvp as well. They nerfed it in a hotfix 4 days later because it was incredibly broken anywhere below 70 defence.
It was nerfed the same day iirc. I remember watching some void pure pk with it, it was incredibly strong.
I think 4 days later is correct, there were not too many blowpipes and they were going for around 50m per blowpipe.
Against a 1 def pure it was as good as a dds with infinite spec. (Dds kn that cb bracket hits a max of around 32-32(No bring (i) glory for accuracy) every 4 ticks while blowpipe maxes 32 every 2 ticks.)
That was my introduction to staking. Rip my first 7m
Blowpipe is seriously the most OP thing in osrs. Largely in part because it's such an inexpensive weapon for how stupidly powerful it is.
Yep mod ash on the official forums post did a really bad job answering questions about that.
Clearly john c and hoever did the actual coding had different thoughts on BP.
are u making a weekly edition of jagex lying or fucking up on their dev blog
Just to consider:
Balista was never polled because it would not be BIS for anything (Heavy has 15 range str more than handcannon) its really strong in PVP even after the nerfs they did.
I want that look of the blowpipe, so stop bitching because you can't always get what you want.
misleading at least.
ranged weaps speed is based on speed on accurate. the rapid style is +1 speed.
if it attacked at the speed of a shortbow, it would match the ticks on all styles. Your logic is pretty flawed, why would they advertise the accurate mode speed when they know all range weapons are used on rapid while also comparing it to the rapid speed of a currently existing weapon.
All range weapons are listed by speed on accurate though.
My logic is fine, the dev blog is intentionally misleading
His logic is fine. They say the speed of the weapon and compare it to commonly used weapon to give example. I was little bit surprised that this was misleading tho.