Belgium says loot boxes are gambling, wants them banned in Europe
pcgamer.com/belgium-says-loot-boxes-are-gambl...Posted Nov 21, 2017, 11:40 PM UTC
Posted Nov 21, 2017, 11:40 PM UTC
Damn, i am glad they came to this conclusion. now lets see what effects it has on the industry
[deleted]
Wtf r u talking about a bunch of states have anti gambling laws
I doubt that not going by the below, seems real change is coming
We shall see. I doubt it would happen here in the states though.
Yeah but the states are the states, we're talking about Europe
Drugs could generate billions of dollars of tax money but they are illegal.
[deleted]
Hopefully this is a domino effect and other govs follow suit.
So Overwatch just makes loot boxes impossible to purchase in Europe? Don't know what changes Battlefront will need but that seems like an easy fix
They can just sell the individual items in the marketplace, completely removing it would eliminate a big chunk of market-money, and since Belgium's only pushing for a loot box ban, and not a microtransaction ban, it'd be legal.
They'd just sell Credits I guess
They're specifically targetting the Star Wars game which has already used that loophole ("oh, you can't actually buy loot boxes see? You buy credits and then spend credits on loot boxes. Totally different!")
The legislators will hopefully account for that loophole then, with language that bans directly OR INDIRECTLY exchanging USD for a random chance at something.
Then overwatch and everyone else would hopefully drop their loot box systems in europe, and hopefully everywhere else as well. Once people see how much better the Europeans have it being able to directly buy what they want, ideally they would insist on getting treated fairly. Kind of like how European consumer protection benefited the whole world despite only having jurisdiction in the EU.
I think his point was overwatch would sell credits for money, which you then use to buy certain skins dirrectly.
If they ban it, will games like OW be completely banned? Cuz i still want to play it
They will probably remove gambling aspect of lootboxes (paying for them) and you will get them for free when you win a game or something like that.
Sounds good!
In addition they will probably add a way to directly buy the currency that you currently get from lootboxes and duplicates.
As honest message, because I got to the article via facebook link of pc gamer. That is still the same link, reddit link detection didn't recognize it is a article already posted on the subreddit, with a direct link to it.
Good, hopefully this sets some variety of precedent.
He wants the lootboxes banned? Or the games that include lootboxes themselves?
EU has sadly hands full with the Batshit crazy Brits maybe end this year when the biggest question is cleared we can push it to the comission
I don't think banning loot boxes outright is a good thing or the right way to go here.
Just slap an M rating on the games, or (and) have a big thing on the front of the cover that says that the game includes gambling.
Banning lootboxes is one thing, but if we allow them to this, then the government has put their noses into our games. Will it stop here? or will it become a case of
Violence against women? BANNED
Killing arabs? BANNED
Gay person dies in game? BANNED
I'd rather governments not poke around in our games. Leaving games to their own vices would be a far better thing to do than restrict the creative freedom of developers.
Just my two cents.
Edit: well it would seem people do not agree with me. Anyone care to elaborate why. I simply prefer governments not stick their noses into our games, as much as i oppose the lootboxes and pay2win etc.
The rating system is not a government organisation, this is the case for US and the EU.
And banning like that has been done before. See Germany with any game with nazi stuff in or Australia with GTA5.
See Germany with any game with nazi stuff in
Actually having Nazi stuff in video games is technically not illegal anymore in Germany (and never has been), according to many German lawyers, experts and politicians. Censoring video games (in Germany finally a cultural good worth protecting) is violating the german media basic law which states that such censorship is illegal.
The only thing holding Germany back right now is an old court order which says that it is illegal to include Nazi stuff, but as soon as that court order is declared invalid all the uncensored stuff can be sold in Germany. Now Germany only needs a brave person/company that asks for this court order to be declared invalid. Hmm... let‘s wait and see if someone in 2018 will do it.
[removed]
Indeed. I'm not in favour of that either.
A tax-paying legit gambling industry does exist: they face laws and deep restrictions.
You wouldn't see slot machines in Disney World's Star Wars segment... not any children there anyway.
So, why should EA being so special over other companies in gambling?
Oh man if they actually do have to start following gambling restrictions I wonder how many companies will follow the true essence of gambling and have lootboxes that give nothing. This should encourage more spending.
Let's be real kids buying loot boxes isn't the problem, but if they classify loot boxes as gambling and they are regulated on it I see no reason for them to not go all out. Might even make more money on the big spenders that have a real addiction.
Let's be real kids buying loot boxes isn't the problem, but if they classify loot boxes as gambling and they are regulated on it I see no reason for them to not go all out. Might even make more money on the big spenders that have a real addiction.
This only depend on the way your lawmaker operate.
If you think they do shitty job... they'll do it anyway: as voting citizen you're mostly to be blamed for it.
It looks like Belgium got good representative who concern seriously the law- making stuff. You assume just your politician are idiots... while in truth, the real idiots is the people who send them in office.
I am from Italy, and I know the problem in my country is not just the crappy people in the government: but the number of people (non-voters and "don't care" mostly) who are indirectly supporting that crappy people in government.
The correct definition for "idiot" comes from politics: ancient Athens at the very beginning of the Democracy.
http://www.historydisclosure.com/what-does-idiot-mean/
The "don't regulate" BS basically is like a politician say to citizen: - hey! you know how much shitty job we make, eh? so... let's us do not any job until any big company pay us big money to sell your freedom away
here's gone your Net Neutrality as well.
Not saying they should be special. I'm just saying loot boxes shouln'd be banned. They should follow all other rules and regulations that come with having a gambling mechanic in their games.
Translation of the article is correct.
Source: I'm Belgian.
^^^^^But ^^^^^how ^^^^^can ^^^^^I ^^^^^trust ^^^^^you?
Jk, thanks for the info!
To verify that you're Belgian.. In what glass would you drink a Duvel?
A Duvel glas
Disrupts the taste of the beer if drunk from another. Heeft ne goeie kraag nodig, of het is geen deftige Duvel.
Can confirm u/Meakis is Belgian