Mutual Credit and Inflation?
Hey, was just wondering if I had some substantial misunderstanding re. how interest free banking operates.
So, suppose credit is furnished at cost to be repaid one year later, and inflation is 3% per year. In order to recoup buying power, doesn't the lender need to factor inflation into the price of credit? Doesn't this mean that interest has to be set at just above 3% to fully compensate the lender, ie. not at 1% or below?
Posted Nov 22, 2017, 5:36 AM UTC
If steady inflation is a characteristic of the economy in general, then it will be a cost of doing business. "Free credit" on the mutualist model means cost-price credit and the 1% figure often thrown around is based on the ability of particular mutual credit systems to reduce factors like risk that would increase costs.
I'm not sure why a mutualist society would experience steady inflation, particularly if mutual currencies were used for capital improvement and those currencies were adequately backed by assets. A circulation-centric economy and secured-credit currency don't seem particularly prone to structural inflation.
what about a change in population? If China adopts a mutualist model of inflation (New_Debt=Old_Debt) , their one-child policy vs India, for example, would change the relationship between India-China and how their new, higher population change the circulation?
Wouldn't you need more inflation to give the next group of adherents more to play with?
I’m not sure what a “mutualist model of inflation” is supposed to be. But if a change in population increased demand for the sorts of assets generally used to secure mutual credit, isn’t the effect with regard to the price of other goods in relation to the potential supply of mutual currency actually likely to be deflationary? The overall structural effect is probably not something we can say much about without specifying a great deal about property conventions, available resources, etc., but I don’t see a reason to think that steady inflation would be likely.
yes, especially when coins are lost in underwater caves and bills are used as firewood.
Me neither, but my perspective is "If no debt is forgave from yesterdays_generation until today", any credit associated with that debt would be impacted by population size and debt commitment, that would be "non-inflationary". No net new money, nor net new assets.
A bank vaults door is a heavy hunk of metal. As this metal's scarcity increases due to demand of heavier bank vault doors (on a commercial market), this would render fewer currencies-to-bank doors; ratio, yes. Especially when currencies are mined, printed, or otherwise have a higher rate of input to bank_door_producing output.
But I think it is important to remember that supply (bank_doors_per_currency) and demand (fear_of_thievery_amongst_bank_door_early_adopters) still need people to talk to each other. Friendly (golden rule) conversation about the currency buying power can be given context, as opposed to the credit-purchasing of that currency. (Buying bonds and shares of debt instead of productive goods' factory repair).