Socialism in a nutshell

Posted Nov 22, 2017, 2:53 PM UTC

Posted Nov 22, 2017, 2:53 PM UTC
Normally I hate these, but this one is decent. It actually sounds like the effects of the "Gilded Age" which reddit seems to so proudly love pointing at (over the last two days) as an example of why we need government-regulated NN.
deleted ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^0.0694 ^^^What ^^^is ^^^this?
I also find it sort of strange that so many people are advocating regulation based on fear of extreme outcomes which have yet to be realized.
Political philosophies aside... doesn't it make sense to at least wait and see if those things happen and then regulate them? Rather than batch regulating based on fear???
Everyone wants government solutions now, because apparently citizens are less trustworthy than the people they chose.
But without sarcasm: most people who are vocal seem to just want the government to make sure their idealized status quo stays, even at the cost of freedom and a better standard that may emerge.
Textbook manipulation. Wave a fear of actions from some boogeyman (corporations) in people's faces enough, and they'll believe it. Just like how a good portion of the country believes that letting muslims travel to the US will cause mass terrorist attacks. Our friends from across the ideological pond have fallen for similar fear tactics.
The US government invaded Iraq on a totally fake premise after whipping the country into a hysteria about weapons of mass destruction.
In fact, it nearly destroyed the world and wasted what must have been trillions of 2017 dollars over the myth that that Soviet Union would militarily invade Western Europe, something that we now know the USSR had zero intention of ever doing.
Scaring kids about Comcast slowing their Netflix streams down in order to build up the FCC’s powers is a relatively minor and easy trick in comparison.
Yup, sounds about right.
Is there any proof that raising the minimum wage increases unemployment and prices? I know it seems intuitive, but Seattle and other $15/hour locations seem to be proving the opposite. Once employees actually have some money to spend, businesses begin booming and unemployment declines - at least in the studies I've seen.
Please - anyone - prove me wrong rather than blindly downvoting.
The economy is so complex that it's very difficult to "prove" anything. But if you want a book length review of the evidence from a reputable source, check this out:
https://mitpress.mit.edu/books/minimum-wages
"Based on their comprehensive reading of the evidence, Neumark and Wascher argue that minimum wages do not achieve the main goals set forth by their supporters. They reduce employment opportunities for less-skilled workers and tend to reduce their earnings; they are not an effective means of reducing poverty; and they appear to have adverse longer-term effects on wages and earnings, in part by reducing the acquisition of human capital. The authors argue that policymakers should instead look for other tools to raise the wages of low-skill workers and to provide poor families with an acceptable standard of living."
That's in a city with extremely high cost of living.
Imagine a 15 dollar min wage in the middle of Kansas.
I didn't mean to imply that $15/hour is the "right" number, or even that there is a "right" number for every location. I just want to find some proof for the theory that raising the minimum wage inevitably leads to increased unemployment and/or prices - if that proof exists at all.
If the minimum wage is raised, but still set to below the market-agreed-upon price for wages, then there will be little to no effect. If, however, it is set to above the market price, it is then you will see unemployment/prices go up.
As of right now in the US, less than 2% of workers actually make minimum wage, because the market has determined a price for wages higher than that. But if the federal minimum wage jumped from 7.25 to 15.00/hr you would definitely see the effect.
This.
To add an anecdote. Years ago, I was at a drive-through and noticed they had a help wanted sign up, for $8 and hour. The radio had news of a motion in Congress to increase the minimum wage to $7.25 or something. I just shook my head thinking it was just another useless feel-good measure to win votes by showing that the politicos "care".
i mean take basic principles of business decisions into account:
cost to produce consumer goods rises with wage hike. what company would rationally eat this cost at the expense of profit margins?
http://lmgtfy.com/?q=wage+hikes+in+seattle
first article explains that a University of Washington study found that low wage workers were earning ~100 dollars less per month.
The times where it has a apparent positive affect could be compared to cemo treating cancer. A city's economy is FBAR to the point where wages are being kept artificially low thus raising the minimum wage becomes a fix where otherwise it would be a bad thing.
Dude I just moved to this area. $975k for a 4bdr house? Cost of everything is 30% higher than the state I came from (except housing where it's 300%). $15 for minimum wage isn't helping them. Real estate costs are crushing everyone but the few who bank, economy is good here, but there's lots of vendors are bringing in foreign coders on a tourist visa, paying them shit, keeping them in company apartments, and rotating them every 2 months, which is doing wonders for the qualified local talent. The sales tax is fucking retarded. Double most places. Seattle is like San Francisco North. If you're not making 100k you're poor. Same thing with NY.
Edit: k
$975 for a 4 bedroom? Are you missing a 0 in there somewhere?
I think he means $975k?
Correct
Is there any proof that raising the minimum wage increases unemployment and prices?
There's countless amounts of proof that increasing the cost of something reduces the demand for it. If you want to say that labour is somehow DIFFERENT from any other good in that respect, you're going to need some good solid evidence.
www.en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Veblen_good
You're not wrong about labor though.
Even if it didn't create unemployment in the first place, you shouldn't restrict my right to accept a trade with an employer. You are not in this trade, I am.
If I want to work for 2 dollars per hour of work and work 3 hours a day 6 days a week, you shouldn't be able to take this right from me as long as there's at least one other person willing to accept to trade with me. I'd be earning 36 dollars a week from this trade, yes. It doesn't have anything to do with my ability to live or the number of other trades I have made. I have my reasons to accept this trade and you even have no right to force me to tell you these reasons.
A bit of authoritarianism is the best way to more authoritarianism.
I'm too lazy to find it, but in Seattle raising the minimum wage to $15 an hour actually led to a overall pay decrease of something like $90 per paycheck for minimum $15 earners.
No one really disputes that the effect of minimum wage hikes is unemployment. But there is a lot of debate about how fast this change happens as a result of how fast you implement the changes.
For example: many states and cities around the country have experimented with raising the wage slowly to try to give the market time to equalize in other way instead of unemployment. The results seem to be that if you do it slowly enough, employment may remain more stable and the added costs are instead eaten by allocating funds elsewhere.
Another way to think about this is that maybe the market responds to changes in the minimum wage relative to the current equilibrium of the market.
In the end I personally think if the only solution is to move the wages as slowly as possible while letting the market equalize, why not just let the market equalize naturally rather than forcing an economic reallocation that is suboptimal elsewhere?
Did you not hear about the scandal of the former Seattle mayor going to another source of data (Berkeley) after the initial data from the UW didn't say what they wanted it to say about the increase?
http://www.dailywire.com/news/19231/busted-seattle-mayor-caught-colluding-squash-james-barrett
http://www.seattleweekly.com/news/seattle-is-getting-an-object-lesson-in-weaponized-data/
Different areas will have different tolerances for price increases depending on the wealth of the area.
This is why an increase in the minimum wage in one area can completely destroy the economy & in another area have no effect at all.
There's an excellent study out of the University of Washington that proved just that. Seattle's minimum wage increase caused low-wage workers to lose so many hours of work, they actually earned less money in total because of the change. You can listen to an interview with one of the authors here.
I'm upvoting you because of all the great replies. People should see the evidence and understand the reasoning.
This post is a thing of beauty.
Oh god this is some good shit right there
Gosh, these jpeg artifacts are killing my eyes!
Nothing to do with anarcho-communism whatsoever.
Ye wtf when has anyone heard of anarcho communists wanting a government or hating capitalism solely on 'inequality'
Nice work!
best meme in a while