r/Sophist•
Morble

Iconoclasm in Richard Kelly's Donnie Darko (2001)

There's been a long standing debate over what Richard Kelly's 2001 film, Donnie Darko, was really about. Was it the supernatural story of a person learning that they could travel through time, or did it instead document the nervous breakdown of someone with a developing schizophrenic disorder? While either of these interpretations have their own merits, it's worth considering that the answer to this question may, ultimately, be neither.

Now, there's no question that a claim is being made that time travelling is possible within the universe this movie takes place in, but just as Ridley Scott's Bladerunner wasn't about interplanetary travel, nor Neil Bomkampff's District 9 about self-levitating space crafts, there needs to be some recognition that just because a fictitious element exists as a conceit to a movie's plot, doesn't mean it holds dominant thematic significance in a story. In both of the aforementioned examples, those conceits are significant because they exist in service to a greater theme. In Bladerunner, space travel served primarily as a vehicle to explore themes of segregating and marginalizing Replicants, where the hovering spaceship in District 9 served as the unexpected beacon of hope against hatred, alienation, and systematic prejudice.

There remains the question here of how to distinguish when a major fictitious conceit of a movie is the theme, and when it's simply used as a plot device to explore other, more dominant ideas in the movie. There is certainly an argument to be made here that in those previously mentioned examples, although the specific plot devices mentioned wouldn't be considered the dominant themes or plot contributors, the science-fiction premise, in either of these cases, was. One might even go further and say that there is a difference between outlining major elements that comprise a plot, and those that contribute to a theme. With this in mind, however, consider the following simple question; what was the plot to Donnie Darko?

If it's been years since you've seen it, it might be easy to patch together a sort of hodgepodge of scenes, from when Donnie sleepwalks into Frank, who gives him a date for the end of the world, to stumbling across Roberta Sparrow and later discovering her book, The Philosophy of Time Travel and her letter, addressed to him, all the way through the discovery of astrally projected wormholes and a conclusion that revealed Frank's identity while hurdling Donnie through time. It's worth noting here, however, that this reading arguably neglects half of the story. Multiple scenes are devoted specifically to focusing on Graham Green, the content and controversy of his writings; the self-help philosophy based on a dichotomous view of fear and love not only features prominently, but so too do the character arcs of the people promoting it; the bullying between students, the dishonest behaviour of people in positions of authority, and acts of vandalism all take up significant focus in the plot.

So what was it all about? In the words of Donnie himself, "They just want to see what happens when they tear the world apart. They want to change things." Donnie Darko is a film about iconoclasm.

Posted Nov 23, 2017, 2:20 AM UTC · edited

10
rflyers•

This is amazing man, I've been fascinated by this film ever since I came across it, and after all these years I think you have gotten the closest to the true meaning of this masterpiece. It actually makes me treasure it even more, I think iconoclasm being the main theme gives it a lot more substance than the time travel theory. Great post in /truefilm as well.

2
MorbleOP•

Haha, hey man, I'm glad you enjoyed it. This is just a work in progress (using my own sub to kind of edit it over time; I didn't expect any visitors). I still actually have so much to say about the movie that it's kind of a daunting task, but I'm really happy to get that positive feedback. Reminds and motivates me to keep going.

Obviously, I agree with you that this is really a cinematic masterpiece. There's just so much going on in the story beyond time travel, I feel like it's kind of a shame that most people seem to stop analysis at a dichotomous comparison of this film as either being about time travel or mental health; whether, basically, to accept the fictitious conceit of the film or not, and there's so much to look at beyond this question.

2