Triple Threat Series:Archer Comment below who you think walks away the Winner
Posted Nov 27, 2017, 10:58 PM UTC
3577
Nobu, cause pure unadulterated badass
18
If it's simply a contest of "badass," Archer!Nobu gets unceremoniously mauled to death by Agrius Metamorphosis Nyanta.
7
Don't forget that Nobu's Tenka Fubu skill has an Anti- Mystery attribute which would probably be strong against Nyanta who probably has heavier mystery due to being from the Age of Gods. The mystery part is mentioned in Koha Ace EX.
2
I'm pretty sure it's not a Black Barrel effect that would cause Nyanta to die from her own Mystery. It's more like using an Olympic swimming pool instead of a thimble when trying to empty the Atlantic Ocean. Far more effective than normal but still ultimately useless.
0
It isn't an absolute advantage, right, but the difference between them to begin with isn't nearly that big, Nobu has a ton more firepower, and her Papiyas Noble Phantasm would definitely roast Atalante alive.
2
Nobu will always be my fave but I actually don't know who that is, can you link me info about her?
1
Agrius Metamorphosis It's this Noble Phantasm that seals her bow in exchange for higher stats and puts her in a semi-Berserker state.
6
This should have been her Berserker Archer form, DW!
2
Arigato
1
Atalanta with Agility:A without using Arcadia or that pelt NP which raises almost all her parameters and gives her lifesteal. Lowest endurance.
Chloe with Agility:B but with eye of the mind:false B.
Nobu with Agility:C but with better str, endurance and luck than other two.
I think Atalanta could survive the other two if she doesn't fight them head on like in apocrypha. She's extremely hard to match in speed and will become even more dangerous to survive against should she use the pelt. Downside in using the pelt is her weapon is sealed and she gains Madness Enhancement A which turns off reason and she's then reliant on primal instinct.
Eye of the mind can let Chloe see what's coming, but she isn't necessarily going to be able to properly react in time. While she can create some fake NPs, those do cost mana and would be hard to aim against Atalanta and lowered in effectiveness against Nobu.
Nobu's a strategist, but to strategize properly, she needs information to prepare beforehand. She does have Tenka, and 2 NPs, all 3 becoming increasingly effective against things with higher divinity or mystery(basically from older times or just older).
How I see it unfolding.
Whichever servant is engaged with Nobu in battle will lose to the other one due to a long range nuke. Nobu has no real defenses or speed boosts to speak of and the other two are faster. Chloe can craft fake NPs for emergency purposes. Atalanta is basically untouchable without NP usage but Chloe does seem young enough so I'm going to have to give this one to Chloe.
1
I mean just look at that art, thats the face of someone who will not only kill you, but is probably bored doing it just because her enemy is so weak
6
She don't give a shit bout yo children
2
You think she would go for the kill right away?
2
Hell yea
1
She would probably try to recruit them, but the minute they challenge her...
3
Pure Archery/ Distant fight : Atalanta by a mile
Medium combat : Nobu with her rifle barrage
Close combat : Kuro
Waifu : Atalanta
17
You've got good taste, friend
3
Hm never knew Atalanta was that deadly Any chance Nobu would be able to get her into a mid rage fight or would Atalanta be moving around to much
2
Atalanta has outstanding tracking abilities, the smell of guwpoder will be easy to find and keep distance. Not even taking in account her insane speed that match even Achilles speed (without his NP "Comet Form" activated) to keep said distance.
5
Well color me impressed! Here I am thinking i picked “even” servants to brawl I guess it fits her character for being a humanoid cat
1
Atalanta can cloak her presence while she's in the forest quite easily and has incredible long range accuracy. If the enemies are just dots, she can still hit them.
2
So in short she moves on to the next round lol
1
One is a kid and another has a big advantage against Mystery, so Atalante has terrible compatibility. Either she goes down without putting up much of a fight or she makes herself an extra big target with the boarskin.
Chloe is an inferior copy of a lackluster Servant. She has the advantage in melee, but these are Archers, and melee is not their strong point.
Nobu has the definitive advantage with a huge amount of firepower thanks to the fact that she doesn't have to manually attack, she can just have a full battery of guns go off behind her. On top of that she has the Papiyas, which doesn't actually do anything to Chloe, but it tears Atalante apart and she is a bigger threat anyways.
15
Love seeing actual breakdowns of how things would go down!
Any chance Atalanta goes easy on Chloe since she is a kid?
Lol are you not a fan of Emyia and Chloe?
2
Atalante absolutely goes easy on Chloe. If she didn't I'd put her at an easy second place, but her versus a kid would never go well.
I'm not a fan of either, but I'm not factoring that into the match-up. The fact of the matter is just that Emiya is simply not very good, and Chloe is just a weaker Emiya. Emiya has lacking abilities and one skill that is troublesome at best for other Servants that aren't Berserker Herc or Gil, but uses his brain to tangle with stronger Servants. Nobu is not an exceptionally strong one, but she still has overwhelming firepower. Especially if we are considering Koha-Ace Nobu, who is a fair bit stronger than Grand Order's version.
5
To be fair to Emiya when he's being serious and acting as an Archer instead of going for melee he can defeat high tier servants like Artoria via sniping with his NP's and Eye of The Mind. He isn't killing Godly tier people like Herc and Karna or people he has bad compatibility with like Cu and his Protection from Arrows skill but Godly tier is busted for a reason and bad compatibility kills everything in Fate see Gil vs Herc or Shirou vs Gil. The sheer number of options he has to attack while remaining a safe distance and having Eye of The Mind helping him counter enemy moves makes him very dangerous so calling him lackluster would be down playing him.
Agree with your other points though Chloe is just a weaker version of him and lacks the tactical mind to use her skills to the effect Emiya does while the other two are just plain better then her (even if Atalante would never go all out on a child)
4
I just want to point out that Emiya has an advantage against servants similar to the one that Gil has: he can pretty much counter all of them. He has access to an effectively infinite number of nps. Even if they have downgraded he probably has something good for the situation. He has also literally killed Herc, multiple times. By virtue of being a CG, he likely has more combat experience than most servants too. He wouldn't have an easy time facing a godly servant, but he can fight just about anyone and always has a chance at winning.
A side note about him frequently sword fighting his opponents: the biggest fights he has in UBW are against Medea and Chu Chu. Medea is probably much more comfortable in a ranged fight than in cqc and Chu chu is basically immune to ranged attacks (besides magic). He probably fought them in the best way possible.
2
Hm I can see where ur coming from Chloe for me is just an excuse to had the true Loli option which is a Waifu type in very sketchy with..
1
Well the one in the middle she can jail the other two.
11
Kuro obviously. She's a loli. And everyone knows that in anime lolis are the strongest.
9
To be fair Nobu is kinda a loli and she is chuunibyou as FUUUUUU---- so she gets extra points
5
Trick question: Robin already poisoned them all.
5
Nyanta because waifu
4
kuro because she would just teleport behind them, kiss them and then have the cops take them away along with us.
but my serious answer is actually would be kuro as Atalanta cant kill her because of her wish to save all children including servants and nobu has bad compatibility with kuro who lacks riding, divinity or even a legend meaning her attacks wont do much.
3
Kuro has B-rank Protagonist skill just under Illya for a good bit of their series. That's more than enough to win against Atalantae's no-child-left-behind policies and the lack of an advantage for Nobu to exploit.
3
Alright Lads Same rules as last time explain why you think any of these 3 would walk away the Champion Explain it anyway you desire
2
The one in the middle. Atlante will go easy on her because she's a kid. Nobu will self destruct somewhere in the fight due to her own disappointing nature.
2
You think so? I figured with Atlanta there she would be Going in for the kill
1
Nah, she likes to act all tough but has a huge soft spots for kids. Also Kuro would totally play the party of cute innocent girl to lower her guard.
1
Kuro because shes the sexiest and the coolest
If we had to play this serious lame, I would say
Nobu would win since Nobu has Tenka Fubu which will murder Atalanta and potentially Kuro because of their amount of Mystery
2
Nobbu! Sandanuchi ftw
2
Haha surprise Okita-San
2
Reminder that Kuro gets beaten by a regular adult with a Dojo, who in turn got beaten by Lluvia and one of Illya's elementary school girl friends.
2
Poor Atalanta is in a terrible position. Nobu has a natural advantage against her, and she'll likely go easy on Kuro who I doubt has any problem with using that to her own advantage. As for Nobu vs Kuro, the latter is fairly powerful, but so is Nobu and Kuro lacks the combat experience to make full use of Emiya's abilities.
2
So Nobu would walk away with a fluke win?
1
I wouldn't call it a fluke so much as this match being stacked in her favor
2
Senpai! It seems you've forgotten to properly flair your post, but this kouhai will gladly do it for you. Simply reply to my comment with one of these flairs and I'll change it myself. Just put the flair title inside brackets, like so '[Fluff]'.
1
[Fluff]
1
I've done as you've asked, Senpai. Please remember to flair next time, unless you're a mobile user. Please continue to request my assistance in the future if that is the case.
Fluff
1
Nobu. Now excuse me while I try to stack the odds in her favor...
1
Kuro just because she did lewd things with her tongue.
1
do you have source for the Atalanta pic?
1
Not at this moment but I think I can try to DM you the pic If that would help
1
please do!
2
So tried sending it in the PM didn’t work lol Gonna post it has a a regular post Tell me once u got it
1
In the middle, the one behind the little girl.
. . . I just finish my UBW reread and I come and see this comment. Bravo.
Unfortunately he is only spectating
Idk man. Actually satan can use his Hell NP
sadly based on the title its an archer only fight no sabers allowed
THERE ARE SEVERAL WRONG THINGS WRONG WITH THAT - Actually Satan
Shut up Loosey-Goosey.
BAH GAWD WHAT IS EMIYA DOING HERE?!
TRIPLE THREATS ARE NO DQ SO ANYTHING GOES!
You don’t know how happy you just made me!
Now I need to see Emyia run in with a chair and start whacking people!
I mean, he can probably project it... That'd be interesting. lol
That's my answer too.