Shackles or Shard
What is better to add, Vedalken Shackles or Crystal Shard?
Posted Nov 30, 2017, 12:14 PM UTC
What is better to add, Vedalken Shackles or Crystal Shard?
Posted Nov 30, 2017, 12:14 PM UTC
Really depends on the environment you're running.
Shackles is great, of course. If you've got some support for Shackles, the card's bonkers (Control Magic effects are in general).
Shard's utility is much broader. A lot of creatures in Cube have great ETB effects; this holds true for your and your opponents creatures, so keep that in mind. However, a t4 Shard and bouncing your opponents creature while they're tapped out is quite backbreaking.
If you support something that resembles a blink archetype (which is pretty hard to avoid in Cube with staples like Mulldrifter and Blade Splicer among many others), you can safely run Shard.
Personally I really like shard, for the simple fact it makes games interesting and will surprise you in the different ways it can be utilized. Shackles is much more straightforward.
All in all I'd say Shackles is 'better' (again, highly dependent).
Shackles based on raw power alone. Would try and run both if you could though.
Shackles is pants-on-head levels of powerful.
Crystal Shard is a great way to have fun while losing.
Hahaha, well said
Shackles is stronger alone and much more groany, shard is stronger with synergy and more fun in general I think
I haven’t played with Shackles, but Shard is a very high pick in my unpowered cube. With [[Venser, Shaper Savant]], [[Shriekmaw]] (bounce with the sac trigger on the stack), [[Mulldrifter]], and even janky stuff like [[Whirler Rogue]], shard wins games. It can also really slow down your opponent with only the threat of activation.
Whenever I see Shackles in a list I just assume the cube curator hates aggro. Card is oppressive.
Old Man of the Sea or bust.
There is no relativity here, shackles is a first pick in any cube in which it appears.
Shard is not
I run both but if you only pick one then it is simple
shackles is a first pick in any cube in which it appears
That is a mighty bold statement
haha, it is def first pick. not the first pick against a lotus, mox, jace hand. but it is not the worst first pick either
IMO, Crystal Shard is too slow and cute for a high powered cube now a days.
Shackles is still very powerful no matter the list.
I'll add to this that having fixing with basic subtypes helps quite a bit. For example, running Shackles in a UB Control list with Underground Sea and Watery Grave is far better than if you had it in a list with Drowned Catacomb and Choked Estuary instead.